| 1 | Steven FlynnPlace 1 · Edison | — | Edison | 4:20.03 |
| 2 | Marcus HatchettPlace 2 · Piscataway | — | Piscataway | 4:21.77 |
| 3 | Lance WeaverPlace 3 · Piscataway | — | Piscataway | 4:22.68 |
| 4 | Jim GormanPlace 4 · St. Joe's | — | St. Joe's | 4:24.68 |
| 5 | Sam HabibPlace 5 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:28.57 |
| 6 | Thomas HogartyPlace 6 · St. Joe's | — | St. Joe's | 4:29.51 |
| 7 | Nick PricePlace 7 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:30.75 |
| 8 | James HampseyPlace 8 · Metuchen | — | Metuchen | 4:38.22 |
| 9 | Patrick BellPlace 9 · St. Joe's | — | St. Joe's | 4:38.32 |
| 10 | Andrew BellPlace 10 · St. Joe's | — | St. Joe's | 4:38.48 |
| 11 | Ryan ColonPlace 11 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:38.65 |
| 12 | Panth PatelPlace 12 · J P Stevens | — | J P Stevens | 4:40.18 |
| 13 | Andrew GillPlace 13 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:41.63 |
| 14 | Billy MurawskiPlace 14 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:42.13 |
| 15 | Michael MorsePlace 15 · St. Joe's | — | St. Joe's | 4:42.30 |
| 16 | Joe CapolinoPlace 16 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:42.43 |
| 17 | Brandon D'SousaPlace 17 · St. Joe's | — | St. Joe's | 4:42.48 |
| 18 | Tristan NorcuttPlace 18 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:43.74 |
| 19 | Corey CaplanPlace 19 · Metuchen | — | Metuchen | 4:46.99 |
| 20 | Mike MilazzoPlace 20 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:47.20 |
| 21 | Sean MulqueenPlace 21 · Dunellen | — | Dunellen | 4:48.12 |
| 22 | Nick PiccilloPlace 22 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:48.23 |
| 23 | Mike DoPlace 23 · Metuchen | — | Metuchen | 4:49.84 |
| 24 | Anik ChattopadhyayPlace 24 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:51.13 |
| 25 | SaiKumar MedicherlaPlace 25 · So. Plfld | — | So. Plfld | 4:51.86 |
| 26 | Kaustubh DeshpandePlace 26 · J P Stevens | — | J P Stevens | 4:52.79 |
| 27 | Adam ButricoPlace 27 · So. Plfld | — | So. Plfld | 4:54.31 |
| 28 | Shaun VanBuskirkPlace 28 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:54.76 |
| 29 | Rich DufresnePlace 29 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:54.78 |
| 30 | Parag BapnaPlace 30 · J P Stevens | — | J P Stevens | 4:55.42 |
| 31 | Kevin PuPlace 31 · J P Stevens | — | J P Stevens | 4:55.62 |
| 32 | Zach WilsonPlace 32 · So. Plfld | — | So. Plfld | 4:57.83 |
| 33 | Daniel GalarzaPlace 33 · J P Stevens | — | J P Stevens | 4:58.14 |
| 34 | Artur DebekPlace 34 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 4:58.36 |
| 35 | Nick ProtoPlace 35 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 5:00.34 |
| 36 | Alec HorvathPlace 36 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 5:05.26 |
| 37 | Nick MarraroPlace 37 · Metuchen | — | Metuchen | 5:10.34 |
| 38 | Dan BucinoPlace 38 · Dunellen | — | Dunellen | 5:14.05 |
| 39 | Tristan TeitlerPlace 39 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 5:15.50 |
| 40 | Ryan KoenigPlace 40 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 5:19.37 |
| 41 | Neil ShahPlace 41 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 5:19.83 |
| 42 | Nick BottePlace 42 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 5:20.26 |
| 43 | Troy KanasakaPlace 43 · Metuchen | — | Metuchen | 5:20.35 |
| 44 | ? LawsonPlace 44 · Dunellen | — | Dunellen | 5:22.21 |
| 45 | Dan SalardinoPlace 45 · Old Bridge | — | Old Bridge | 5:24.74 |
| 46 | Robby GilmanPlace 46 · Metuchen | — | Metuchen | 5:28.14 |