| 1 | Chris RomboughPlace 1 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 3:50.17 |
| 2 | Jack DiechertPlace 2 · Hamline | — | Hamline | 3:52.57 |
| 3 | Hassan MeadPlace 3 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 3:53.50 |
| 4 | Bobby NicholsPlace 4 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 3:54.54 |
| 5 | Luke TosoPlace 5 · Minn Morris | — | Minn Morris | 3:55.38 |
| 6 | Tom SederquistPlace 6 · Conc Moorhead | — | Conc Moorhead | 3:58.87 |
| 7 | Dan GreenoPlace 7 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 3:59.73 |
| 8 | Tom HoffmanPlace 8 · Saint John's | — | Saint John's | 4:00.54 |
| 9 | Aaron GormanPlace 9 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:02.14 |
| 10 | Scott BehlingPlace 10 · Wis Superior | — | Wis Superior | 4:02.38 |
| 11 | Drew ParadisPlace 11 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:02.46 |
| 12 | Sam SaccomanPlace 12 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:05.02 |
| 13 | Jordan FladlandPlace 13 · Saint John's | — | Saint John's | 4:05.05 |
| 14 | Chris MasseyPlace 14 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:05.75 |
| 15 | Denny MeintsPlace 15 · Bethel | — | Bethel | 4:06.41 |
| 16 | Cole ToepferPlace 16 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:06.75 |
| 17 | Tim LillehaugenPlace 17 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:07.11 |
| 18 | Sean OlsonPlace 18 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:09.07 |
| 19 | Aron BlockPlace 19 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:09.56 |
| 20 | Dillon JohnstonPlace 20 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:09.79 |
| 21 | Ian CampbellPlace 21 · Hamline | — | Hamline | 4:10.05 |
| 22 | Joe GairPlace 22 · Saint John's | — | Saint John's | 4:10.95 |
| 23 | Ryan EasonPlace 23 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:10.99 |
| 24 | John ChristianPlace 24 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:11.48 |
| 25 | Jon LambertPlace 25 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:12.52 |
| 26 | Stefan LemkePlace 26 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:13.36 |
| 27 | Jared JohnstonPlace 27 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:14.02 |
| 28 | Jeff WinkelmanPlace 28 · N. Central U | — | N. Central U | 4:14.35 |
| 29 | Kian FlynnPlace 29 · Carleton | — | Carleton | 4:14.39 |
| 30 | Nick EvensPlace 30 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:15.28 |
| 31 | Derek SchlagerPlace 31 · Northwestern | — | Northwestern | 4:15.48 |
| 31 | Matt VenaasPlace 31 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:15.48 |
| 33 | Ollie St. JohnPlace 33 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 4:15.50 |
| 34 | Ben EhlersPlace 34 · Conc Moorhead | — | Conc Moorhead | 4:15.71 |
| 35 | Nick NygaardPlace 35 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:15.75 |
| 36 | Chris ReisdorferPlace 36 · Hamline | — | Hamline | 4:15.97 |
| 37 | Colin SinclairPlace 37 · Carleton | — | Carleton | 4:16.46 |
| 38 | Collin HagerPlace 38 · Saint John's | — | Saint John's | 4:17.37 |
| 39 | Patrick BolandPlace 39 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:17.48 |
| 40 | Jason CoffinPlace 40 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:18.41 |
| 41 | Nicholas CassPlace 41 · Conc St.Paul | — | Conc St.Paul | 4:18.92 |
| 42 | Joel JohnsonPlace 42 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:19.19 |
| 43 | Aaron HandorffPlace 43 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:19.74 |
| 44 | Matt ScherberPlace 44 · Saint John's | — | Saint John's | 4:20.14 |
| 45 | Paul LillehaugenPlace 45 · Conc Moorhead | — | Conc Moorhead | 4:20.16 |
