| 1. | Melvin HodgePlace 1. · Grade Sr · Illinois College | Sr | Illinois College | 60.39m |
| 2. | Quinn SholarPlace 2. · Grade Sr · Wabash | Sr | Wabash | 55.21m |
| 3. | Lane BrockmanPlace 3. · Grade Sr · Wabash | Sr | Wabash | 52.75m PR |
| 4. | Deon RodgersPlace 4. · Grade Sr · Illinois College | Sr | Illinois College | 51.35m |
| 5. | Griffin MartinPlace 5. · Grade So · Illinois College | So | Illinois College | 50.60m PR |
| 6. | Jordan TatePlace 6. · Grade So · Wabash | So | Wabash | 50.32m |
| 7. | Evan FurunessPlace 7. · Grade Sr · Wabash | Sr | Wabash | 49.82m |
| 8. | Ian MurphyPlace 8. · Grade So · Washington (Mo.) | So | Washington (Mo.) | 49.43m PR |
| 9. | Tristan BenskinPlace 9. · Grade Jr · Saint Mary-of-the-Woods (Ind.) | Jr | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods (Ind.) | 48.59m PR |
| 10. | Joey HuizengaPlace 10. · Grade Sr · Millikin | Sr | Millikin | 48.47m PR |
| 11. | Hunter DanberryPlace 11. · Grade Jr · Millikin | Jr | Millikin | 48.11m |
| 12. | Mark FisherPlace 12. · Grade Sr · Principia | Sr | Principia | 47.83m PR |
| 13. | Will BoasPlace 13. · Grade Sr · Wabash | Sr | Wabash | 47.68m |
| 14. | Lane MilnerPlace 14. · Grade Fr · Saint Mary-of-the-Woods (Ind.) | Fr | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods (Ind.) | 45.04m PR |
| 15. | Jacob GusePlace 15. · Grade Jr · Wabash | Jr | Wabash | 44.82m |
| 16. | Joseph ZoellnerPlace 16. · Grade So · Millikin | So | Millikin | 43.67m |
| 17. | Matthew WilsonPlace 17. · Grade So · McKendree | So | McKendree | 43.08m |
| 18. | Eric MitchellPlace 18. · Grade So · Greenville | So | Greenville | 42.95m |
| 19. | Thomas PenaPlace 19. · Grade Fr · Illinois College | Fr | Illinois College | 42.63m |
| 20. | Marc-Quan DanielsPlace 20. · Grade Sr · Principia | Sr | Principia | 42.48m |
| 21. | Cleon SewellPlace 21. · Grade Fr · McKendree | Fr | McKendree | 42.31m PR |
| 22. | Leland BranstnerPlace 22. · Grade Fr · Blackburn | Fr | Blackburn | 42.22m |
| 23. | Jerahmia SmithPlace 23. · Grade Sr · Saint Mary-of-the-Woods (Ind.) | Sr | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods (Ind.) | 42.14m |
| 24. | Antonio GonzalezPlace 24. · Grade Sr · McKendree | Sr | McKendree | 42.03m |
| 25. | Hunter TriplettPlace 25. · Grade Fr · Greenville | Fr | Greenville | 40.62m PR |
| 26. | Jakob Van PeltPlace 26. · Grade So · Wabash | So | Wabash | 39.00m |
| 27. | Ashtun BakerPlace 27. · Grade Fr · Principia | Fr | Principia | 36.71m |
| 28. | Spencer WallPlace 28. · Grade So · Millikin | So | Millikin | 35.66m PR |
| 29. | Mauro PabloPlace 29. · Grade Jr · Wabash | Jr | Wabash | 34.53m |
| 30. | Josh WienkePlace 30. · Grade Fr · Greenville | Fr | Greenville | 33.90m |
| 31. | Kristofer St ClairPlace 31. · Grade So · Health Sciences and Pharmacy (MO) | So | Health Sciences and Pharmacy (MO) | 32.82m |
| 32. | Abdul-Rahman EnninPlace 32. · Grade Fr · Wabash | Fr | Wabash | 32.19m |
| 33. | Scott CookPlace 33. · Grade Fr · Washington (Mo.) | Fr | Washington (Mo.) | 31.84m |
| 34. | Tyler StandridgePlace 34. · Grade Fr · Principia | Fr | Principia | 31.58m |
| 35. | Robbie VavrikPlace 35. · Grade So · Millikin | So | Millikin | 30.72m |
| 36. | Max RosaPlace 36. · Grade Sr · Wabash | Sr | Wabash | 29.82m |
| 37. | Cole LenczyckiPlace 37. · Grade So · Greenville | So | Greenville | 26.32m PR |
| 38. | Brandon PetersPlace 38. · Grade So · Millikin | So | Millikin | 23.12m |
| — | Jahrel Claude-EnninGrade So · Webster | So | Webster | DNS |
| — | Nate HendersonGrade So · Illinois Wesleyan | So | Illinois Wesleyan | FOUL |
