| 1. | Scott KellyPlace 1. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 4:44.83a |
| 2. | Hodaifa ElkayfePlace 2. · Grade 11 · Port Richmond | 11 | Port Richmond | 4:49.06a |
| 3. | Daniel OlsenPlace 3. · Grade 10 · Monsignor Farrell | 10 | Monsignor Farrell | 4:51.76a |
| 4. | Daoud NejumiPlace 4. · Grade 11 · St Peters Boys | 11 | St Peters Boys | 4:51.94a |
| 5. | Alexis Garcia-SantiagoPlace 5. · Grade 12 · Susan Wagner | 12 | Susan Wagner | 4:52.81a |
| 6. | Owen SplanPlace 6. · Grade 12 · Monsignor Farrell | 12 | Monsignor Farrell | 4:54.68a |
| 7. | Tony WongPlace 7. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 4:55.91a |
| 8. | James WoodsPlace 8. · Grade 11 · Monsignor Farrell | 11 | Monsignor Farrell | 4:58.13a |
| 9. | Preston ChinPlace 9. · Grade 11 · Curtis | 11 | Curtis | 4:58.50a |
| 10. | Pat BuckleyPlace 10. · Grade 10 · Monsignor Farrell | 10 | Monsignor Farrell | 4:58.75a |
| 11. | Matthew FasanellaPlace 11. · Grade 11 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 11 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 4:59.59a |
| 12. | Michael SclafaniPlace 12. · Grade 10 · St Joseph's by the Sea | 10 | St Joseph's by the Sea | 4:59.78a |
| 13. | Nicholas AllegrettiPlace 13. · Grade 12 · CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 12 | CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 5:00.14a |
| 14. | Sebasthian DiazPlace 14. · Grade 10 · Curtis | 10 | Curtis | 5:05.87a |
| 15. | Daniel RomeroPlace 15. · Grade 11 · Susan Wagner | 11 | Susan Wagner | 5:08.45a |
| 16. | Joseph ImparatoPlace 16. · Grade 10 · St Joseph's by the Sea | 10 | St Joseph's by the Sea | 5:09.69a |
| 17. | Joshua ZucconiPlace 17. · Grade 10 · St Joseph's by the Sea | 10 | St Joseph's by the Sea | 5:09.81a |
| 18. | Robert LombardiPlace 18. · Grade 10 · Monsignor Farrell | 10 | Monsignor Farrell | 5:13.23a |
| 19. | Nicholas SosaPlace 19. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:14.41a |
| 20. | Thomas MoorePlace 20. · Grade 12 · Monsignor Farrell | 12 | Monsignor Farrell | 5:14.50a |
| 21. | Dylan VasquezPlace 21. · Grade 10 · St Peters Boys | 10 | St Peters Boys | 5:14.70a |
| 22. | Thomas DemarcoPlace 22. · Grade 10 · St Joseph's by the Sea | 10 | St Joseph's by the Sea | 5:15.09a |
| 23. | Eric GajewskiPlace 23. · Grade 10 · Monsignor Farrell | 10 | Monsignor Farrell | 5:16.21a |
| 24. | Yu Chang LiuPlace 24. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:19.61a |
| 25. | Jordan CalderonPlace 25. · Grade 11 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 11 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:22.15a |
| 26. | Michael MatiychenkoPlace 26. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:22.49a |
| 27. | Muhammadakbar SharofidinovPlace 27. · Grade 10 · CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 10 | CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 5:26.75a |
| 28. | Jimmy MartinezPlace 28. · Grade 10 · Monsignor Farrell | 10 | Monsignor Farrell | 5:28.03a |
| 29. | Aaron LiuPlace 29. · Grade 12 · CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 12 | CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 5:29.70a |
| 30. | Shaven WijesekeraPlace 30. · Grade 11 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 11 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:31.40a |
| 31. | Chris ZencuchPlace 31. · Grade 11 · Monsignor Farrell | 11 | Monsignor Farrell | 5:34.14a |
| 32. | John HerreraPlace 32. · Grade 11 · Monsignor Farrell | 11 | Monsignor Farrell | 5:35.03a |
| 33. | KENNETH GAOPlace 33. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:36.81a |
| 34. | Michael GiacchiPlace 34. · Grade 10 · St Joseph's by the Sea | 10 | St Joseph's by the Sea | 5:37.65a |
| 35. | Sergi DuraPlace 35. · Grade 11 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 11 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:39.27a |
| 36. | Michael ManganelPlace 36. · Grade 12 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 12 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:39.57a |
| 37. | Jack WrightPlace 37. · Grade 10 · St Peters Boys | 10 | St Peters Boys | 5:46.57a |
| 38. | Matthew GoldsteinPlace 38. · Grade 10 · CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 10 | CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 5:46.83a |
| 39. | Peter AdamkiewiczPlace 39. · Grade 11 · Monsignor Farrell | 11 | Monsignor Farrell | 5:48.27a |
| 40. | Mike CaruanaPlace 40. · Grade 10 · Monsignor Farrell | 10 | Monsignor Farrell | 5:56.61a |
| 41. | Patrick RogersPlace 41. · Grade 10 · CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 10 | CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 5:57.52a |
| 42. | Aren Paul Santos TorralbaPlace 42. · Grade 10 · CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 10 | CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 6:03.13a |
| 43. | Arun AnantharajahPlace 43. · Grade 12 · CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 12 | CSIHS/McCown International Studies | 6:12.66a |