| 1. | Zachary GuberPlace 1. · Grade 12 · St Anthony's | 12 | St Anthony's | 4:32.36a |
| 2. | Matthew PenaPlace 2. · Grade 11 · Sachem North | 11 | Sachem North | 4:35.40a PR |
| 3. | Matteo RitieniPlace 3. · Grade 11 · Ward Melville | 11 | Ward Melville | 4:36.16a |
| 4. | Sean GrossmanPlace 4. · Grade 11 · Port Jefferson (Earl Vandermeulen) | 11 | Port Jefferson (Earl Vandermeulen) | 4:36.75a |
| 5. | Matthew HeffernanPlace 5. · Grade 11 · Commack | 11 | Commack | 4:37.68a PR |
| 6. | Joshua BergPlace 6. · Grade 11 · St Anthony's | 11 | St Anthony's | 4:44.35a PR |
| 7. | Jordan CambriaPlace 7. · Grade 10 · Commack | 10 | Commack | 4:44.54a PR |
| 8. | Jack HanrattyPlace 8. · Grade 12 · Commack | 12 | Commack | 4:47.37a PR |
| 9. | John ColucciPlace 9. · Grade 10 · Ward Melville | 10 | Ward Melville | 4:47.55a |
| 10. | Colin JenningsPlace 10. · Grade 12 · Patchogue/Medford | 12 | Patchogue/Medford | 4:48.42a |
| 11. | Thomas WightmanPlace 11. · Grade 11 · Smithtown West | 11 | Smithtown West | 4:48.57a |
| 12. | Tyler HoriuchiPlace 12. · Grade 11 · Stuyvesant | 11 | Stuyvesant | 4:48.74a |
| 13. | Shivam ShirazPlace 13. · Grade 10 · Sachem North | 10 | Sachem North | 4:48.97a |
| 14. | Josh LathamPlace 14. · Grade 11 · Ward Melville | 11 | Ward Melville | 4:49.18a PR |
| 15. | Christopher NasserPlace 15. · Grade 11 · Commack | 11 | Commack | 4:50.98a PR |
| 16. | Daniel RodriguezPlace 16. · Grade 12 · St Anthony's | 12 | St Anthony's | 4:51.26a PR |
| 17. | William SmithPlace 17. · Grade 11 · Smithtown West | 11 | Smithtown West | 4:51.81a |
| 18. | Brycen RicciPlace 18. · Grade 9 · Harborfields | 9 | Harborfields | 4:52.75a |
| 19. | Alexander BassPlace 19. · Grade 12 · Walt Whitman | 12 | Walt Whitman | 4:53.36a |
| 20. | Ryan AguilaPlace 20. · Grade 9 · Bayport Blue Point | 9 | Bayport Blue Point | 4:53.57a |
| 21. | Nolan MurrayPlace 21. · Grade 10 · Commack | 10 | Commack | 4:53.61a PR |
| 22. | Evan RizzoPlace 22. · Grade 10 · Babylon | 10 | Babylon | 4:54.40a |
| 23. | Jayden YoonPlace 23. · Grade 10 · Ward Melville | 10 | Ward Melville | 4:54.87a PR |
| 24. | Paul DiPaolaPlace 24. · Grade 11 · Harborfields | 11 | Harborfields | 4:56.15a PR |
| 25. | Caden EspositoPlace 25. · Grade 8 · Ward Melville | 8 | Ward Melville | 4:56.66a |
| 26. | Joziah DavisPlace 26. · Grade 11 · Half Hollow Hills East | 11 | Half Hollow Hills East | 4:57.18a PR |
| 27. | Patrick TaylorPlace 27. · Grade 11 · Sachem North | 11 | Sachem North | 4:57.18a PR |
| 28. | Jude KidonakisPlace 28. · Grade 9 · Commack | 9 | Commack | 4:58.27a PR |
| 29. | Nicholas GuariniPlace 29. · Grade 10 · Walt Whitman | 10 | Walt Whitman | 4:58.91a PR |
| 30. | Lester SoyosPlace 30. · Grade 12 · Riverhead | 12 | Riverhead | 4:59.60a |
| 31. | David DubonPlace 31. · Grade 11 · Riverhead | 11 | Riverhead | 4:59.83a |
| 32. | Matthew SchabePlace 32. · Grade 9 · Deer Park | 9 | Deer Park | 5:00.44a |
