| 1. | Alfie AdamsPlace 1. · Grade 10 · Hackley | 10 | Hackley | 1:52.90a |
| 2. | Henry FrascaPlace 2. · Grade 11 · The Masters | 11 | The Masters | 1:53.30a |
| 3. | Dorsey Smith Sr.Place 3. · Grade 12 · Poly Prep Country Day | 12 | Poly Prep Country Day | 1:57.30a PR |
| 4. | Baker BrodliebPlace 4. · Grade 11 · The Browning | 11 | The Browning | 1:59.43a PR |
| 5. | Lucas RosadoPlace 5. · Grade 10 · Riverdale Country | 10 | Riverdale Country | 2:00.12a |
| 6. | Bryson SylvainPlace 6. · Grade 10 · Poly Prep Country Day | 10 | Poly Prep Country Day | 2:00.81a |
| 7. | Kyler CalderonPlace 7. · Grade 11 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 11 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 2:01.01a PR |
| 8. | James BullPlace 8. · Grade 12 · The Masters | 12 | The Masters | 2:01.01a PR |
| 9. | Leo BeirnePlace 9. · Grade 12 · St Anns | 12 | St Anns | 2:01.60a |
| 10. | Eytan GoldbergPlace 10. · Grade 9 · Poly Prep Country Day | 9 | Poly Prep Country Day | 2:01.65a PR |
| 11. | Jack SlovinPlace 11. · Grade 10 · Rye Country Day | 10 | Rye Country Day | 2:02.13a |
| 12. | Charles SylofskiPlace 12. · Grade 10 · The Loyola-NYC | 10 | The Loyola-NYC | 2:03.28a PR |
| 13. | Cooper MorgensternPlace 13. · Grade 11 · Horace Mann | 11 | Horace Mann | 2:03.69a PR |
| 14. | William StitesPlace 14. · Grade 10 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 10 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 2:03.91a PR |
| 15. | Spencer KojimaPlace 15. · Grade 12 · Collegiate | 12 | Collegiate | 2:04.90a |
| 16. | Kabeer AroraPlace 16. · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 2:07.18a PR |
| 17. | Michael BaezPlace 17. · Grade 11 · Hackley | 11 | Hackley | 2:07.45a |
| 18. | Leo McHughPlace 18. · Grade 10 · Friends Seminary | 10 | Friends Seminary | 2:07.71a |
| 19. | Roman TackneyPlace 19. · Grade 12 · Riverdale Country | 12 | Riverdale Country | 2:08.74a |
| 20. | Kayden MowryPlace 20. · Grade 10 · Albany Academy for Boys & Girls | 10 | Albany Academy for Boys & Girls | 2:08.84a |
| 21. | Wesley SmithPlace 21. · Grade 11 · Avenues: The World | 11 | Avenues: The World | 2:08.95a PR |
| 22. | Miles AlbanoPlace 22. · Grade 8 · Columbia Grammar & Prep | 8 | Columbia Grammar & Prep | 2:09.51a PR |
| 23. | Lucas Kadio-MorokroPlace 23. · Grade 10 · Lycee Francais de New York | 10 | Lycee Francais de New York | 2:09.53a PR |
| 24. | Jacob MarinerPlace 24. · Grade 10 · Long Island Lutheran | 10 | Long Island Lutheran | 2:10.36a PR |
| 25. | Sam FerragutoPlace 25. · Grade 11 · Avenues: The World | 11 | Avenues: The World | 2:11.03a PR |
| 26. | Arman MasjediPlace 26. · Grade 8 · Berkeley Carroll | 8 | Berkeley Carroll | 2:11.19a |
| 27. | David LusmanPlace 27. · Grade 9 · Rye Country Day | 9 | Rye Country Day | 2:11.52a |
| 28. | Gabriel De las herasPlace 28. · Grade 11 · Lycee Francais de New York | 11 | Lycee Francais de New York | 2:11.67a PR |
| 29. | David LarenaPlace 29. · Grade 11 · Riverdale Country | 11 | Riverdale Country | 2:11.97a PR |
| 30. | Nicky AcquistaPlace 30. · Grade 10 · Avenues: The World | 10 | Avenues: The World | 2:12.10a PR |
| 31. | Zachary (Zach) StennettPlace 31. · Grade 11 · Portledge | 11 | Portledge | 2:12.75a PR |
| 32. | Liam RileyPlace 32. · Grade 11 · The Stony Brook | 11 | The Stony Brook | 2:13.29a |
| 33. | Mason D'AulerioPlace 33. · Grade 11 · The Stony Brook | 11 | The Stony Brook | 2:13.33a |
| 34. | Nathan KooPlace 34. · Grade 11 · Trevor Day School | 11 | Trevor Day School | 2:15.58a |
| 35. | Ben HelfsteinPlace 35. · Grade 10 · The Birch Wathen Lenox | 10 | The Birch Wathen Lenox | 2:17.42a |
| 36. | Brandon Day-PittsPlace 36. · Grade 8 · Rye Country Day | 8 | Rye Country Day | 2:17.76a |
| 37. | Ben ShehigianPlace 37. · Grade 11 · Long Island Lutheran | 11 | Long Island Lutheran | 2:18.98a |
| 38. | Sam MwangaguhungaPlace 38. · Grade 9 · Collegiate | 9 | Collegiate | 2:19.87a |
| 39. | William NeumannPlace 39. · Grade 12 · Grace Church | 12 | Grace Church | 2:20.03a |
| 40. | Clyde RiffaterrePlace 40. · Grade 10 · The Dwight | 10 | The Dwight | 2:20.54a |
| 41. | Konrad WagnerPlace 41. · Grade 10 · The Masters | 10 | The Masters | 2:20.99a |
| 42. | Malo LimpalaerPlace 42. · Grade 8 · Lycee Francais de New York | 8 | Lycee Francais de New York | 2:21.07a |
| 43. | Alex ManganPlace 43. · Grade 10 · The Loyola-NYC | 10 | The Loyola-NYC | 2:22.32a |
| 44. | Julien EhrenkranzPlace 44. · Grade 10 · Grace Church | 10 | Grace Church | 2:23.43a |
| 45. | Julian MannPlace 45. · Grade 12 · Hackley | 12 | Hackley | 2:23.45a |