| 1. | Lucas SilvaPlace 1. · Grade 11 · Union Catholic Reg | 11 | Union Catholic Reg | 1:57.95a |
| 2. | Noah AbdallaPlace 2. · Grade 12 · Governor Livingston | 12 | Governor Livingston | 1:58.99a PR |
| 3. | Christopher YuePlace 3. · Grade 10 · Governor Livingston | 10 | Governor Livingston | 2:00.71a PR |
| 4. | Ivan ZubrinicPlace 4. · Grade 11 · Governor Livingston | 11 | Governor Livingston | 2:02.69a PR |
| 5. | Robert DudleyPlace 5. · Grade 9 · Oratory Prep | 9 | Oratory Prep | 2:02.83a PR |
| 6. | Tommy BasingerPlace 6. · Grade 12 · Seton Hall Prep | 12 | Seton Hall Prep | 2:03.27a PR |
| 7. | Jonah TamayoPlace 7. · Grade 12 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 12 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:03.49a PR |
| 8. | Manny SanchezPlace 8. · Grade 10 · Union Catholic Reg | 10 | Union Catholic Reg | 2:03.56a PR |
| 9. | Jordan HotraPlace 9. · Grade 10 · Oratory Prep | 10 | Oratory Prep | 2:03.91a PR |
| 10. | Ryan Ross-MorreyPlace 10. · Grade 12 · Rahway | 12 | Rahway | 2:05.15a PR |
| 11. | Leandro Garcia PhillipsPlace 11. · Grade 12 · Rahway | 12 | Rahway | 2:05.46a PR |
| 12. | John EsselPlace 12. · Grade 12 · Rahway | 12 | Rahway | 2:06.35a PR |
| 13. | Tyler WeissmanPlace 13. · Grade 12 · Governor Livingston | 12 | Governor Livingston | 2:06.90a PR |
| 14. | Ryan HuttonPlace 14. · Grade 11 · Cranford | 11 | Cranford | 2:07.61a PR |
| 15. | Will RooneyPlace 15. · Grade 11 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 11 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:08.58a PR |
| 16. | Jared BerryPlace 16. · Grade 10 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 10 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:08.68a PR |
| 17. | Dean KeechPlace 17. · Grade 12 · Rahway | 12 | Rahway | 2:09.84a |
| 18. | Alexander HagopianPlace 18. · Grade 11 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 11 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:10.06a PR |
| 19. | Brandon ChristopherPlace 19. · Grade 11 · Rahway | 11 | Rahway | 2:10.21a |
| 20. | Makhi MartinPlace 20. · Grade 11 · Rahway | 11 | Rahway | 2:11.00a PR |
| 21. | Ryan LeBrunPlace 21. · Grade 11 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 11 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:11.10a PR |
| 22. | Sasha ZhukovPlace 22. · Grade 12 · Newark Academy | 12 | Newark Academy | 2:11.32a PR |
| 23. | Henry SalakiPlace 23. · Grade 10 · Oratory Prep | 10 | Oratory Prep | 2:11.62a PR |
| 24. | Stephen PolefkoPlace 24. · Grade 9 · Oratory Prep | 9 | Oratory Prep | 2:11.74a PR |
| 25. | Marty GerbounkaPlace 25. · Grade 10 · Union Catholic Reg | 10 | Union Catholic Reg | 2:11.87a |
| 26. | Russell EschbacherPlace 26. · Grade 11 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 11 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:12.25a |
| 27. | Patrick ParentePlace 27. · Grade 10 · Governor Livingston | 10 | Governor Livingston | 2:12.84a PR |
| 28. | Camilo PorrasPlace 28. · Grade 11 · Oratory Prep | 11 | Oratory Prep | 2:13.23a |
| 29. | Nico CovielloPlace 29. · Grade 11 · Governor Livingston | 11 | Governor Livingston | 2:14.18a PR |
| 30. | Akiles Guimarães-RibeiroPlace 30. · Grade 10 · Rahway | 10 | Rahway | 2:14.55a |
| 31. | Alex AbramsPlace 31. · Grade 12 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 12 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:14.70a PR |
| 32. | Aiden LahrPlace 32. · Grade 9 · Cranford | 9 | Cranford | 2:14.97a PR |
| 33. | Luke LangPlace 33. · Grade 11 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 11 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:15.26a |
| 34. | Chase LynchPlace 34. · Grade 12 · Oratory Prep | 12 | Oratory Prep | 2:15.38a PR |
| 35. | Ben ColettiPlace 35. · Grade 11 · Newark Academy | 11 | Newark Academy | 2:15.51a |
| 36. | Chad VassalloPlace 36. · Grade 10 · Oratory Prep | 10 | Oratory Prep | 2:15.76a PR |
| 37. | Greyson AstlePlace 37. · Grade 9 · Oratory Prep | 9 | Oratory Prep | 2:16.02a |
| 38. | Liam HynesPlace 38. · Grade 9 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 9 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:16.05a |
