| 1. | Prince Owusu-TwumPlace 1. · Grade - · Sharpe AthleticsUnofficial | - | Sharpe Athletics | 47.70a PR |
| 2. | Myles SmallPlace 2. · UnattachedUnofficial | — | Unattached | 48.76a |
| 3. | Schnyder GermainPlace 3. · Grade 10 · Central Park Track Club (CPTC) - TracksmithUnofficial | 10 | Central Park Track Club (CPTC) - Tracksmith | 49.11a |
| 4. | Habibu GadoPlace 4. · Bold Purpose AthleticsUnofficial | — | Bold Purpose Athletics | 49.29a |
| 5. | Geraldy VolcyPlace 5. · Grade Sr · UnattachedUnofficial | Sr | Unattached | 49.48a PR |
| 6. | Dante BrownPlace 6. · Grade 12 · UnattachedUnofficial | 12 | Unattached | 49.72a PR |
| 7. | Ayokunle OsunkiyesiPlace 7. · Grade 11 · UnattachedUnofficial | 11 | Unattached | 49.75a PR |
| 8. | Hunter KanePlace 8. · Grade 12 · UnattachedUnofficial | 12 | Unattached | 49.77a |
| 9. | Ben WagnerPlace 9. · Grade Fr · Moore EliteUnofficial | Fr | Moore Elite | 50.04a |
| 10. | Krithik Ram SaravanarajPlace 10. · Grade 11 · Garden State Track ClubUnofficial | 11 | Garden State Track Club | 50.32a PR |
| 11. | Skylar McGheePlace 11. · Grade So · UnattachedUnofficial | So | Unattached | 50.43a PR |
| 12. | Michael ArmentPlace 12. · Grade 10 · UnattachedUnofficial | 10 | Unattached | 50.85a PR |
| 13. | Mason RosenblattPlace 13. · Grade 11 · The Masters TCUnofficial | 11 | The Masters TC | 50.99a |
| 14. | Enrique CoronaPlace 14. · Grade 12 · UnattachedUnofficial | 12 | Unattached | 51.54a PR |
| 15. | Johnathan TorresPlace 15. · DickinsonUnofficial | — | Dickinson | 51.93a |
| 16. | Elijah KibomaPlace 16. · Grade - · Blue PhoenixUnofficial | - | Blue Phoenix | 52.02a PR |
| 17. | Zechariah EvansPlace 17. · Grade 12 · Garden State Track ClubUnofficial | 12 | Garden State Track Club | 52.07a PR |
| 18. | Joshua AkakpoPlace 18. · Grade 11 · Delbarton TCUnofficial | 11 | Delbarton TC | 52.21a PR |
| 19. | Andre ThomasPlace 19. · Grade - · D-BestUnofficial | - | D-Best | 52.44a |
| 20. | Sherman GlascoPlace 20. · Piscataway TCUnofficial | — | Piscataway TC | 52.53a |
| 22. | Mauricio CuadrosPlace 22. · UnattachedUnofficial | — | Unattached | 53.39a |
| 23. | Frederick VaughnPlace 23. · UnattachedUnofficial | — | Unattached | 53.46a |
| 24. | Kyle HolderPlace 24. · UnattachedUnofficial | — | Unattached | 54.48a |
| 25. | Micah BradleyPlace 25. · Grade 11 · ElizabethUnofficial | 11 | Elizabeth | 54.51a PR |
| 26. | Carter PricePlace 26. · Grade - · Garden State Track ClubUnofficial | - | Garden State Track Club | 54.65a PR |
| 27. | Chace BernardPlace 27. · Grade 10 · UnattachedUnofficial | 10 | Unattached | 54.69a PR |
| 28. | Chima NwanonyiriPlace 28. · Mount Olive TCUnofficial | — | Mount Olive TC | 54.76a |
| 29. | Frederick BansemerPlace 29. · Grade 10 · Wallkill Valley HSUnofficial | 10 | Wallkill Valley HS | 54.90a PR |
| 30. | Roniel SanchezPlace 30. · Grade 12 · Blue PhoenixUnofficial | 12 | Blue Phoenix | 55.02a PR |
| 31. | Noah SanchezPlace 31. · Grade 8 · Garden State Track ClubUnofficial | 8 | Garden State Track Club | 55.11a PR |
| 32. | David OrtizPlace 32. · Grade 11 · ElizabethUnofficial | 11 | Elizabeth | 55.24a PR |
| 33. | Marc AbataPlace 33. · Grade - · Garden State Track ClubUnofficial | - | Garden State Track Club | 55.35a PR |
| 34. | Nolan RaperPlace 34. · Grade 9 · UnattachedUnofficial | 9 | Unattached | 55.43a PR |
| 35. | Ari WofsyPlace 35. · Grade 12 · Livingston TCUnofficial | 12 | Livingston TC | 55.45a PR |
| 36. | Tyler KaplanPlace 36. · Grade 11 · Garden State Track ClubUnofficial | 11 | Garden State Track Club | 55.93a |
| 38. | Federico De LimaPlace 38. · ColombiaUnofficial | — | Colombia | 56.32a |
| 39. | Anjolaoluwa FagunPlace 39. · Grade 12 · UnattachedUnofficial | 12 | Unattached | 56.41a PR |
| 40. | Siddharth SelvarajPlace 40. · Grade 9 · Garden State Track ClubUnofficial | 9 | Garden State Track Club | 56.47a |
| 41. | Chase YoungPlace 41. · Grade 8 · Garden State Track ClubUnofficial | 8 | Garden State Track Club | 57.01a PR |
| 42. | Toby MorenoPlace 42. · Grade 12 · ImmaculataUnofficial | 12 | Immaculata | 1:01.23a PR |
| 44. | David GarciaPlace 44. · Grade 9 · Wallkill Valley RegUnofficial | 9 | Wallkill Valley Reg | 1:01.64a PR |
| 46. | Zachary OsinowoPlace 46. · Grade - · UnattachedUnofficial | - | Unattached | 1:02.99a PR |
| 50. | Reid PetersonPlace 50. · Grade 5 · Lakeland Track ClubUnofficial | 5 | Lakeland Track Club | 1:05.94a |
| 51. | Leandro GarciaPlace 51. · Grade 6 · UnattachedUnofficial | 6 | Unattached | 1:06.12a PR |
| — | Sanpha KamaraGrade 11 · Unattached | 11 | Unattached | DNS |
| — | Andre Harrell Sr.Grade - · Professional Runners Club | - | Professional Runners Club | DNS |
| — | Reyansh MatteGrade 8 · Garden State Track Club | 8 | Garden State Track Club | DNS |
| — | Leandro Kieffer-BrownGrade 9 · Garden State Track Club | 9 | Garden State Track Club | DNS |
| — | Philip ZyskowskiGrade - · D-Best | - | D-Best | DNS |
| — | Jordan Johnson · Ex Le Moyne College/ Unattache | — | Ex Le Moyne College/ Unattache | DNF |
| — | Aidan MacManus · Unattached | — | Unattached | DNS |