| 33. | Diego MartinezPlace 33. · Grade 12 · Ward Melville | 12 | Ward Melville | 5:00.48a PR |
| 34. | Randy ChenPlace 34. · Grade 11 · Ward Melville | 11 | Ward Melville | 5:01.51a PR |
| 35. | Patrick Cannone IIIPlace 35. · Grade 11 · Half Hollow Hills West | 11 | Half Hollow Hills West | 5:03.68a |
| 36. | Braylin FlorianPlace 36. · Grade 10 · Riverhead | 10 | Riverhead | 5:03.97a PR |
| 37. | Gabriel StavitskiPlace 37. · Grade 9 · Ward Melville | 9 | Ward Melville | 5:04.71a PR |
| 38. | Ethan PrinzPlace 38. · Grade 10 · The Stony Brook | 10 | The Stony Brook | 5:05.42a |
| 39. | Jack TripoliPlace 39. · Grade 11 · Walt Whitman | 11 | Walt Whitman | 5:05.78a PR |
| 40. | Brody WilsonPlace 40. · Grade 12 · St Anthony's | 12 | St Anthony's | 5:06.78a |
| 41. | Ethan AbreuPlace 41. · Grade 10 · Walt Whitman | 10 | Walt Whitman | 5:07.34a PR |
| 42. | Lucas JohnsonPlace 42. · Grade 11 · Ward Melville | 11 | Ward Melville | 5:07.69a PR |
| 43. | Brighton PerduePlace 43. · Grade 10 · Smithtown East | 10 | Smithtown East | 5:09.06a |
| 44. | Jake ThelianPlace 44. · Grade 10 · Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 10 | Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 5:09.24a PR |
| 45. | Matthew RussottoPlace 45. · Grade 10 · Walt Whitman | 10 | Walt Whitman | 5:09.57a PR |
| 46. | Mason D'AulerioPlace 46. · Grade 11 · The Stony Brook | 11 | The Stony Brook | 5:11.52a PR |
| 47. | Brendan TheisenPlace 47. · Grade 11 · St John The Baptist | 11 | St John The Baptist | 5:11.66a |
| 48. | Jon SommoPlace 48. · Grade 12 · Commack | 12 | Commack | 5:11.77a |
| 49. | William TunsteadPlace 49. · Grade 10 · Ward Melville | 10 | Ward Melville | 5:11.89a |
| 50. | Ethan LiuPlace 50. · Grade 9 · Ward Melville | 9 | Ward Melville | 5:12.53a PR |
| 51. | Liam RileyPlace 51. · Grade 11 · The Stony Brook | 11 | The Stony Brook | 5:13.26a PR |
| 52. | Nathen PeinadoPlace 52. · Grade 9 · Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 9 | Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 5:13.38a |
| 53. | Luca RitieniPlace 53. · Grade 9 · Ward Melville | 9 | Ward Melville | 5:13.65a PR |
| 54. | Robert John KalinPlace 54. · Grade 12 · Miller Place | 12 | Miller Place | 5:14.00a |
| 55. | Lucas Del CarpioPlace 55. · Grade 8 · Ward Melville | 8 | Ward Melville | 5:14.12a PR |
| 56. | Tyler BalcanPlace 56. · Grade 10 · Half Hollow Hills East | 10 | Half Hollow Hills East | 5:14.49a |
| 57. | James PaoliniPlace 57. · Grade 10 · Sachem North | 10 | Sachem North | 5:15.79a |
| 58. | John TimpanaroPlace 58. · Grade 11 · Ward Melville | 11 | Ward Melville | 5:15.82a |
| 59. | Tate GhizPlace 59. · Grade 9 · Ward Melville | 9 | Ward Melville | 5:16.03a PR |
| 60. | Brady NoonPlace 60. · Grade 12 · Bayport Blue Point | 12 | Bayport Blue Point | 5:16.53a |
| 61. | Brayan Chacon CarbajalPlace 61. · Grade 10 · Riverhead | 10 | Riverhead | 5:16.62a |
| 62. | Delron JonesPlace 62. · Grade 11 · Patchogue/Medford | 11 | Patchogue/Medford | 5:16.64a PR |
