| 1. | Jason CristPlace 1. · Grade 12 · Franklin Central | 12 | Franklin Central | 4:11.56a PR | 10 |
| 2. | Troy ReederPlace 2. · Grade 11 · Hamilton Southeastern | 11 | Hamilton Southeastern | 4:12.29a PR | 8 |
| 3. | Matt DorseyPlace 3. · Grade 11 · Lawrence Central | 11 | Lawrence Central | 4:12.63a PR | 6 |
| 4. | Jacob ThomsonPlace 4. · Grade 11 · Holy Cross (Louisville) | 11 | Holy Cross (Louisville) | 4:13.66a | 5 |
| 5. | Jacob PoynerPlace 5. · Grade 11 · Warsaw Community | 11 | Warsaw Community | 4:13.86a | 4 |
| 6. | Joey ZielinskiPlace 6. · Grade 12 · South Bend St. Joseph | 12 | South Bend St. Joseph | 4:15.09a PR | 3 |
| 7. | Connor SorrellsPlace 7. · Grade 11 · Barr Reeve | 11 | Barr Reeve | 4:15.23a PR | 2 |
| 8. | Kent GarrettPlace 8. · Grade 12 · Guerin Catholic | 12 | Guerin Catholic | 4:15.73a PR | 1 |
| 9. | Mark ChandlerPlace 9. · Grade 12 · Bloomington South | 12 | Bloomington South | 4:16.86a PR | — |
| 10. | Samuel BergerPlace 10. · Grade 12 · Zionsville | 12 | Zionsville | 4:17.45a PR | — |
| 11. | Kyle DuVallPlace 11. · Grade 11 · Westfield | 11 | Westfield | 4:18.26a PR | — |
| 12. | Mitchell HubnerPlace 12. · Grade 12 · LaPorte | 12 | LaPorte | 4:18.33a PR | — |
| 13. | Tyler SchickelPlace 13. · Grade 12 · Evansville Mater Dei | 12 | Evansville Mater Dei | 4:19.52a PR | — |
| 14. | Daniel WilliamsPlace 14. · Grade 11 · Carmel | 11 | Carmel | 4:19.86a PR | — |
| 15. | Jack AndritchPlace 15. · Grade 12 · Hamilton Southeastern | 12 | Hamilton Southeastern | 4:20.83a PR | — |
| 16. | Christopher KelseyPlace 16. · Grade 12 · Columbus North | 12 | Columbus North | 4:21.40a PR | — |
| 17. | Dillon HinenPlace 17. · Grade 12 · Fairfield | 12 | Fairfield | 4:21.63a PR | — |
| 18. | Patrick AppletonPlace 18. · Grade 11 · Carmel | 11 | Carmel | 4:21.63a PR | — |
| 19. | Johnnie GuyPlace 19. · Grade 12 · North Harrison | 12 | North Harrison | 4:21.78a PR | — |
| 20. | Tate SchienbeinPlace 20. · Grade 12 · Union County | 12 | Union County | 4:21.93a PR | — |
| 21. | Mitchell DuttonPlace 21. · Grade 12 · Fort Wayne Snider | 12 | Fort Wayne Snider | 4:22.00a PR | — |
| 22. | Patrick GregoryPlace 22. · Grade 10 · Butler | 10 | Butler | 4:22.36a PR | — |
| 23. | Jonathan ReynoldsPlace 23. · Grade 11 · North Harrison | 11 | North Harrison | 4:23.30a | — |
| 24. | Carl SmithPlace 24. · Grade 12 · Bloomington South | 12 | Bloomington South | 4:23.37a PR | — |
| 25. | Michael SublettePlace 25. · Grade 12 · Columbus North | 12 | Columbus North | 4:23.50a PR | — |
| 26. | Hayden MerkelPlace 26. · Grade 12 · Batesville | 12 | Batesville | 4:25.03a PR | — |
| 27. | Alec KostelnikPlace 27. · Grade 11 · Morgan Township | 11 | Morgan Township | 4:25.52a PR | — |
| 28. | Jackson BertoliPlace 28. · Grade 10 · Terre Haute South Vigo | 10 | Terre Haute South Vigo | 4:26.14a | — |
| 29. | Ryan ConradPlace 29. · Grade 11 · Zionsville | 11 | Zionsville | 4:26.25a PR | — |
| 30. | Cole HesterPlace 30. · Grade 11 · Lawrence Central | 11 | Lawrence Central | 4:26.49a PR | — |
| 31. | Adam WilliamsPlace 31. · Grade 12 · Fort Wayne Snider | 12 | Fort Wayne Snider | 4:27.04a PR | — |
| 32. | Zachary SniderPlace 32. · Grade 9 · Brebeuf Jesuit | 9 | Brebeuf Jesuit | 4:27.17a | — |
| 33. | Curtis BurksPlace 33. · Grade 12 · Bloomington South | 12 | Bloomington South | 4:27.39a PR | — |
| 34. | Bobby BrowningPlace 34. · Grade 10 · Carmel | 10 | Carmel | 4:27.52a | — |
| 35. | Rocky PollockPlace 35. · Grade 12 · Fishers | 12 | Fishers | 4:28.15a PR | — |
| 36. | Nickolas ArndtPlace 36. · Grade 11 · New Prairie | 11 | New Prairie | 4:30.31a PR | — |
| 37. | Asher ScottPlace 37. · Grade 11 · Fort Wayne Snider | 11 | Fort Wayne Snider | 4:30.56a PR | — |
| 38. | Charlie WatsonPlace 38. · Grade 11 · Carmel | 11 | Carmel | 4:31.66a PR | — |
| 39. | Sam RoudebushPlace 39. · Grade 12 · Noblesville | 12 | Noblesville | 4:31.73a PR | — |
| 40. | Andrew DiehnPlace 40. · Grade 12 · Columbus North | 12 | Columbus North | 4:32.61a PR | — |
| 41. | Austin PresnellPlace 41. · Grade 11 · Franklin Central | 11 | Franklin Central | 4:33.19a PR | — |
| 42. | Hitchcock SawyerPlace 42. · Grade 12 · Hamilton Southeastern | 12 | Hamilton Southeastern | 4:33.66a PR | — |
| 43. | Anthony DidionPlace 43. · Grade 10 · LaPorte | 10 | LaPorte | 4:35.42a PR | — |
| 44. | Tyeson MundyPlace 44. · Grade 12 · Terre Haute North Vigo | 12 | Terre Haute North Vigo | 4:36.90a PR | — |
| 45. | Brandon SmithPlace 45. · Grade 12 · Warren Central | 12 | Warren Central | 4:40.31a PR | — |