| 1. | Todd FordPlace 1. · Grade Fr · Williams | Fr | Williams | 4:22.44a | 10 |
| 2. | Justin BullockPlace 2. · Grade Jr · MIT | Jr | MIT | 4:24.04a | 8 |
| 3. | Makopa RugabirwaPlace 3. · Grade Fr · Franklin Pierce | Fr | Franklin Pierce | 4:24.46a | 6 |
| 4. | Tristan ColePlace 4. · Grade Sr · Connecticut College | Sr | Connecticut College | 4:24.48a PR | 5 |
| 5. | Aldis IndePlace 5. · Grade So · Williams | So | Williams | 4:24.51a PR | 4 |
| 6. | Ed ColvinPlace 6. · Grade Jr · Brandeis | Jr | Brandeis | 4:24.99a PR | 3 |
| 7. | Conor McCloskeyPlace 7. · Grade Sr · Rhode Island College | Sr | Rhode Island College | 4:25.45a | 2 |
| 8. | Patrick DermodyPlace 8. · Grade So · Connecticut College | So | Connecticut College | 4:25.66a PR | 1 |
| 9. | Jay McKennaPlace 9. · Grade Jr · MIT | Jr | MIT | 4:26.14a | — |
| 10. | Ali SherifPlace 10. · Grade So · Merrimack | So | Merrimack | 4:26.78a PR | — |
| 11. | Wade DavisPlace 11. · Grade Sr · Williams | Sr | Williams | 4:27.19a PR | — |
| 12. | Andrew Reifman-PackettPlace 12. · Grade Fr · Saint Rose | Fr | Saint Rose | 4:28.43a | — |
| 13. | Abdihakim IbrahimPlace 13. · Grade Sr · Emmanuel (Mass.) | Sr | Emmanuel (Mass.) | 4:28.87a | — |
| 14. | Bijan MazaheriPlace 14. · Grade Fr · Williams | Fr | Williams | 4:29.99a | — |
| 15. | Eric SafaiPlace 15. · Grade Jr · MIT | Jr | MIT | 4:32.78a | — |
| 16. | Ricardo PaezPlace 16. · Grade So · MIT | So | MIT | 4:33.78a | — |
| 17. | Bradley PientaPlace 17. · Grade Jr · Coast Guard | Jr | Coast Guard | 4:34.52a | — |
| 18. | Eric KarstunenPlace 18. · Grade So · UMass Dartmouth | So | UMass Dartmouth | 4:34.75a PR | — |
| 19. | Dallas O'BrienPlace 19. · Grade So · Bridgewater State | So | Bridgewater State | 4:35.07a | — |
| 20. | Grady WardPlace 20. · Grade Fr · Brandeis | Fr | Brandeis | 4:35.99a | — |
| 21. | Christopher JordanPlace 21. · Grade Jr · UMass Dartmouth | Jr | UMass Dartmouth | 4:37.17a | — |
| 22. | Sean ColfordPlace 22. · Grade Fr · Franklin Pierce | Fr | Franklin Pierce | 4:37.37a PR | — |
| 23. | Adam GidleyPlace 23. · Grade Fr · Merrimack | Fr | Merrimack | 4:37.46a PR | — |
| 24. | Dan O'FlynnPlace 24. · Grade Fr · Merrimack | Fr | Merrimack | 4:38.55a | — |
| 25. | Matt GitkindPlace 25. · Grade Sr · Connecticut College | Sr | Connecticut College | 4:41.43a PR | — |
| 26. | Evan VadenaisPlace 26. · Grade Fr · Merrimack | Fr | Merrimack | 4:43.13a | — |
| 27. | Chaz MunroePlace 27. · Grade Fr · Franklin Pierce | Fr | Franklin Pierce | 4:46.05a | — |
| 28. | Eric GallosPlace 28. · Grade So · Franklin Pierce | So | Franklin Pierce | 4:47.88a PR | — |
| 29. | Daniel WalshPlace 29. · Grade Fr · Bridgewater State | Fr | Bridgewater State | 4:48.61a PR | — |
| 30. | Michael MorrisPlace 30. · Grade Jr · Emmanuel (Mass.) | Jr | Emmanuel (Mass.) | 4:49.19a | — |
| 31. | Michael GraselaPlace 31. · Grade Sr · Fitchburg State | Sr | Fitchburg State | 4:49.76a | — |
| 32. | Andrew GoncalvesPlace 32. · Grade Fr · UMass Dartmouth | Fr | UMass Dartmouth | 4:51.03a | — |
| 33. | Mark WallerPlace 33. · Grade Fr · Bridgewater State | Fr | Bridgewater State | 4:52.37a | — |
| 34. | Ryan DeanPlace 34. · Grade Fr · Connecticut College | Fr | Connecticut College | 4:54.41a | — |
| 35. | Connor FoleyPlace 35. · Grade So · Bridgewater State | So | Bridgewater State | 4:55.96a | — |
| 36. | JT TrujilloPlace 36. · Grade Fr · Franklin Pierce | Fr | Franklin Pierce | 4:56.40a | — |
| 37. | Zachary BohnPlace 37. · Grade Fr · Emmanuel (Mass.) | Fr | Emmanuel (Mass.) | 5:01.55a | — |
| 38. | Sam CarrollPlace 38. · Grade Fr · Fitchburg State | Fr | Fitchburg State | 5:08.45a | — |
| 39. | Miguel TaverasPlace 39. · Grade Sr · Lasell | Sr | Lasell | 5:09.02a | — |
| 40. | Lawerence TeaguePlace 40. · Grade Jr · Fitchburg State | Jr | Fitchburg State | 5:14.06a | — |
| 41. | Jeff KavaschPlace 41. · Grade Fr · Fitchburg State | Fr | Fitchburg State | 5:15.83a | — |
| 42. | Owen McQuaidPlace 42. · Grade So · Regis (Mass.) | So | Regis (Mass.) | 5:22.94a | — |
| 43. | Kyle NorthropPlace 43. · Grade So · Lasell | So | Lasell | 5:30.32a | — |
| -- | Kyle HannonPlace -- · Grade Sr · MIT | Sr | MIT | DNF | — |
| -- | Ian BarberPlace -- · Grade Fr · Lesley | Fr | Lesley | DNF | — |