| 1. | Braden SweetPlace 1. · Grade Sr · Indiana Wesleyan | Sr | Indiana Wesleyan | 3:53.85a |
| 2. | Charles LeedkePlace 2. · Grade So · Marian (Ind.) | So | Marian (Ind.) | 3:53.94a |
| 3. | Nathan BurnsPlace 3. · Grade Jr · Taylor (Ind.) | Jr | Taylor (Ind.) | 3:56.95a |
| 4. | Ben MosterPlace 4. · Grade Sr · Marian (Ind.) | Sr | Marian (Ind.) | 3:59.54a |
| 5. | Jack StrongPlace 5. · Grade Fr · Purdue Fort Wayne | Fr | Purdue Fort Wayne | 4:01.80a |
| 6. | Curt DahnckePlace 6. · Grade So · Indianapolis | So | Indianapolis | 4:03.88a |
| 7. | David YowlerPlace 7. · Grade Fr · Indiana Wesleyan | Fr | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:04.02a PR |
| 8. | Trenton SweetPlace 8. · Grade So · Indiana Wesleyan | So | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:04.47a |
| 9. | Evan NickolesPlace 9. · Grade Fr · Indiana Wesleyan | Fr | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:04.66a |
| 9. | Liam LillyPlace 9. · Grade Fr · IU-Indy | Fr | IU-Indy | 4:04.66a PR |
| 11. | Sam SienkowskiPlace 11. · Grade Fr · Marian (Ind.) | Fr | Marian (Ind.) | 4:04.92a |
| 12. | Preston MarkleyPlace 12. · Grade Fr · Marian (Ind.) | Fr | Marian (Ind.) | 4:05.24a |
| 13. | Josh RoperPlace 13. · Grade So · Purdue Fort Wayne | So | Purdue Fort Wayne | 4:05.49a PR |
| 14. | Mason PiattPlace 14. · Grade Sr · Marian (Ind.) | Sr | Marian (Ind.) | 4:06.01a |
| 15. | Mike HerringtonPlace 15. · Grade Fr · Indiana Wesleyan | Fr | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:06.15a |
| 16. | John YoungPlace 16. · Grade So · Grace (Ind.) | So | Grace (Ind.) | 4:06.68a PR |
| 17. | Joel MumawPlace 17. · Grade Sr · Taylor (Ind.) | Sr | Taylor (Ind.) | 4:08.36a |
| 18. | Hunter WasnichPlace 18. · Grade Sr · Indiana Wesleyan | Sr | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:08.43a PR |
| 19. | Bradyn LivingstonPlace 19. · Grade Fr · Purdue Fort Wayne | Fr | Purdue Fort Wayne | 4:10.94a PR |
| 20. | Evan LongPlace 20. · Grade Jr · Indiana Wesleyan | Jr | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:11.00a |
| 21. | Kale SeymourPlace 21. · Grade Fr · Purdue Fort Wayne | Fr | Purdue Fort Wayne | 4:11.69a PR |
| 22. | Steven CasePlace 22. · Grade Jr · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | Jr | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 4:12.76a |
| 23. | Noah McPhailPlace 23. · Grade Fr · Indiana Wesleyan | Fr | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:13.51a PR |
| 24. | Conner UpplegerPlace 24. · Grade Sr · Lawrence Tech (Mich.) | Sr | Lawrence Tech (Mich.) | 4:14.22a |
| 25. | Alec ShawPlace 25. · Grade Sr · Lawrence Tech (Mich.) | Sr | Lawrence Tech (Mich.) | 4:14.99a |
| 26. | Jackson TuckPlace 26. · Grade Jr · IU-Indy | Jr | IU-Indy | 4:15.25a PR |
| 27. | Rudy BowmanPlace 27. · Grade Fr · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | Fr | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 4:16.22a PR |
| 28. | Daniel MulletPlace 28. · Grade Fr · Purdue Fort Wayne | Fr | Purdue Fort Wayne | 4:16.50a |
| 29. | Tripp WingatePlace 29. · Grade Fr · Indiana Wesleyan | Fr | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:16.69a PR |