| 39. | Brandon BurnsPlace 39. · Grade 9 · Union Catholic Reg | 9 | Union Catholic Reg | 2:16.36a PR |
| 40. | Joshua CinquePlace 40. · Grade 9 · Governor Livingston | 9 | Governor Livingston | 2:16.51a PR |
| 41. | Hanzala MohammadPlace 41. · Grade 10 · Rahway | 10 | Rahway | 2:17.53a |
| 42. | Phil KellyPlace 42. · Grade 9 · Oratory Prep | 9 | Oratory Prep | 2:17.88a |
| 43. | Ethan ZhouPlace 43. · Grade 12 · Newark Academy | 12 | Newark Academy | 2:19.36a |
| 44. | Jayden FevrierPlace 44. · Grade 10 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 10 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:19.41a |
| 45. | Matt MalobaPlace 45. · Grade 12 · Oratory Prep | 12 | Oratory Prep | 2:19.46a |
| 46. | Jamison AlvaradoPlace 46. · Grade 9 · Linden | 9 | Linden | 2:21.31a |
| 47. | Harcourt Lucius IIPlace 47. · Grade 10 · Newark Academy | 10 | Newark Academy | 2:21.95a PR |
| 48. | Brody ChasePlace 48. · Grade 10 · Oratory Prep | 10 | Oratory Prep | 2:22.18a PR |
| 49. | Aidan SchobelPlace 49. · Grade 11 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 11 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:22.26a PR |
| 50. | Michael SavarePlace 50. · Grade 12 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 12 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:22.37a PR |
| 51. | Edward TrifanPlace 51. · Grade - · Rahway | - | Rahway | 2:22.90a PR |
| 52. | Nicholas DoranPlace 52. · Grade 10 · Rahway | 10 | Rahway | 2:23.78a |
| 53. | Logan KennedyPlace 53. · Grade 10 · Governor Livingston | 10 | Governor Livingston | 2:24.66a PR |
| 54. | Connor JohnsonPlace 54. · Grade 12 · Governor Livingston | 12 | Governor Livingston | 2:24.72a |
| 55. | Gianluca DomingoPlace 55. · Grade 10 · Governor Livingston | 10 | Governor Livingston | 2:27.80a PR |
| 56. | Jacob SchlegelPlace 56. · Grade 9 · Oratory Prep | 9 | Oratory Prep | 2:27.90a PR |
| 57. | Max KleindienstPlace 57. · Grade 9 · Oratory Prep | 9 | Oratory Prep | 2:29.20a PR |
| 58. | Raphael McGinnisPlace 58. · Grade 10 · Newark Academy | 10 | Newark Academy | 2:29.25a |
| 59. | Luca VessechiaPlace 59. · Grade 12 · Oratory Prep | 12 | Oratory Prep | 2:29.59a |
| 60. | Ishan AlurPlace 60. · Grade 9 · Newark Academy | 9 | Newark Academy | 2:29.80a PR |
| 61. | Evan LaBarberaPlace 61. · Grade 9 · Oratory Prep | 9 | Oratory Prep | 2:30.07a PR |
| 62. | Kamil GryzbPlace 62. · Grade 10 · Governor Livingston | 10 | Governor Livingston | 2:30.28a |
| 63. | Patrick Roberts 9Place 63. · Grade 11 · Oratory Prep | 11 | Oratory Prep | 2:31.38a |
| 64. | Matteo Wolfe OrtegaPlace 64. · Grade 9 · Cranford | 9 | Cranford | 2:31.62a PR |
| 65. | Alden Louis-PierrePlace 65. · Grade 9 · Union Catholic Reg | 9 | Union Catholic Reg | 2:32.86a |
| 66. | Shalin MathurPlace 66. · Grade 10 · Governor Livingston | 10 | Governor Livingston | 2:33.45a |
| 67. | Ben PrussmanPlace 67. · Grade - · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | - | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:33.46a |
| 68. | Matthew GaonaPlace 68. · Grade 10 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 10 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:34.68a PR |
| 69. | Andrew ScheppePlace 69. · Grade 9 · Governor Livingston | 9 | Governor Livingston | 2:35.45a |
| 70. | Stephen DelRePlace 70. · Grade 9 · Cranford | 9 | Cranford | 2:35.93a PR |
| 71. | Daniel CashinPlace 71. · Grade 10 · Oratory Prep | 10 | Oratory Prep | 2:37.50a PR |
| 72. | Christian SalgueiroPlace 72. · Grade 9 · Cranford | 9 | Cranford | 2:38.58a PR |
| 73. | Garrett LapentaPlace 73. · Grade - · Cranford | - | Cranford | 2:39.06a PR |
| 74. | Liam EhartPlace 74. · Grade 9 · Cranford | 9 | Cranford | 2:40.90a PR |
| 75. | Alex WolfPlace 75. · Grade 10 · Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 10 | Scotch Plains-Fanwood | 2:41.82a PR |
| 76. | Ishan PalPlace 76. · Grade 9 · Governor Livingston | 9 | Governor Livingston | 2:46.36a PR |
| 77. | Leo DiniPlace 77. · Grade - · Cranford | - | Cranford | 2:49.56a PR |
| 78. | Alexander ColyerPlace 78. · Grade 9 · Cranford | 9 | Cranford | 2:59.08a PR |
| 79. | John KennedyPlace 79. · Grade 11 · Oratory Prep | 11 | Oratory Prep | 3:08.25a |