| 1 | Mike RuttPlace 1 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:02.95 |
| 2 | Nick StenufPlace 2 · Syracuse Cha | — | Syracuse Cha | 4:03.11 |
| 3 | Patrick MelleaPlace 3 · Bryn Mawr Ru | — | Bryn Mawr Ru | 4:03.16 |
| 4 | Thomas MorganPlace 4 · Zap Fitness | — | Zap Fitness | 4:04.94 |
| 5 | Timothy RitchiePlace 5 · Boston Colle | — | Boston Colle | 4:05.47 |
| 6 | Brian GagnonPlace 6 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:05.79 |
| 7 | Angus MacDonaldPlace 7 · Umass Lowell | — | Umass Lowell | 4:07.92 |
| 8 | Tom OsbornePlace 8 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:08.30 |
| 9 | Craig MacPhersonPlace 9 · Boston U. | — | Boston U. | 4:08.61 |
| 10 | Mark MillerPlace 10 · Baa | — | Baa | 4:08.77 |
| 11 | Yermie CohenPlace 11 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:09.35 |
| 12 | Ian ThomasPlace 12 · Boston Colle | — | Boston Colle | 4:10.03 |
| 13 | Louis SerafiniPlace 13 · Boston Colle | — | Boston Colle | 4:10.09 |
| 14 | Duriel HardyPlace 14 · Brown | — | Brown | 4:10.95 |
| 15 | Christia GonzalezPlace 15 · Rider | — | Rider | 4:11.06 |
| 16 | Trevor WisemanPlace 16 · Syracuse | — | Syracuse | 4:11.54 |
| 17 | Darcy WilsonPlace 17 · Harvard | — | Harvard | 4:11.79 |
| 18 | John BledayPlace 18 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:12.70 |
| 19 | Brian HarveyPlace 19 · Baa | — | Baa | 4:12.74 |
| 20 | Erin SchirmPlace 20 · Syracuse | — | Syracuse | 4:13.22 |
| 21 | Frank IwanickiPlace 21 · Rutgers-Camd | — | Rutgers-Camd | 4:13.23 |
| 22 | Dennis WolffPlace 22 · Riadha | — | Riadha | 4:13.57 |
| 23 | Sean WardPlace 23 · La Salle | — | La Salle | 4:13.87 |
| 24 | Stephen HankinsonPlace 24 · Providence | — | Providence | 4:14.04 |
| 25 | Devon HolgatePlace 25 · Brandeis | — | Brandeis | 4:14.07 |
| 26 | Brian SchilderPlace 26 · Brown | — | Brown | 4:14.65 |
| 27 | Peter GilmorePlace 27 · Boston U. | — | Boston U. | 4:14.94 |
| 28 | Corey BrunellePlace 28 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:15.04 |
| 29 | Colin BrettPlace 29 · Brown | — | Brown | 4:15.17 |
| 30 | David PolgarPlace 30 · Boston U. | — | Boston U. | 4:15.55 |
| 31 | Jeff PerrellaPlace 31 · Yale | — | Yale | 4:16.18 |
| 32 | Ben BrayPlace 32 · Brandeis | — | Brandeis | 4:16.63 |
| 33 | Maxwell BrownPlace 33 · Yale | — | Yale | 4:16.84 |
| 34 | Corey DewittPlace 34 · Dartmouth | — | Dartmouth | 4:16.88 |
| 35 | Andrew MacIsaacPlace 35 · Boston Colle | — | Boston Colle | 4:17.50 |
| 36 | Matthew DunhamPlace 36 · New Haven | — | New Haven | 4:17.59 |
| 37 | Michael StumpfPlace 37 · Brown | — | Brown | 4:17.75 |
| 38 | Justin MurrayPlace 38 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:17.91 |
| 39 | David EmersonPlace 39 · Boston Colle | — | Boston Colle | 4:18.50 |
| 40 | Conor ShelleyPlace 40 · Marist | — | Marist | 4:18.59 |
| 41 | Trevon RainfordPlace 41 · La Salle | — | La Salle | 4:18.61 |
| 42 | Marty MaloneyPlace 42 · Gordon | — | Gordon | 4:18.64 |
| 43 | Matt MinerPlace 43 · Dartmouth | — | Dartmouth | 4:18.64 |
| 44 | Erik BergPlace 44 · Brown | — | Brown | 4:18.97 |
| 45 | Ted DoylePlace 45 · Boston Colle | — | Boston Colle | 4:19.24 |
| 46 | Michael KeeblerPlace 46 · Boston Colle | — | Boston Colle | 4:19.39 |
| 47 | Jeffrey LusignanPlace 47 · Sacred Heart | — | Sacred Heart | 4:19.49 |
| 48 | Jordan HammPlace 48 · Boston Colle | — | Boston Colle | 4:19.66 |
| 49 | Chris BrownPlace 49 · Brandeis | — | Brandeis | 4:19.92 |
| 50 | Tim GuerinPlace 50 · Umass Lowell | — | Umass Lowell | 4:20.07 |
