| 1. | James MeePlace 1. · Grade Sr · American International | Sr | American International | 3:55.08a | 10 |
| 2. | Glarius RopPlace 2. · Grade Jr · American International | Jr | American International | 3:56.55a PR | 8 |
| 3. | Jonathan JoycePlace 3. · Grade Sr · Westfield State | Sr | Westfield State | 3:59.20a PR | 6 |
| 4. | Christopher PlankeyPlace 4. · Grade So · Keene State | So | Keene State | 4:03.34a | 5 |
| 5. | Mark GulesianPlace 5. · Grade Fr · Babson | Fr | Babson | 4:03.49a | 4 |
| 6. | Ryan WidzgowskiPlace 6. · Grade So · Keene State | So | Keene State | 4:03.69a | 3 |
| 7. | Samuel RothPlace 7. · Grade Jr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Jr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 4:04.03a PR | 2 |
| 8. | Anthony FrissoraPlace 8. · Grade Jr · Westfield State | Jr | Westfield State | 4:04.89a | 1 |
| 9. | Jonathan HorstmanPlace 9. · Grade Fr · American International | Fr | American International | 4:05.87a | — |
| 10. | Jordan LeePlace 10. · Grade So · Coast Guard | So | Coast Guard | 4:09.56a PR | — |
| 11. | Bradley PientaPlace 11. · Grade So · Coast Guard | So | Coast Guard | 4:10.00a | — |
| 12. | Hayden BunnellPlace 12. · Grade Fr · Colby-Sawyer | Fr | Colby-Sawyer | 4:10.16a | — |
| 13. | Thomas PaquettePlace 13. · Grade Jr · Keene State | Jr | Keene State | 4:10.64a PR | — |
| 14. | Patrick ReganPlace 14. · Grade Sr · Westfield State | Sr | Westfield State | 4:12.32a | — |
| 15. | Scott BockusPlace 15. · Grade Jr · Westfield State | Jr | Westfield State | 4:13.13a PR | — |
| 16. | Daniel ShepardPlace 16. · Grade Fr · Westfield State | Fr | Westfield State | 4:13.33a PR | — |
| 17. | Nathan KolmanPlace 17. · Grade So · Babson | So | Babson | 4:14.41a | — |
| 18. | Nathan PanciackPlace 18. · Grade Sr · Springfield (Mass.) | Sr | Springfield (Mass.) | 4:14.68a | — |
| 19. | Brett MastrangeloPlace 19. · Grade So · Keene State | So | Keene State | 4:14.79a | — |
| 20. | Yevgeniy MakarovPlace 20. · Grade Fr · American International | Fr | American International | 4:15.98a | — |
| 21. | AJ SkainsPlace 21. · Grade So · Babson | So | Babson | 4:19.35a PR | — |
| 22. | Chance WilkPlace 22. · Grade Jr · Keene State | Jr | Keene State | 4:19.41a | — |
| 23. | Zack KearneyPlace 23. · Grade Fr · Coast Guard | Fr | Coast Guard | 4:20.08a | — |
| 24. | Eric ArchambaultPlace 24. · Grade Sr · Springfield (Mass.) | Sr | Springfield (Mass.) | 4:20.25a PR | — |
| 25. | Steven GilfeatherPlace 25. · Grade Sr · Springfield (Mass.) | Sr | Springfield (Mass.) | 4:20.34a | — |
| 26. | Jason CoxPlace 26. · Grade Fr · Westfield State | Fr | Westfield State | 4:20.93a | — |
| 27. | Ryan O'NeilPlace 27. · Grade So · Coast Guard | So | Coast Guard | 4:21.27a | — |
| 28. | Steven ConnollyPlace 28. · Grade Fr · Westfield State | Fr | Westfield State | 4:22.86a | — |
| 29. | Julian Compagni-PortisPlace 29. · Grade Fr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Fr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 4:23.24a PR | — |
| 30. | Aaron MichelPlace 30. · Grade Sr · Springfield (Mass.) | Sr | Springfield (Mass.) | 4:23.57a PR | — |
| 31. | Daniel KipronoPlace 31. · Grade Sr · American International | Sr | American International | 4:24.00a | — |
| 32. | Nick RiendeauPlace 32. · Grade So · Keene State | So | Keene State | 4:24.98a | — |
| 33. | Patrick CallanPlace 33. · Grade So · Emmanuel (Mass.) | So | Emmanuel (Mass.) | 4:26.24a | — |
| 34. | Erick JacksonPlace 34. · Grade Fr · Coast Guard | Fr | Coast Guard | 4:27.68a PR | — |
| 35. | Lee CattanachPlace 35. · Grade Fr · Eastern Connecticut State | Fr | Eastern Connecticut State | 4:27.76a | — |
| 36. | Kevin O'BrienPlace 36. · Grade Sr · Coast Guard | Sr | Coast Guard | 4:29.25a | — |
| 37. | Michael MorrisPlace 37. · Grade So · Emmanuel (Mass.) | So | Emmanuel (Mass.) | 4:30.59a | — |
| 38. | Sean ComerfordPlace 38. · Grade So · Westfield State | So | Westfield State | 4:30.87a | — |
| 39. | Nicholas FosterPlace 39. · Grade Fr · Coast Guard | Fr | Coast Guard | 4:31.76a | — |
| 40. | Roger (RJ) WilkiePlace 40. · Grade Fr · Keene State | Fr | Keene State | 4:33.30a | — |
| 41. | Chris PiercePlace 41. · Grade Jr · Babson | Jr | Babson | 4:33.54a | — |
| 42. | Jon LashPlace 42. · Grade Fr · Coast Guard | Fr | Coast Guard | 4:34.38a | — |
| 43. | Eric LopezPlace 43. · Grade Fr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Fr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 4:35.93a PR | — |
| 44. | Tal LeveranPlace 44. · Grade Fr · Wesleyan (Conn.) | Fr | Wesleyan (Conn.) | 4:35.99a PR | — |
| 45. | Patrick MeanyPlace 45. · Grade Fr · Babson | Fr | Babson | 4:39.51a PR | — |
| 46. | Alex SchopfPlace 46. · Grade Fr · Westfield State | Fr | Westfield State | 4:41.72a | — |
| 47. | Elliot KahlPlace 47. · Grade So · Coast Guard | So | Coast Guard | 4:42.59a PR | — |
| 48. | Ian McmillianPlace 48. · Grade So · Bard | So | Bard | 4:45.80a PR | — |
| 49. | Daniel MurphyPlace 49. · Grade Fr · Colby-Sawyer | Fr | Colby-Sawyer | 4:55.74a PR | — |
| 50. | Brad ConinePlace 50. · Grade So · Springfield (Mass.) | So | Springfield (Mass.) | 5:40.75a | — |
| -- | Justin GeroPlace -- · Grade Jr · Bard | Jr | Bard | DNF | — |
