| 1 | Jordan GeistPlace 1 · Saxonburg, PA | — | Saxonburg, PA | 70-4 |
| 2 | Sam WrightPlace 2 · T1D | — | T1D | 60-5 |
| 3 | Tom BojaladPlace 3 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 57-8.75 |
| 4 | Jon SurdejPlace 4 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 53-8 |
| 5 | Paul KemsleyPlace 5 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 52-6.75 |
| 6 | Mark ThomasPlace 6 · Williamsville, NY | — | Williamsville, NY | 50-4.75 |
| 7 | Ryan SwavelyPlace 7 · Rome, NY | — | Rome, NY | 49-5 |
| 8 | Jamie CoccaPlace 8 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 49-4.75 |
| 9 | Jamal EllisPlace 9 · T1D | — | T1D | 48-6.25 |
| 10 | Nate WonselyPlace 10 · T1D | — | T1D | 47-6 |
| 11 | Robert EdgePlace 11 · T1D | — | T1D | 46-6 |
| 12 | Russ KobiereckiPlace 12 · Clarence, NY | — | Clarence, NY | 45-6.75 |
| 13 | Andy PietrantoniPlace 13 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 45-4.25 |
| 14 | Jon BanksPlace 14 · Cheektowaga Throws Club | — | Cheektowaga Throws Club | 45-3.75 |
| 15 | Brian MurphyPlace 15 · FIRE Athletic Club | — | FIRE Athletic Club | 45-2.5 |
| 16 | Andrew PalermoPlace 16 · Rochester Running Rebels | — | Rochester Running Rebels | 44-4 |
| 17 | Caleb NickensPlace 17 · Amherst, NY | — | Amherst, NY | 43-5 |
| 18 | Art JordanPlace 18 · Cheektowaga Throws Club | — | Cheektowaga Throws Club | 43-3.25 |
| 19 | Marquel RobertsPlace 19 · FIRE Athletic Club | — | FIRE Athletic Club | 42-11.5 |
| 20 | Krischan PietrantoniPlace 20 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 42-7.5 |
| 21 | Scott FinebergPlace 21 · T1D | — | T1D | 42-4.75 |
| 22 | Arin SamadPlace 22 · Rome, NY | — | Rome, NY | 41-6.5 |
| 23 | Tyler DotyPlace 23 · FIRE Athletic Club | — | FIRE Athletic Club | 40-11 |
| 24 | Mike CiminellaPlace 24 · Amherst, NY | — | Amherst, NY | 39-5.25 |
| 25 | Kyle BrownPlace 25 · T1D | — | T1D | 39-1 |
| 26 | Chris RickardPlace 26 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 38-1.75 |
| 27 | Devin WiencekPlace 27 · Clarence, NY | — | Clarence, NY | 37-11.5 |
| 28 | Will GrossPlace 28 · FIRE Athletic Club | — | FIRE Athletic Club | 37-4 |
| 29 | Mike WolfordPlace 29 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 35-3.75 |
| 30 | Scott PriesterPlace 30 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 35-1 |
| 31 | Matt CressPlace 31 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 34-10.75 |
| 32 | Sam FriendPlace 32 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 34-3 |
| 33 | Greg GyalogPlace 33 · Cheektowaga Throws Club | — | Cheektowaga Throws Club | 34-1 |
| 34 | Grey LockPlace 34 · Amherst, NY | — | Amherst, NY | 34-0 |
| 35 | Zach MackPlace 35 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 33-1 |
| 36 | Zack ZielinskiPlace 36 · Cheektowaga Throws Club | — | Cheektowaga Throws Club | 33-.5 |
| 37 | Solomon ShabazzPlace 37 · Amherst, NY | — | Amherst, NY | 31-9.75 |
| 38 | Brody CarrPlace 38 · Cheektowaga Throws Club | — | Cheektowaga Throws Club | 31-8.5 |
| 39 | Earl WellsPlace 39 · Clarence, NY | — | Clarence, NY | 31-8.25 |
| 40 | John FredericePlace 40 · FIRE Athletic Club | — | FIRE Athletic Club | 30-11.25 |
| 41 | Micah MoorePlace 41 · FIRE Athletic Club | — | FIRE Athletic Club | 30-7.75 |
| 42 | Jake BuckleyPlace 42 · Cheektowaga Throws Club | — | Cheektowaga Throws Club | 29-4.25 |
| 43 | Kyle ChandlerPlace 43 · Cheektowaga Throws Club | — | Cheektowaga Throws Club | 28-5 |
| 44 | Joe PowerPlace 44 · Redskin Throwers | — | Redskin Throwers | 28-1.25 |
| 45 | Trent CurtisPlace 45 · Clarence, NY | — | Clarence, NY | 27-8.75 |
| 46 | Hayden HarringtonPlace 46 · Amherst, NY | — | Amherst, NY | 26-5.75 |
| 47 | Tobias GaylePlace 47 · Cheektowaga Throws Club | — | Cheektowaga Throws Club | 23-3.5 |
| 48 | Matt CarliniPlace 48 · Amherst, NY | — | Amherst, NY | 21-5 |