| 1. | Dage MinorsPlace 1. · Grade So · Franklin Pierce | So | Franklin Pierce | 1:56.95a |
| 2. | Tim BolickPlace 2. · Grade So · Bentley | So | Bentley | 1:57.11a |
| 3. | Daniel KilcoynePlace 3. · Grade So · MIT | So | MIT | 1:57.22a PR |
| 4. | Ricardo PaezPlace 4. · Grade Sr · MIT | Sr | MIT | 1:58.06a |
| 5. | Joshua ErcoliniPlace 5. · Grade Fr · Franklin Pierce | Fr | Franklin Pierce | 1:58.72a |
| 6. | Anthony LaceyPlace 6. · Grade Jr · Bentley | Jr | Bentley | 1:58.77a PR |
| 7. | Tom CunninghamPlace 7. · Grade So · Boston University | So | Boston University | 1:58.86a |
| 8. | Alex BonittoPlace 8. · Grade So · Franklin Pierce | So | Franklin Pierce | 1:59.10a |
| 9. | Matthew CarpenterPlace 9. · Grade So · Franklin Pierce | So | Franklin Pierce | 1:59.32a |
| 10. | Korey HuntPlace 10. · Grade So · New England College | So | New England College | 2:00.09a |
| 11. | Brandon LegendrePlace 11. · Grade So · Colby-Sawyer | So | Colby-Sawyer | 2:00.47a |
| 12. | Graham ChapskiPlace 12. · Grade Fr · Bentley | Fr | Bentley | 2:00.72a |
| 13. | Kody FryePlace 13. · Grade Fr · Colby-Sawyer | Fr | Colby-Sawyer | 2:00.74a PR |
| 14. | Jon HolmesPlace 14. · Grade So · Franklin Pierce | So | Franklin Pierce | 2:00.98a |
| 15. | Michael PicchiniPlace 15. · Grade Fr · MIT | Fr | MIT | 2:01.10a PR |
| 16. | Ben LanePlace 16. · Grade Sr · Roger Williams | Sr | Roger Williams | 2:01.29a |
| 17. | Henry TarequePlace 17. · Grade So · MIT | So | MIT | 2:01.44a |
| 18. | Thomas NegronPlace 18. · Grade So · Harvard | So | Harvard | 2:01.86a |
| 19. | John ChristopherPlace 19. · Grade Jr · Roger Williams | Jr | Roger Williams | 2:01.89a |
| 20. | Antoine GisorePlace 20. · Grade Sr · Franklin Pierce | Sr | Franklin Pierce | 2:01.97a |
| 21. | Brad DeMarcoPlace 21. · Grade Jr · Connecticut College | Jr | Connecticut College | 2:02.84a PR |
| 22. | Jordan ComeauPlace 22. · Grade Fr · Connecticut College | Fr | Connecticut College | 2:03.11a |
| 23. | Dan O'FlynnPlace 23. · Grade Jr · Merrimack | Jr | Merrimack | 2:03.50a |
| 24. | Jeff DavisPlace 24. · Grade Fr · New England College | Fr | New England College | 2:03.53a PR |
| 25. | Cyrenus PaquinPlace 25. · Grade Jr · UMass Dartmouth | Jr | UMass Dartmouth | 2:03.88a PR |
| 26. | Dylan CrowleyPlace 26. · Grade So · Franklin Pierce | So | Franklin Pierce | 2:04.25a PR |
| 27. | Dominic RoyPlace 27. · Grade Fr · UMass Dartmouth | Fr | UMass Dartmouth | 2:04.56a |
| 28. | Trevor LombaPlace 28. · Grade So · Babson | So | Babson | 2:04.89a |
| 29. | Chris BirottePlace 29. · Grade Jr · Franklin Pierce | Jr | Franklin Pierce | 2:05.08a |
| 30. | Patrick DermodyPlace 30. · Grade Sr · Connecticut College | Sr | Connecticut College | 2:05.17a PR |
