| 1. | Eric BeswickPlace 1. · Grade 12 · North Hunterdon | 12 | North Hunterdon | 4:31.17a | 10 |
| 2. | Patrick PalmaPlace 2. · Grade 12 · North Hunterdon | 12 | North Hunterdon | 4:32.79a | 8 |
| 3. | Cole KoberPlace 3. · Grade 11 · North Hunterdon | 11 | North Hunterdon | 4:35.43a | 6 |
| 4. | Samuel Rosario-RoachPlace 4. · Grade 11 · Piscataway | 11 | Piscataway | 4:37.28a PR | 4 |
| 5. | Jeremy CrawfordPlace 5. · Grade 11 · Columbia | 11 | Columbia | 4:37.60a | 2 |
| 6. | Avery InnisPlace 6. · Grade 12 · Voorhees | 12 | Voorhees | 4:37.63a PR | 1 |
| 7. | Benjamin AdamoPlace 7. · Grade 12 · North Hunterdon | 12 | North Hunterdon | 4:38.25a PR | — |
| 8. | Evan SchmidtPlace 8. · Grade 10 · North Hunterdon | 10 | North Hunterdon | 4:38.91a | — |
| 9. | Maxwell NeumannPlace 9. · Grade 12 · Ridge | 12 | Ridge | 4:39.90a | — |
| 10. | Matthew HillmannPlace 10. · Grade 10 · North Hunterdon | 10 | North Hunterdon | 4:41.52a | — |
| 11. | Ryan SchmidtPlace 11. · Grade 12 · North Hunterdon | 12 | North Hunterdon | 4:41.90a | — |
| 12. | Rehaan WadhwaniPlace 12. · Grade 10 · Ridge | 10 | Ridge | 4:41.97a | — |
| 13. | Nishank ShivapurPlace 13. · Grade 10 · Ridge | 10 | Ridge | 4:42.65a | — |
| 14. | Lachlan NevillePlace 14. · Grade 12 · Morristown | 12 | Morristown | 4:42.94a | — |
| 15. | Ryan HuttonPlace 15. · Grade 11 · Cranford | 11 | Cranford | 4:43.14a PR | — |
| 16. | Andrew BandrowskiPlace 16. · Grade 9 · Ridge | 9 | Ridge | 4:44.18a | — |
| 17. | Arun DamodaranPlace 17. · Grade 12 · Newark Academy | 12 | Newark Academy | 4:46.39a | — |
| 18. | Benjamin DamianoPlace 18. · Grade 12 · Voorhees | 12 | Voorhees | 4:48.22a | — |
| 19. | Ernan NargotraPlace 19. · Grade 10 · Ridge | 10 | Ridge | 4:49.70a | — |
| 20. | Henry GriffeePlace 20. · Grade 12 · Morristown | 12 | Morristown | 4:49.74a | — |
| 21. | Kyle BeerPlace 21. · Grade 12 · Voorhees | 12 | Voorhees | 4:50.91a | — |
| 22. | Jacob RuffoloPlace 22. · Grade 11 · North Hunterdon | 11 | North Hunterdon | 4:52.50a | — |
| 23. | Bryan SeoPlace 23. · Grade 10 · Ridge | 10 | Ridge | 4:53.03a | — |
| 24. | Rishan RajeshPlace 24. · Grade 11 · Piscataway | 11 | Piscataway | 4:53.96a PR | — |
| 25. | Patrick ParentePlace 25. · Grade 10 · Governor Livingston | 10 | Governor Livingston | 4:54.37a | — |
| 26. | William HoyerPlace 26. · Grade 12 · North Hunterdon | 12 | North Hunterdon | 4:54.68a | — |
| 27. | Pranay BulusuPlace 27. · Grade 12 · North Hunterdon | 12 | North Hunterdon | 4:55.30a | — |
| 28. | Evan WallerPlace 28. · Grade 11 · Columbia | 11 | Columbia | 4:55.70a | — |
| 29. | Ivan ZubrinicPlace 29. · Grade 11 · Governor Livingston | 11 | Governor Livingston | 4:55.75a PR | — |
| 30. | Alex CalafatiPlace 30. · Grade 11 · Morristown | 11 | Morristown | 4:55.97a PR | — |
| 31. | Caleb ReaveyPlace 31. · Grade 10 · Piscataway | 10 | Piscataway | 4:56.67a PR | — |