| 46 | Dillon DavisPlace 46 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:22.96 |
| 47 | Brian SpisiakPlace 47 · Carleton | — | Carleton | 4:23.77 |
| 48 | Daniel BakkenPlace 48 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:24.23 |
| 49 | Jake StunekPlace 49 · Conc Moorhead | — | Conc Moorhead | 4:24.59 |
| 50 | Tim LaschPlace 50 · Minn Duluth | — | Minn Duluth | 4:25.22 |
| 51 | Matthew PerkovichPlace 51 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:25.23 |
| 52 | Andrew KlevenPlace 52 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:25.90 |
| 53 | Tony JohnsPlace 53 · N. Central U | — | N. Central U | 4:26.61 |
| 54 | Nate ManderfieldPlace 54 · Mich Tech | — | Mich Tech | 4:26.75 |
| 55 | Jimmy LinnPlace 55 · St. Scholast | — | St. Scholast | 4:27.16 |
| 56 | Spencer HinsethPlace 56 · Bethel | — | Bethel | 4:27.67 |
| 57 | Max WilsonPlace 57 · Mich Tech | — | Mich Tech | 4:28.20 |
| 58 | Matthew NitzPlace 58 · Mich Tech | — | Mich Tech | 4:28.40 |
| 59 | Adam KollmannPlace 59 · St. Scholast | — | St. Scholast | 4:28.84 |
| 60 | Ian O'NeillPlace 60 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:29.66 |
| 61 | Owen HeinPlace 61 · N. Central U | — | N. Central U | 4:30.22 |
| 62 | Lucas FoleyPlace 62 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:30.94 |
| 63 | Ben CarlsonPlace 63 · St. Scholast | — | St. Scholast | 4:31.10 |
| 64 | Andrew BirnstengelPlace 64 · Minn Morris | — | Minn Morris | 4:31.75 |
| 65 | Andrew HardtPlace 65 · Carleton | — | Carleton | 4:32.19 |
| 66 | Frankie HellerPlace 66 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:33.03 |
| 67 | Ethan SchubertPlace 67 · St. Scholast | — | St. Scholast | 4:34.08 |
| 68 | Ben MayhewPlace 68 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 4:34.53 |
| 69 | Max TusaPlace 69 · Saint John's | — | Saint John's | 4:34.57 |
| 70 | Evan JohnsonPlace 70 · Carleton | — | Carleton | 4:34.86 |
| 71 | Ryan SutleyPlace 71 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 4:34.98 |
| 72 | Daanish KhanPlace 72 · Conc St.Paul | — | Conc St.Paul | 4:36.55 |
| 73 | Scott CartwrightPlace 73 · Mich Tech | — | Mich Tech | 4:36.99 |
| 74 | Carlos MartinezPlace 74 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 4:40.00 |
| 75 | Joe SchubertPlace 75 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 4:40.68 |
| 76 | Kevin RotichPlace 76 · Northwestern | — | Northwestern | 4:41.30 |
| 77 | Charles AbrahamPlace 77 · Minn Morris | — | Minn Morris | 4:41.96 |
| 78 | Austin MuchowPlace 78 · N. Central U | — | N. Central U | 4:42.09 |
| 79 | Ben ParksPlace 79 · Carleton | — | Carleton | 4:42.48 |
| 80 | Tony FremlingPlace 80 · Augsburg | — | Augsburg | 4:46.74 |
| 81 | Anthony WhitePlace 81 · Minn Morris | — | Minn Morris | 4:48.10 |
| 82 | Lee SouthertonPlace 82 · Mich Tech | — | Mich Tech | 4:48.21 |
| 83 | Dan WilsonPlace 83 · St. Olaf | — | St. Olaf | 4:51.73 |
| 84 | Cody HowePlace 84 · Bethel | — | Bethel | 4:52.18 |
| 85 | Brad JohnsonPlace 85 · Conc Moorhead | — | Conc Moorhead | 4:53.17 |
| 86 | Mike UngerPlace 86 · Minn Morris | — | Minn Morris | 4:55.45 |
| 87 | Denver RogallaPlace 87 · Minn Morris | — | Minn Morris | 4:57.88 |
| 88 | Kyle BillettPlace 88 · Minn Morris | — | Minn Morris | 4:58.19 |
| 89 | Alex JorgensonPlace 89 · Conc Moorhead | — | Conc Moorhead | 5:00.50 |
| 90 | Joey FranklPlace 90 · Macalester | — | Macalester | 5:01.19 |
| 91 | Seth NeumannPlace 91 · Wis Superior | — | Wis Superior | 5:08.09 |
| 92 | Joe MarrenPlace 92 · Carleton | — | Carleton | 5:17.59 |
| 93 | Patrick ThorntonPlace 93 · Saint John's | — | Saint John's | 5:23.01 |