| 1. | Alexander LositoPlace 1. · Grade 9 · Smithtown West | 9 | Smithtown West | 2:06.58a | 10 |
| 2. | Sawyer BrummPlace 2. · Grade 9 · Northport | 9 | Northport | 2:07.53a | 8 |
| 3. | Lennie Carter IIIPlace 3. · Grade 9 · Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 9 | Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 2:08.11a | 6 |
| 4. | Tristan RiveraPlace 4. · Grade 9 · North Babylon | 9 | North Babylon | 2:13.20a PR | 4 |
| 5. | Eduardo Angel ReyesPlace 5. · Grade 9 · Brentwood | 9 | Brentwood | 2:13.47a PR | 2 |
| 6. | Garv PatelPlace 6. · Grade 9 · Sachem East | 9 | Sachem East | 2:15.41a PR | 1 |
| 7. | Patrick FreeburgPlace 7. · Grade 9 · Kings Park | 9 | Kings Park | 2:18.92a PR | — |
| 8. | Collin MulliganPlace 8. · Grade 9 · Bay Shore | 9 | Bay Shore | 2:19.51a PR | — |
| 9. | Tavon AmayaPlace 9. · Grade 9 · North Babylon | 9 | North Babylon | 2:19.80a PR | — |
| 10. | Jamison GargiuloPlace 10. · Grade 9 · Mount Sinai | 9 | Mount Sinai | 2:20.46a | — |
| 11. | Ryan AguilaPlace 11. · Grade 9 · Bayport Blue Point | 9 | Bayport Blue Point | 2:20.70a | — |
| 12. | John McInerneyPlace 12. · Grade 9 · Kings Park | 9 | Kings Park | 2:21.79a PR | — |
| 13. | Logan BaumannPlace 13. · Grade 9 · Lindenhurst | 9 | Lindenhurst | 2:22.51a PR | — |
| 14. | William MalvettiPlace 14. · Grade 9 · Rocky Point | 9 | Rocky Point | 2:23.01a PR | — |
| 15. | Vincent MejiaPlace 15. · Grade 9 · Comsewogue | 9 | Comsewogue | 2:23.40a PR | — |
| 16. | Noah StolfiPlace 16. · Grade 9 · Sachem North | 9 | Sachem North | 2:25.31a PR | — |
| 17. | Nathen PeinadoPlace 17. · Grade 9 · Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 9 | Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 2:26.95a | — |
| 18. | Mason StebaliPlace 18. · Grade 9 · Northport | 9 | Northport | 2:27.03a PR | — |
| 19. | William Cruz PaezPlace 19. · Grade 9 · North Babylon | 9 | North Babylon | 2:30.22a PR | — |
| 20. | Harrison DavisPlace 20. · Grade 9 · North Babylon | 9 | North Babylon | 2:30.52a PR | — |
| 21. | Austin FauntleroyPlace 21. · Grade 9 · North Babylon | 9 | North Babylon | 2:31.36a PR | — |
| 22. | Michael StahlPlace 22. · Grade 9 · Longwood | 9 | Longwood | 2:31.58a PR | — |
| 23. | Frank TaldonePlace 23. · Grade 9 · Half Hollow Hills East | 9 | Half Hollow Hills East | 2:32.27a PR | — |
| 24. | Jason ArnoldPlace 24. · Grade 9 · Patchogue/Medford | 9 | Patchogue/Medford | 2:32.40a PR | — |
| 25. | Noah HansenPlace 25. · Grade 9 · Smithtown East | 9 | Smithtown East | 2:32.79a | — |
| 26. | Justice MillerPlace 26. · Grade 9 · Sachem East | 9 | Sachem East | 2:33.18a PR | — |
| 27. | Neil RajpalPlace 27. · Grade 9 · Half Hollow Hills West | 9 | Half Hollow Hills West | 2:33.87a PR | — |
| 28. | Nicholas HerbstPlace 28. · Grade 9 · Hauppauge | 9 | Hauppauge | 2:34.63a PR | — |
