| 1. | Matthew CarranoPlace 1. · Grade 12 · St Peters Boys | 12 | St Peters Boys | 4:33.67a PR |
| 2. | Samuel FrankPlace 2. · Grade 11 · Xaverian | 11 | Xaverian | 4:37.72a PR |
| 3. | Lorenzo PantaleoPlace 3. · Grade 11 · St Francis Prep | 11 | St Francis Prep | 4:37.80a PR |
| 4. | Henry BissellPlace 4. · Grade 10 · John Jay Campus | 10 | John Jay Campus | 4:38.25a PR |
| 5. | Gabe PonichterPlace 5. · Grade 12 · Dalton | 12 | Dalton | 4:42.93a PR |
| 6. | Anthony CarlinoPlace 6. · Grade 12 · Monsignor McClancy | 12 | Monsignor McClancy | 4:43.43a PR |
| 7. | Aidan McClurePlace 7. · Grade 12 · Regis | 12 | Regis | 4:43.68a PR |
| 8. | Marco ArrojoPlace 8. · Grade 10 · Lab Museum United | 10 | Lab Museum United | 4:47.87a PR |
| 9. | Jonah Fox-chmielewskiPlace 9. · Grade 10 · Queens Complex | 10 | Queens Complex | 4:50.82a PR |
| 10. | Aidan ShrekastPlace 10. · Grade 11 · Regis | 11 | Regis | 4:50.89a PR |
| 11. | Dylan MompointPlace 11. · Grade 12 · Archbishop Molloy | 12 | Archbishop Molloy | 4:52.73a PR |
| 12. | Amir AllyPlace 12. · Grade 12 · Archbishop Molloy | 12 | Archbishop Molloy | 5:04.39a PR |
| 13. | Jeremy JimenezPlace 13. · Grade 12 · Christ The King | 12 | Christ The King | 5:04.78a PR |
| 14. | Jonathan ReissPlace 14. · Grade 12 · Archbishop Molloy | 12 | Archbishop Molloy | 5:09.03a PR |
| 15. | Jack LombardoPlace 15. · Grade 11 · Archbishop Molloy | 11 | Archbishop Molloy | 5:09.64a PR |
| 16. | Jaisimha DattatreyanPlace 16. · Grade 10 · Lab Museum United | 10 | Lab Museum United | 5:09.67a PR |
| 17. | Andres Felip CastrillonPlace 17. · Grade 9 · Townsend Harris | 9 | Townsend Harris | 5:10.14a PR |
| 18. | Denis AcostaPlace 18. · Grade 11 · Regis | 11 | Regis | 5:10.29a |
| 19. | Daniel CollinsPlace 19. · Grade 11 · Xaverian | 11 | Xaverian | 5:12.51a PR |
| 20. | Sean Del GrossoPlace 20. · Grade 12 · Archbishop Molloy | 12 | Archbishop Molloy | 5:12.93a PR |
| 21. | Sebastian Ivaldi-QuintaniPlace 21. · Grade 10 · The Baccalaureate School for Global Education | 10 | The Baccalaureate School for Global Education | 5:14.61a PR |
| 22. | Connor DonoghuePlace 22. · Grade 11 · Regis | 11 | Regis | 5:18.52a PR |
| 23. | Andrew LwinPlace 23. · Grade 11 · The Baccalaureate School for Global Education | 11 | The Baccalaureate School for Global Education | 5:39.05a PR |
| 24. | Ryan KielyPlace 24. · Grade 11 · Fordham Prep | 11 | Fordham Prep | 5:44.35a PR |
| 25. | Peter CoughlinPlace 25. · Grade 9 · Lab Museum United | 9 | Lab Museum United | 5:49.32a PR |
| 26. | Christopher DeckPlace 26. · Grade 12 · Monsignor McClancy | 12 | Monsignor McClancy | 5:49.44a |
| 27. | Pedro PichardoPlace 27. · Grade 11 · St Raymonds-Boys | 11 | St Raymonds-Boys | 5:49.53a PR |
| 28. | Thomas PorcellaPlace 28. · Grade 11 · Regis | 11 | Regis | 5:50.35a PR |
| 29. | Elijah KeshodkarPlace 29. · Grade 9 · The Baccalaureate School for Global Education | 9 | The Baccalaureate School for Global Education | 5:51.75a PR |
| 30. | Orion BonetPlace 30. · Grade 12 · St Raymonds-Boys | 12 | St Raymonds-Boys | 6:25.43a PR |
| 31. | James WalshPlace 31. · Grade 11 · Archbishop Molloy | 11 | Archbishop Molloy | 7:11.57a PR |
| 32. | Branden YoungPlace 32. · Grade 12 · Fordham Prep | 12 | Fordham Prep | 7:13.68a PR |