| 31. | Makopa RugabirwaPlace 31. · Grade Jr · Franklin Pierce | Jr | Franklin Pierce | 2:06.21a |
| 32. | Greg KarpaczPlace 32. · Grade So · Bentley | So | Bentley | 2:06.63a PR |
| 33. | Martin GradijanPlace 33. · Grade Fr · Franklin Pierce | Fr | Franklin Pierce | 2:07.24a |
| 34. | Nick MalonePlace 34. · Grade Fr · Roger Williams | Fr | Roger Williams | 2:08.17a |
| 35. | Peter GraceffaPlace 35. · Grade So · UMass Dartmouth | So | UMass Dartmouth | 2:08.33a PR |
| 36. | Tyree GorhamPlace 36. · Grade Fr · UMass Dartmouth | Fr | UMass Dartmouth | 2:08.56a |
| 37. | William BarnesPlace 37. · Grade Sr · Connecticut College | Sr | Connecticut College | 2:08.73a |
| 38. | Scott AtwoodPlace 38. · Grade Fr · Babson | Fr | Babson | 2:09.79a PR |
| 39. | Mike FrappierPlace 39. · Grade Jr · Franklin Pierce | Jr | Franklin Pierce | 2:10.50a PR |
| 40. | James WaynePlace 40. · Grade Sr · New England College | Sr | New England College | 2:10.69a |
| 41. | Jonathan MartinPlace 41. · Grade Fr · Babson | Fr | Babson | 2:11.02a PR |
| 42. | Sam HarveyPlace 42. · Grade Jr · Franklin Pierce | Jr | Franklin Pierce | 2:11.25a |
| 43. | Aaron KarlinPlace 43. · Grade Fr · Brandeis | Fr | Brandeis | 2:11.95a |
| 44. | Justin EnrightPlace 44. · Grade Fr · New England College | Fr | New England College | 2:12.01a PR |
| 45. | Sam FisherPlace 45. · Grade Fr · New England College | Fr | New England College | 2:13.74a PR |
| 46. | Jonathan PaulPlace 46. · Grade Jr · Regis (Mass.) | Jr | Regis (Mass.) | 2:14.42a PR |
| 47. | Alejandro HernandezPlace 47. · Grade So · Connecticut College | So | Connecticut College | 2:16.28a |
| 48. | Jonathan GerominiPlace 48. · Grade Fr · Assumption | Fr | Assumption | 2:17.06a |
| 49. | Kyle HolmsenPlace 49. · Grade So · Connecticut College | So | Connecticut College | 2:17.46a PR |
| 50. | Andrew BlanchardPlace 50. · Grade Sr · New England College | Sr | New England College | 2:19.70a PR |
| 51. | Steven MendozaPlace 51. · Grade So · Assumption | So | Assumption | 2:20.04a PR |
| 52. | Owen McQuaidPlace 52. · Grade Sr · Regis (Mass.) | Sr | Regis (Mass.) | 2:21.24a |
| 53. | Joshua WeinmannPlace 53. · Grade Fr · Endicott | Fr | Endicott | 2:22.42a PR |
| 54. | Stephen BennettPlace 54. · Grade Fr · Colby-Sawyer | Fr | Colby-Sawyer | 2:22.99a |
| 55. | Edgar OcanaPlace 55. · Grade Jr · Babson | Jr | Babson | 2:23.39a |
| 56. | Sean LaPrisePlace 56. · Grade So · Regis (Mass.) | So | Regis (Mass.) | 2:27.82a |
| 57. | Gary KargakosPlace 57. · Grade Fr · New England College | Fr | New England College | 2:36.86a PR |
| 58. | Alec HollandPlace 58. · Grade So · Colby-Sawyer | So | Colby-Sawyer | 2:39.54a |
| 59. | Chris WhaleyPlace 59. · Grade So · New England College | So | New England College | 2:50.07a |
