| 1. | Sarahi PaulinoPlace 1. · Grade 12 · Cardinal Spellman | 12 | Cardinal Spellman | 2:27.97a |
| 2. | Kimora SimsPlace 2. · Grade 12 · Hudson Catholic | 12 | Hudson Catholic | 2:30.01a |
| 3. | Niera EugenePlace 3. · Grade 12 · Midwood | 12 | Midwood | 2:30.82a |
| 4. | Riley DevaneyPlace 4. · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 2:31.09a PR |
| 5. | Geneva AustinPlace 5. · Grade 12 · Cardinal Spellman | 12 | Cardinal Spellman | 2:31.12a |
| 6. | Clementine SweeneyPlace 6. · Grade 10 · Ursuline School (NY) | 10 | Ursuline School (NY) | 2:34.36a |
| 7. | Najea SmithPlace 7. · Grade 11 · Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 11 | Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 2:37.74a PR |
| 8. | Amelia TrejgisPlace 8. · Grade 9 · Monsignor McClancy | 9 | Monsignor McClancy | 2:37.76a PR |
| 9. | Chloe DufaillyPlace 9. · Grade 9 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 9 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 2:39.10a |
| 10. | Terri GundermanPlace 10. · Grade 9 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 9 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 2:41.67a PR |
| 11. | Janae AvilesPlace 11. · Grade 11 · Monsignor Scanlan | 11 | Monsignor Scanlan | 2:42.30a PR |
| 12. | Liyah BryantPlace 12. · Grade 11 · Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 11 | Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 2:44.56a |
| 13. | Aya ZaherPlace 13. · Grade 10 · Midwood | 10 | Midwood | 2:45.98a PR |
| 14. | Melanie Romero CruzPlace 14. · Grade 12 · Sacred Heart | 12 | Sacred Heart | 2:46.08a |
| 15. | Camille CruzPlace 15. · Grade 11 · Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 11 | Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 2:47.43a |
| 16. | Liliana WinPlace 16. · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 2:47.83a |
| 17. | Moriah WalkerPlace 17. · Grade 12 · Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 12 | Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 2:47.87a PR |
| 18. | Caitlin SetnessPlace 18. · Grade 9 · Ursuline School (NY) | 9 | Ursuline School (NY) | 2:51.33a PR |
| 19. | Elizabeth MunozPlace 19. · Grade 9 · Archbishop Molloy | 9 | Archbishop Molloy | 2:53.38a |
| 20. | Juliana CollacoPlace 20. · Grade 9 · Monsignor McClancy | 9 | Monsignor McClancy | 2:54.42a |
| 21. | Kaitlyn DeleonPlace 21. · Grade 11 · Monsignor Scanlan | 11 | Monsignor Scanlan | 2:54.79a |
| 22. | Caroline RuessPlace 22. · Grade 9 · Xaverian | 9 | Xaverian | 2:55.53a |
| 23. | Gianna GonzalezPlace 23. · Grade 11 · Archbishop Molloy | 11 | Archbishop Molloy | 2:55.65a |
| 24. | Princesse PierrePlace 24. · Grade 9 · Midwood | 9 | Midwood | 2:55.66a |
| 25. | Madison ForbesPlace 25. · Grade 11 · Cardinal Spellman | 11 | Cardinal Spellman | 2:55.88a |
| 26. | Emma HlinkaPlace 26. · Grade 10 · Xaverian | 10 | Xaverian | 2:56.09a PR |
| 27. | Kyla WestonPlace 27. · Grade 9 · Cardinal Spellman | 9 | Cardinal Spellman | 2:56.19a |
| 28. | Julia HegartyPlace 28. · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 2:56.85a |
| 29. | Lena OlkPlace 29. · Grade 9 · Monsignor McClancy | 9 | Monsignor McClancy | 2:58.45a PR |
| 30. | Isabelle AlexandrePlace 30. · Grade 10 · Midwood | 10 | Midwood | 2:59.23a |
| 31. | Sarah KohanPlace 31. · Grade 10 · Xaverian | 10 | Xaverian | 2:59.81a PR |
| 32. | Gianna PiccirilloPlace 32. · Grade 10 · Xaverian | 10 | Xaverian | 2:59.86a PR |
| 33. | Madi VincenziPlace 33. · Grade 12 · Monsignor McClancy | 12 | Monsignor McClancy | 3:00.24a |
| 34. | Eliana CasianoPlace 34. · Grade 9 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 9 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 3:01.02a |
| 35. | Cindy ChinPlace 35. · Grade 12 · Archbishop Molloy | 12 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:01.90a |
| 36. | Ava FescinaPlace 36. · Grade 9 · Archbishop Molloy | 9 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:02.13a |
| 37. | Victoria CarbonePlace 37. · Grade 11 · Archbishop Molloy | 11 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:02.75a |
| 38. | Gabrielle TaylorPlace 38. · Grade 12 · Cardinal Spellman | 12 | Cardinal Spellman | 3:03.08a |
| 39. | Kavya MahindruPlace 39. · Grade 11 · Ursuline School (NY) | 11 | Ursuline School (NY) | 3:04.73a |
| 40. | Ava ColuccioPlace 40. · Grade 9 · Xaverian | 9 | Xaverian | 3:06.64a |
| 41. | Arianna Pacheco VasquezPlace 41. · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:06.71a PR |
| 42. | Sophia AlmontePlace 42. · Grade 11 · Archbishop Molloy | 11 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:07.17a |
| 43. | Amelia TyszukPlace 43. · Grade 9 · Monsignor McClancy | 9 | Monsignor McClancy | 3:08.71a PR |
| 44. | Sofia WisemanPlace 44. · Grade 12 · Archbishop Molloy | 12 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:09.05a |
| 45. | Bettie SchwartzPlace 45. · Grade 9 · Archbishop Molloy | 9 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:13.08a PR |
| 46. | Amelia BonillaPlace 46. · Grade 11 · Franklin (Jersey City) | 11 | Franklin (Jersey City) | 3:13.12a |
| 47. | Valentina CalabresePlace 47. · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:13.89a |
| 48. | Alexandra WalshPlace 48. · Grade 9 · Archbishop Molloy | 9 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:15.19a |
| 49. | Victoria MartinezPlace 49. · Grade 9 · Archbishop Molloy | 9 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:19.40a PR |
| 50. | Isabella PortuhondoPlace 50. · Grade 11 · Christ The King | 11 | Christ The King | 3:27.68a PR |
| 51. | Alyssa TupsaitongPlace 51. · Grade 9 · Archbishop Molloy | 9 | Archbishop Molloy | 3:55.88a PR |
| 52. | Abby TuckmanPlace 52. · Grade 9 · Franklin (Jersey City) | 9 | Franklin (Jersey City) | 3:58.73a |