| 32. | Aiden LahrPlace 32. · Grade 9 · Cranford | 9 | Cranford | 4:59.31a | — |
| 33. | Maddox WilliamsPlace 33. · Grade 12 · Columbia | 12 | Columbia | 5:00.45a | — |
| 34. | Ethan HartPlace 34. · Grade 10 · Columbia | 10 | Columbia | 5:00.85a | — |
| 35. | Alex AbramsPlace 35. · Grade 12 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 12 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 5:00.89a | — |
| 36. | Alexander HagopianPlace 36. · Grade 11 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 11 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 5:02.04a | — |
| 37. | James EvangelistaPlace 37. · Grade 9 · Columbia | 9 | Columbia | 5:02.14a | — |
| 38. | Gavin ShollenbergerPlace 38. · Grade 12 · Boonton | 12 | Boonton | 5:02.32a | — |
| 39. | Liam Uychich PrunerPlace 39. · Grade 11 · Boonton | 11 | Boonton | 5:02.35a | — |
| 40. | Caden SchmidtPlace 40. · Grade 10 · North Hunterdon | 10 | North Hunterdon | 5:02.41a PR | — |
| 41. | Ryan HeinbachPlace 41. · Grade 12 · North Hunterdon | 12 | North Hunterdon | 5:02.50a | — |
| 42. | Joshua CinquePlace 42. · Grade 9 · Governor Livingston | 9 | Governor Livingston | 5:05.28a | — |
| 43. | Sherman GlascoPlace 43. · Grade 11 · Piscataway | 11 | Piscataway | 5:06.41a PR | — |
| 44. | Andrei MalataPlace 44. · Grade 9 · Piscataway | 9 | Piscataway | 5:07.56a PR | — |
| 45. | Vedant PatilPlace 45. · Grade 11 · Piscataway | 11 | Piscataway | 5:07.69a PR | — |
| 46. | Owen AkersPlace 46. · Grade 12 · North Hunterdon | 12 | North Hunterdon | 5:07.71a | — |
| 47. | Riley Jenson BautistaPlace 47. · Grade 11 · Morristown | 11 | Morristown | 5:09.70a | — |
| 48. | Zain AhmadPlace 48. · Grade 11 · Piscataway | 11 | Piscataway | 5:10.37a | — |
| 49. | Mason BachmanPlace 49. · Grade 10 · North Hunterdon | 10 | North Hunterdon | 5:10.86a | — |
| 50. | Aidan SchobelPlace 50. · Grade 11 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 11 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 5:13.65a | — |
| 51. | Jake RepmannPlace 51. · Grade 11 · North Hunterdon | 11 | North Hunterdon | 5:13.79a | — |
| 52. | Tyler GlennonPlace 52. · Grade 10 · North Hunterdon | 10 | North Hunterdon | 5:13.94a | — |
| 53. | Ethan VitoPlace 53. · Grade 9 · Piscataway | 9 | Piscataway | 5:17.26a PR | — |
| 54. | Tony LourencoPlace 54. · Grade 12 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 12 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 5:17.86a PR | — |
| 55. | George PesantPlace 55. · Grade 11 · Summit | 11 | Summit | 5:29.73a | — |
| 56. | Ethan ZhouPlace 56. · Grade 12 · Newark Academy | 12 | Newark Academy | 5:35.90a | — |
| 57. | Jude LisaPlace 57. · Grade 9 · North Hunterdon | 9 | North Hunterdon | 5:38.06a | — |
| 58. | Connor JohnsonPlace 58. · Grade 12 · Governor Livingston | 12 | Governor Livingston | 5:44.93a | — |