| 29. | Drew HillPlace 29. · Grade 9 · Commack | 9 | Commack | 2:36.07a PR | — |
| 30. | Peter NkumPlace 30. · Grade 9 · Brentwood | 9 | Brentwood | 2:37.04a PR | — |
| 31. | Zachary NgPlace 31. · Grade 9 · Northport | 9 | Northport | 2:37.29a PR | — |
| 32. | Klever SanchezPlace 32. · Grade 9 · North Babylon | 9 | North Babylon | 2:38.05a PR | — |
| 33. | Andrew TrifoliPlace 33. · Grade 9 · Bay Shore | 9 | Bay Shore | 2:39.72a PR | — |
| 34. | Oliva JosePlace 34. · Grade 9 · Deer Park | 9 | Deer Park | 2:41.23a | — |
| 35. | Padraig MurphyPlace 35. · Grade 9 · Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 9 | Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 2:41.77a PR | — |
| 36. | Anthony CaliendoPlace 36. · Grade 9 · Bayport Blue Point | 9 | Bayport Blue Point | 2:41.82a | — |
| 37. | Cristian TezenPlace 37. · Grade 9 · Riverhead | 9 | Riverhead | 2:43.05a PR | — |
| 38. | Crosby CadmusPlace 38. · Grade 9 · Hauppauge | 9 | Hauppauge | 2:43.45a PR | — |
| 39. | James McAleaveyPlace 39. · Grade 9 · Babylon | 9 | Babylon | 2:43.55a PR | — |
| 40. | Osmel MayenPlace 40. · Grade 9 · Riverhead | 9 | Riverhead | 2:43.63a PR | — |
| 41. | Ian LeonidasPlace 41. · Grade 9 · North Babylon | 9 | North Babylon | 2:43.64a PR | — |
| 42. | Adrian ColladoPlace 42. · Grade 9 · Wg Oconnell-Copiague | 9 | Wg Oconnell-Copiague | 2:44.52a | — |
| 43. | James KlimpelPlace 43. · Grade 9 · Bay Shore | 9 | Bay Shore | 2:45.02a PR | — |
| 44. | Kyle DennistonPlace 44. · Grade 9 · Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 9 | Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 2:49.17a PR | — |
| 45. | Thomas ScaliciPlace 45. · Grade 9 · Northport | 9 | Northport | 2:50.13a PR | — |
| 46. | Craiston WilliamsPlace 46. · Grade 9 · Connetquot | 9 | Connetquot | 2:50.25a PR | — |
| 47. | Michael CoppingerPlace 47. · Grade 9 · East Islip | 9 | East Islip | 2:50.42a PR | — |
| 48. | Liam CheslockPlace 48. · Grade 9 · Patchogue/Medford | 9 | Patchogue/Medford | 2:51.34a PR | — |
| 49. | Caleb MunizPlace 49. · Grade 9 · Connetquot | 9 | Connetquot | 2:55.28a PR | — |
| 50. | Jonathan MillerPlace 50. · Grade 9 · Smithtown West | 9 | Smithtown West | 2:58.11a PR | — |
| 51. | Josh RiveraPlace 51. · Grade 9 · Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 9 | Newfield-Centereach (Middle Country) | 2:58.89a PR | — |
| 52. | Asher TariquePlace 52. · Grade 9 · Half Hollow Hills West | 9 | Half Hollow Hills West | 2:59.19a PR | — |
| 53. | Jack WoodsPlace 53. · Grade 11 · Sachem North | 11 | Sachem North | 3:00.53a PR | — |
| 54. | Aidan LeungPlace 54. · Grade 9 · Connetquot | 9 | Connetquot | 3:02.56a PR | — |
| 55. | Matteo DoylePlace 55. · Grade 9 · Sachem North | 9 | Sachem North | 3:17.02a PR | — |