| 63. | Ezra PewPlace 63. · Grade 9 · Ward Melville | 9 | Ward Melville | 5:17.32a |
| 64. | Nathan HuntingtonPlace 64. · Grade 12 · Riverhead | 12 | Riverhead | 5:18.70a PR |
| 65. | Alex ReegerPlace 65. · Grade 12 · Harborfields | 12 | Harborfields | 5:19.89a PR |
| 66. | Dylan HerathPlace 66. · Grade 11 · Half Hollow Hills East | 11 | Half Hollow Hills East | 5:20.15a |
| 67. | Ryan DreyerPlace 67. · Grade 10 · Ward Melville | 10 | Ward Melville | 5:21.24a |
| 68. | Matthew LaubPlace 68. · Grade 12 · Smithtown East | 12 | Smithtown East | 5:22.04a |
| 69. | Sean WhelanPlace 69. · Grade 10 · Harborfields | 10 | Harborfields | 5:22.78a PR |
| 70. | Jake BrothertonPlace 70. · Grade 10 · Ward Melville | 10 | Ward Melville | 5:22.93a PR |
| 71. | William BellePlace 71. · Grade 9 · Half Hollow Hills West | 9 | Half Hollow Hills West | 5:23.67a |
| 72. | Angel ChavezPlace 72. · Grade 9 · Half Hollow Hills West | 9 | Half Hollow Hills West | 5:24.72a |
| 73. | Alvin Castillo GironPlace 73. · Grade 10 · Riverhead | 10 | Riverhead | 5:25.24a |
| 74. | Jacob MincozziPlace 74. · Grade 9 · Sachem North | 9 | Sachem North | 5:25.36a |
| 75. | Jose Boch ChamalePlace 75. · Grade 10 · Riverhead | 10 | Riverhead | 5:25.56a PR |
| 76. | Alexander AlnwickPlace 76. · Grade 12 · Smithtown West | 12 | Smithtown West | 5:26.51a |
| 77. | Franklin SebastianPlace 77. · Grade 10 · Riverhead | 10 | Riverhead | 5:26.70a |
| 78. | Talon ZizolfoPlace 78. · Grade 10 · Patchogue/Medford | 10 | Patchogue/Medford | 5:27.55a |
| 79. | Johnathan DavisPlace 79. · Grade 10 · Riverhead | 10 | Riverhead | 5:28.47a |
| 80. | Jackson FerraraPlace 80. · Grade 8 · Miller Place | 8 | Miller Place | 5:28.47a |
| 81. | Nathan TrainaPlace 81. · Grade 9 · Harborfields | 9 | Harborfields | 5:32.20a PR |
| 82. | Ronan CareyPlace 82. · Grade 9 · Smithtown East | 9 | Smithtown East | 5:32.99a PR |
| 83. | Abeesh SahniPlace 83. · Grade 9 · Half Hollow Hills East | 9 | Half Hollow Hills East | 5:37.94a |
| 84. | Kyle ReedyPlace 84. · Grade 10 · Commack | 10 | Commack | 5:38.59a PR |
| 85. | Ryan TreubigPlace 85. · Grade 10 · Walt Whitman | 10 | Walt Whitman | 5:41.10a PR |
| 86. | Alex RodasPlace 86. · Grade 10 · Sachem North | 10 | Sachem North | 5:42.19a |
| 87. | Jose Gonzalez-IgnacioPlace 87. · Grade 11 · Riverhead | 11 | Riverhead | 5:43.28a PR |
| 88. | Lucas TanenbaumPlace 88. · Grade 11 · Smithtown East | 11 | Smithtown East | 5:44.91a |
| 89. | Gian-Luca SotoPlace 89. · Grade 10 · Walt Whitman | 10 | Walt Whitman | 5:48.03a |
| 90. | Alex RandazzoPlace 90. · Grade 9 · Smithtown East | 9 | Smithtown East | 6:16.95a PR |
| 91. | Jack VinbergPlace 91. · Grade 9 · Smithtown East | 9 | Smithtown East | 6:24.40a |
| 92. | Daniel DepaloPlace 92. · Grade 10 · Walt Whitman | 10 | Walt Whitman | 6:26.08a PR |
| -- | Anthony AlbanesePlace -- · Grade 12 · Smithtown East | 12 | Smithtown East | DQ |