| 1. | Kaitlyn MooneyPlace 1. · Grade Fr · Coast Guard | Fr | Coast Guard | 4:47.92a | 10 |
| 2. | Samantha FeenstraPlace 2. · Grade So · Trinity (Conn.) | So | Trinity (Conn.) | 5:01.45a | 8 |
| 3. | Stephanie RodriquezPlace 3. · Grade So · Babson | So | Babson | 5:01.95a | 6 |
| 4. | Maeve RoachPlace 4. · Grade Fr · Coast Guard | Fr | Coast Guard | 5:02.36a | 5 |
| 5. | Haley KnoxPlace 5. · Grade Jr · Eastern Connecticut State | Jr | Eastern Connecticut State | 5:03.61a | 4 |
| 6. | Melanie PlattnerPlace 6. · Grade Sr · Babson | Sr | Babson | 5:06.47a PR | 3 |
| 7. | Taylor MahlandtPlace 7. · Grade So · Wellesley | So | Wellesley | 5:06.97a PR | 2 |
| 8. | Lauren BarrettPlace 8. · Grade Jr · Trinity (Conn.) | Jr | Trinity (Conn.) | 5:07.41a | 1 |
| 9. | Emma SimsPlace 9. · Grade Fr · Coast Guard | Fr | Coast Guard | 5:07.56a PR | — |
| 10. | Rachel ScheubPlace 10. · Grade So · Trinity (Conn.) | So | Trinity (Conn.) | 5:08.14a PR | — |
| 11. | Grace HarriisonPlace 11. · Grade So · Trinity (Conn.) | So | Trinity (Conn.) | 5:09.43a PR | — |
| 12. | Eva BrydsonPlace 12. · Grade Jr · Connecticut College | Jr | Connecticut College | 5:09.79a PR | — |
| 13. | Grace SheeranPlace 13. · Grade Sr · Connecticut College | Sr | Connecticut College | 5:09.83a | — |
| 14. | Julia BurdulisPlace 14. · Grade Fr · Trinity (Conn.) | Fr | Trinity (Conn.) | 5:11.22a | — |
| 15. | Samara JohnsonPlace 15. · Grade So · Eastern Connecticut State | So | Eastern Connecticut State | 5:11.97a | — |
| 16. | Rachel BurchillPlace 16. · Grade Sr · Coast Guard | Sr | Coast Guard | 5:13.49a PR | — |
| 17. | Grace CowlesPlace 17. · Grade Fr · Wellesley | Fr | Wellesley | 5:13.88a | — |
| 18. | Elizabeth HensleyPlace 18. · Grade So · Connecticut College | So | Connecticut College | 5:14.74a PR | — |
| 19. | Julia CormierPlace 19. · Grade So · Franklin Pierce | So | Franklin Pierce | 5:15.63a | — |
| 20. | Rebecca ZylakPlace 20. · Grade So · Franklin Pierce | So | Franklin Pierce | 5:19.13a | — |
| 21. | Christina GosselinPlace 21. · Grade Jr · Eastern Connecticut State | Jr | Eastern Connecticut State | 5:21.73a | — |
| 22. | Rachel FarleyPlace 22. · Grade Fr · Westfield State | Fr | Westfield State | 5:30.20a | — |
| 23. | Kara PenneyPlace 23. · Grade Jr · Westfield State | Jr | Westfield State | 5:31.99a | — |
| 24. | Natalie DaviesPlace 24. · Grade Sr · Franklin Pierce | Sr | Franklin Pierce | 5:35.31a | — |
| 25. | Erin MaddenPlace 25. · Grade Fr · Westfield State | Fr | Westfield State | 5:35.33a PR | — |
| 26. | Maeve SullivanPlace 26. · Grade So · Babson | So | Babson | 5:36.57a | — |
| 27. | Julia LawlorPlace 27. · Grade Fr · Babson | Fr | Babson | 5:36.58a | — |
| 28. | Autumn BrownPlace 28. · Grade Sr · Westfield State | Sr | Westfield State | 5:36.64a | — |
| 29. | Caroline WinickiPlace 29. · Grade Fr · Babson | Fr | Babson | 5:38.42a PR | — |
| 30. | Avery HayesPlace 30. · Grade Jr · Trinity (Conn.) | Jr | Trinity (Conn.) | 5:39.98a | — |
| 31. | Taylor BalfourPlace 31. · Grade Fr · Wellesley | Fr | Wellesley | 5:48.35a | — |
| 32. | Kathrine LeahyPlace 32. · Grade Sr · Westfield State | Sr | Westfield State | 5:52.15a | — |
| 33. | Erin ConnollyPlace 33. · Grade So · Westfield State | So | Westfield State | 5:58.43a | — |
| 34. | Megan FeragnePlace 34. · Grade So · Connecticut College | So | Connecticut College | 6:01.91a PR | — |
| 35. | Evalin BrautigamPlace 35. · Grade Sr · Eastern Connecticut State | Sr | Eastern Connecticut State | 6:10.38a | — |