| 30. | Lucas StewardPlace 30. · Grade Jr · Marian (Ind.) | Jr | Marian (Ind.) | 4:17.66a |
| 31. | Austin WilsonPlace 31. · Grade Jr · Grace (Ind.) | Jr | Grace (Ind.) | 4:18.56a |
| 32. | Jeremiah MilesPlace 32. · Grade Fr · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | Fr | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 4:18.94a |
| 33. | Noah VachonPlace 33. · Grade Jr · Indianapolis | Jr | Indianapolis | 4:18.96a |
| 34. | Luke KincaidPlace 34. · Grade Fr · Indiana Wesleyan | Fr | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:20.29a |
| 35. | Andrew ArnosPlace 35. · Grade Jr · Purdue Fort Wayne | Jr | Purdue Fort Wayne | 4:20.34a |
| 36. | Evan BensePlace 36. · Grade Fr · Indianapolis | Fr | Indianapolis | 4:20.54a |
| 37. | Gio HayesPlace 37. · Grade So · Indianapolis | So | Indianapolis | 4:20.84a PR |
| 38. | Jay PillaiPlace 38. · Grade Jr · IU-Indy | Jr | IU-Indy | 4:20.99a |
| 39. | Noah LowmanPlace 39. · Grade Fr · Taylor (Ind.) | Fr | Taylor (Ind.) | 4:21.24a |
| 40. | Clark ChustzPlace 40. · Grade Sr · Marian (Ind.) | Sr | Marian (Ind.) | 4:21.92a |
| 41. | Chase CatesPlace 41. · Grade Jr · Indiana Wesleyan | Jr | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:22.09a PR |
| 42. | Ethan NixPlace 42. · Grade Jr · Indiana Wesleyan | Jr | Indiana Wesleyan | 4:25.60a |
| 43. | Ayden PottsPlace 43. · Grade So · IU Kokomo (Ind.) | So | IU Kokomo (Ind.) | 4:26.63a |
| 44. | Jackson MarshallPlace 44. · Grade So · Purdue Fort Wayne | So | Purdue Fort Wayne | 4:27.89a |
| 45. | Cole JohnstonPlace 45. · Grade Sr · Grace (Ind.) | Sr | Grace (Ind.) | 4:28.16a |
| 46. | Landon WillisPlace 46. · Grade Fr · Marian (Ind.) | Fr | Marian (Ind.) | 4:28.39a PR |
| 47. | Jace BullinsPlace 47. · Grade Fr · Grace (Ind.) | Fr | Grace (Ind.) | 4:30.55a |
| 48. | Kyle BoardmanPlace 48. · Grade So · Indianapolis | So | Indianapolis | 4:31.70a |
| 49. | Noah AskewPlace 49. · Grade Fr · Grace (Ind.) | Fr | Grace (Ind.) | 4:33.68a PR |
| 50. | Luke NierPlace 50. · Grade Sr · Grace (Ind.) | Sr | Grace (Ind.) | 4:38.57a |
| 51. | Elijah PitcockPlace 51. · Grade Fr · Indianapolis | Fr | Indianapolis | 4:45.02a PR |
| — | Jake CooperGrade Fr · Marian (Ind.) | Fr | Marian (Ind.) | DNS |
| — | Jonathan AlbrightGrade Fr · Indiana Wesleyan | Fr | Indiana Wesleyan | DNS |
| — | Cambel BrownGrade Fr · Taylor (Ind.) | Fr | Taylor (Ind.) | DNS |
| — | Matt HemmerlingGrade So · Marian (Ind.) | So | Marian (Ind.) | DNS |
| — | Matt HemmerlingGrade So · Marian (Ind.) | So | Marian (Ind.) | DNS |
| — | Tommy OttGrade Sr · Indiana Wesleyan | Sr | Indiana Wesleyan | DNS |
| — | Jared StayteGrade Sr · Taylor (Ind.) | Sr | Taylor (Ind.) | DNS |
| — | Luke SchrammGrade Jr · Grace (Ind.) | Jr | Grace (Ind.) | DNS |
| — | Gavin WiersmaGrade Jr · Indiana Wesleyan | Jr | Indiana Wesleyan | DNF |
| — | Grant FloraGrade Jr · Indiana Wesleyan | Jr | Indiana Wesleyan | DNS |
| — | Alex OrtizGrade Sr · Taylor (Ind.) | Sr | Taylor (Ind.) | DNS |
| — | Tyler GodwinGrade So · Purdue Fort Wayne | So | Purdue Fort Wayne | DNS |
| — | Owen PittmanGrade Sr · Unattached | Sr | Unattached | DNF |