| 1 | Asher GarodnickPlace 1 · Grade 9 · Trinity School | 9 | Trinity School | 9:04.2 |
| 2 | Jude WalshPlace 2 · Grade 9 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 9 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 9:18.8 PR |
| 3 | Massimo YeungPlace 3 · Grade 10 · Poly Prep Country Day | 10 | Poly Prep Country Day | 9:23.8 PR |
| 4 | Alexander SpencerPlace 4 · Grade 9 · Trinity School | 9 | Trinity School | 9:25.4 |
| 5 | Hart HicksPlace 5 · Grade 10 · Poly Prep Country Day | 10 | Poly Prep Country Day | 9:28.0 |
| 6 | Wes GoldringPlace 6 · Grade 9 · Trinity School | 9 | Trinity School | 9:28.8 |
| 7 | Ali KhrosrowshahiPlace 7 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 9:34.3 |
| 8 | Wyatt TsePlace 8 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 9:36.9 |
| 9 | Williem HaleyPlace 9 · Grade 9 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 9 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 9:43.8 PR |
| 10 | Sachin LuftPlace 10 · Grade 10 · Trinity School | 10 | Trinity School | 9:46.1 |
| 11 | Declan DaileaderPlace 11 · Grade 11 · Collegiate | 11 | Collegiate | 9:47.4 |
| 12 | Wynton CapellanPlace 12 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 10:11.0 |
| 13 | Teddy GibsonPlace 13 · Grade 9 · Dalton | 9 | Dalton | 10:15.2 |
| 14 | Pablo BordesPlace 14 · Grade 9 · Trinity School | 9 | Trinity School | 10:16.8 PR |
| 15 | Andrew WebsterPlace 15 · Grade 9 · Green Meadow Waldorf | 9 | Green Meadow Waldorf | 10:17.1 PR |
| 16 | Roshan KrishnamurthyPlace 16 · Grade 12 · Collegiate | 12 | Collegiate | 10:17.5 |
| 17 | Sal SchafferPlace 17 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 10:26.4 |
| 18 | Noah CampbellPlace 18 · Grade 12 · Collegiate | 12 | Collegiate | 10:27.4 |
| 19 | Dagan RosenblattPlace 19 · Grade 9 · Poly Prep Country Day | 9 | Poly Prep Country Day | 10:27.7 PR |
| 20 | Ryan ChiangPlace 20 · Grade 9 · Riverdale Country | 9 | Riverdale Country | 10:28.5 |
| 21 | Max FerreiraPlace 21 · Grade 11 · Collegiate | 11 | Collegiate | 10:28.7 |
| 22 | Kush UpadhyayaPlace 22 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 10:30.3 PR |
| 23 | Blake McKnightPlace 23 · Grade 12 · Collegiate | 12 | Collegiate | 10:31.6 PR |
| 24 | Elijah RomanPlace 24 · Grade 9 · Riverdale Country | 9 | Riverdale Country | 10:31.7 |
| 25 | Asher TworetzkyPlace 25 · Grade 9 · Trinity School | 9 | Trinity School | 10:34.0 |
| 26 | Oscar WongPlace 26 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 10:41.7 |
| 27 | Sid SinghPlace 27 · Grade 9 · Dalton | 9 | Dalton | 10:43.1 |
| 28 | Bryson CottlerPlace 28 · Grade 9 · Green Meadow Waldorf | 9 | Green Meadow Waldorf | 10:44.6 |
| 29 | Maddox Van DykePlace 29 · Grade 9 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 9 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 10:45.1 |
| 30 | Ryan WurtzPlace 30 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 10:45.7 |
| 31 | Xavier ChenPlace 31 · Grade 10 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 10 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 10:45.8 |
| 32 | Kevin SternPlace 32 · Grade 9 · Dalton | 9 | Dalton | 10:47.0 |
| 33 | David KulmanPlace 33 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 10:50.0 PR |
| 34 | Sam MwangaguhungaPlace 34 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 10:51.7 |
| 35 | Loic NguyenPlace 35 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 10:52.6 |
| 36 | Raphael BenaimPlace 36 · Grade 9 · Dalton | 9 | Dalton | 10:57.2 |
| 37 | Tyler McCulloughPlace 37 · Grade 11 · Collegiate | 11 | Collegiate | 11:01.8 PR |
| 38 | Henry RubinPlace 38 · Grade 12 · Collegiate | 12 | Collegiate | 11:13.0 PR |
| 39 | Nikhil MehraPlace 39 · Grade 9 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 9 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 11:22.9 PR |
| 40 | Elliot LucasPlace 40 · Grade 9 · Trinity School | 9 | Trinity School | 11:29.3 |
| 41 | Wyatt SimpsonPlace 41 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 11:31.4 |
| 42 | Danny LamPlace 42 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 11:44.8 |
| 43 | Justin AzadPlace 43 · Grade 12 · Collegiate | 12 | Collegiate | 11:52.6 |
| 44 | Sanford PiersonPlace 44 · Grade 12 · Collegiate | 12 | Collegiate | 11:52.9 |
| 45 | Alexander BelmanPlace 45 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 11:58.9 |
| 46 | Ranbeer AroraPlace 46 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 11:59.6 |
| 47 | Euan NathanPlace 47 · Grade 11 · Collegiate | 11 | Collegiate | 11:59.8 |
| 48 | Oliver SayerPlace 48 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 12:01.1 |
| 49 | Deven MukherjeePlace 49 · Grade 9 · Poly Prep Country Day | 9 | Poly Prep Country Day | 12:04.4 PR |
| 50 | Robert PlassePlace 50 · Grade 9 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 9 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 12:46.6 |
| 51 | Samir NaqviPlace 51 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 13:51.0 |
| 52 | Jesse KocherPlace 52 · Grade 11 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 11 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 14:44.2 PR |
| 53 | Tahsan HoquePlace 53 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 14:45.6 |
| 54 | Philip FailacePlace 54 · Grade 12 · Collegiate | 12 | Collegiate | 15:16.8 PR |
| 55 | Maxim SwintonPlace 55 · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 15:25.7 PR |
| 56 | Ryan PlummerPlace 56 · Grade 12 · Trinity School | 12 | Trinity School | 15:44.4 |
