| 1. | Isabelle HarouchePlace 1. · Grade 12 · Cold Spring Harbor | 12 | Cold Spring Harbor | 1:40.13a PR |
| 2. | Natalie SopchakPlace 2. · Grade 12 · General Douglas Macarthur | 12 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:40.17a |
| 3. | Nicolette AgostinacchioPlace 3. · Grade 11 · General Douglas Macarthur | 11 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:40.47a |
| 4. | Sydney SopchakPlace 4. · Grade 12 · General Douglas Macarthur | 12 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:40.70a |
| 5. | Rachel WesleyPlace 5. · Grade 12 · Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 12 | Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 1:44.22a |
| 6. | Beatriz ChavarriaPlace 6. · Grade 10 · Paul D Schreiber | 10 | Paul D Schreiber | 1:44.28a |
| 7. | Christina MarinelliPlace 7. · Grade 11 · Paul D Schreiber | 11 | Paul D Schreiber | 1:44.33a PR |
| 8. | Morgan HanelPlace 8. · Grade 12 · Wheatley | 12 | Wheatley | 1:47.99a |
| 9. | Juliann VizosoPlace 9. · Grade 11 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 11 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 1:48.06a |
| 10. | Carly PerlmutterPlace 10. · Grade 10 · Paul D Schreiber | 10 | Paul D Schreiber | 1:49.12a PR |
| 11. | Daniela LoCastroPlace 11. · Grade 11 · Cold Spring Harbor | 11 | Cold Spring Harbor | 1:49.49a PR |
| 12. | Briana NotoPlace 12. · Grade 11 · WC Mepham | 11 | WC Mepham | 1:50.37a |
| 13. | Ariel TillmanPlace 13. · Grade 9 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 9 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 1:52.10a |
| 14. | Shaniece GregoryPlace 14. · Grade 12 · Valley Stream Central | 12 | Valley Stream Central | 1:52.44a |
| 15. | Caitie CunninghamPlace 15. · Grade 12 · Mineola | 12 | Mineola | 1:53.02a PR |
| 16. | Alexandra RodriguezPlace 16. · Grade 11 · W T Clarke | 11 | W T Clarke | 1:53.50a PR |
| 17. | Emma JosephPlace 17. · Grade 11 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 11 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 1:54.21a |
| 18. | Catalina SalvatierraPlace 18. · Grade 11 · Paul D Schreiber | 11 | Paul D Schreiber | 1:54.48a |
| 19. | Diana HadjiyanePlace 19. · Grade 9 · General Douglas Macarthur | 9 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:54.50a PR |
| 20. | Kerri GoldfussPlace 20. · Grade 10 · W T Clarke | 10 | W T Clarke | 1:55.14a |
| 21. | Jacqueline ShandPlace 21. · Grade 11 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 11 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 1:55.35a PR |
| 22. | Katelyn PolitiPlace 22. · Grade 10 · General Douglas Macarthur | 10 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:55.68a |
| 23. | Andrea D'SaPlace 23. · Grade 12 · WC Mepham | 12 | WC Mepham | 1:56.08a |
| 24. | Jenna StillmanPlace 24. · Grade 10 · General Douglas Macarthur | 10 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:56.28a |
| 25. | Futter JillianPlace 25. · Grade 10 · Cold Spring Harbor | 10 | Cold Spring Harbor | 1:56.88a PR |
| 26. | Lucy HurtPlace 26. · Grade 9 · Paul D Schreiber | 9 | Paul D Schreiber | 1:57.91a |
| 27. | Michaela NapoliPlace 27. · Grade 10 · General Douglas Macarthur | 10 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:58.17a |
| 28. | Emma DevereauxPlace 28. · Grade 12 · Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 12 | Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 1:58.23a |
| 28. | Olivia LevyPlace 28. · Grade 10 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 10 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 1:58.23a |
| 30. | Taylor HeldPlace 30. · Grade 12 · WC Mepham | 12 | WC Mepham | 1:58.56a |
| 31. | Ilana HillPlace 31. · Grade 10 · Paul D Schreiber | 10 | Paul D Schreiber | 1:59.09a |
| 32. | Diana BrennanPlace 32. · Grade 9 · East Meadow | 9 | East Meadow | 1:59.21a PR |
| 32. | Stephanie BurchellPlace 32. · Grade 10 · Valley Stream Central | 10 | Valley Stream Central | 1:59.21a |
| 34. | Hannah PetersonPlace 34. · Grade 9 · General Douglas Macarthur | 9 | General Douglas Macarthur | 1:59.32a |
| 35. | Rebecca WoodsPlace 35. · Grade 12 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 12 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 1:59.50a |
| 36. | Niamh WoodsPlace 36. · Grade 12 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 12 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 1:59.52a |
| 37. | Anna PappasPlace 37. · Grade 9 · Friends Academy | 9 | Friends Academy | 1:59.80a PR |
| 38. | Emily PuciloskiPlace 38. · Grade 11 · East Meadow | 11 | East Meadow | 2:00.84a |
| 39. | Maria KoganPlace 39. · Grade 10 · Paul D Schreiber | 10 | Paul D Schreiber | 2:01.16a |
| 40. | Megan FitzpatrickPlace 40. · Grade 11 · W T Clarke | 11 | W T Clarke | 2:01.19a |
| 41. | Jenna DeRosaPlace 41. · Grade 10 · WC Mepham | 10 | WC Mepham | 2:02.61a PR |
| 42. | Emily CappucciPlace 42. · Grade 11 · Cold Spring Harbor | 11 | Cold Spring Harbor | 2:02.69a PR |
| 43. | Karin DurelsPlace 43. · Grade 12 · WC Mepham | 12 | WC Mepham | 2:03.43a PR |
| 44. | Sabrina IaconoPlace 44. · Grade 12 · Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 12 | Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 2:04.04a |
| 45. | Annika KahlPlace 45. · Grade 9 · East Meadow | 9 | East Meadow | 2:05.10a |
| 46. | Brooke WallerPlace 46. · Grade 8 · Long Beach | 8 | Long Beach | 2:05.84a PR |
| 47. | Siobhan O'NeillPlace 47. · Grade 12 · Locust Valley | 12 | Locust Valley | 2:06.35a |