| 51 | Lane ThorntonPlace 51 · WPI | — | WPI | 4:20.39 |
| 52 | Kevin BronsonPlace 52 · Geneseo St. | — | Geneseo St. | 4:20.75 |
| 53 | Andrew GoodwinPlace 53 · St. Lawrence | — | St. Lawrence | 4:20.89 |
| 54 | Arquimed DelaCruzPlace 54 · Marist | — | Marist | 4:20.97 |
| 55 | Conor GroganPlace 55 · Brown | — | Brown | 4:21.08 |
| 56 | Marc BoutinPlace 56 · Brandeis | — | Brandeis | 4:21.41 |
| 57 | Josh PorizkyPlace 57 · Gordon | — | Gordon | 4:21.45 |
| 58 | Daniel KanePlace 58 · Boston Colle | — | Boston Colle | 4:21.59 |
| 59 | Matt CarterPlace 59 · Baa | — | Baa | 4:22.26 |
| 60 | Michael BhattPlace 60 · Boston U. | — | Boston U. | 4:22.40 |
| 61 | Nick BarronPlace 61 · Bates | — | Bates | 4:22.75 |
| 62 | Alex GomesPlace 62 · Southern Mai | — | Southern Mai | 4:22.79 |
| 63 | Thomas EsponnettePlace 63 · Bates | — | Bates | 4:22.81 |
| 64 | Dillon JackPlace 64 · Brown | — | Brown | 4:23.08 |
| 65 | Greg HammettPlace 65 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:23.44 |
| 66 | Daniel RoarkPlace 66 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:23.97 |
| 67 | Daniel WangPlace 67 · Umass Lowell | — | Umass Lowell | 4:24.07 |
| 68 | Ryan HardimanPlace 68 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:24.14 |
| 69 | Chris KiblerPlace 69 · Fitchburg St | — | Fitchburg St | 4:24.87 |
| 70 | Tim KramerPlace 70 · Geneseo St. | — | Geneseo St. | 4:24.88 |
| 71 | Todd ApgarPlace 71 · Monmouth | — | Monmouth | 4:25.00 |
| 72 | Eric SchafferPlace 72 · Monmouth | — | Monmouth | 4:25.49 |
| 73 | Cody thompsonPlace 73 · Naval Academ | — | Naval Academ | 4:25.90 |
| 74 | Miles RichardsonPlace 74 · Phillips Exe | — | Phillips Exe | 4:26.36 |
| 75 | Sean LivingstonPlace 75 · Unat-Roger W | — | Unat-Roger W | 4:26.50 |
| 76 | Alan BernierPlace 76 · Central Mass | — | Central Mass | 4:26.57 |
| 77 | Dave SzymkowiakPlace 77 · Geneseo St. | — | Geneseo St. | 4:27.19 |
| 78 | Patrick DeSabatoPlace 78 · Providence | — | Providence | 4:28.67 |
| 79 | Eric MalnattiPlace 79 · Providence | — | Providence | 4:29.26 |
| 80 | Greg AhnrudPlace 80 · Providence | — | Providence | 4:29.77 |
| 81 | Joseph FerroPlace 81 · Unat-Rhode I | — | Unat-Rhode I | 4:30.82 |
| 82 | Francis BurdettPlace 82 · Greater Spri | — | Greater Spri | 4:31.83 |
| 83 | John HealyPlace 83 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:32.29 |
| 84 | Mik KernPlace 84 · Brandeis | — | Brandeis | 4:32.73 |
| 85 | Matt SpanoPlace 85 · Fitchburg St | — | Fitchburg St | 4:33.70 |
| 86 | Chris O'DayPlace 86 · Assumption | — | Assumption | 4:33.79 |
| 87 | Michael CaputoPlace 87 · Boston U. | — | Boston U. | 4:35.52 |
| 88 | Bart WasiolekPlace 88 · Athletes Foo | — | Athletes Foo | 4:35.96 |
| 89 | Phineas McGovernPlace 89 · Boston Colle | — | Boston Colle | 4:36.17 |
| 90 | Greg JohnstonPlace 90 · GBTC | — | GBTC | 4:36.71 |
| 91 | Francis CusickPlace 91 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:36.78 |
| 92 | Bruce DaviePlace 92 · GBTC | — | GBTC | 4:39.23 |
| 93 | Chris KealeyPlace 93 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:40.79 |
| 94 | David PhippsPlace 94 · Bridgewater | — | Bridgewater | 4:41.04 |
| 95 | John RaguinPlace 95 · GBTC | — | GBTC | 4:42.16 |
| 96 | David BergerPlace 96 · Monmouth | — | Monmouth | 4:43.04 |
| 97 | Brenden GuineePlace 97 · Umass Lowell | — | Umass Lowell | 4:43.63 |
| 98 | Drew MatthewsPlace 98 · St. Anselm | — | St. Anselm | 4:43.76 |
| 99 | Steve FitzsimmonsPlace 99 · Unat-Umass L | — | Unat-Umass L | 4:44.59 |
| 100 | John NolandPlace 100 · B.A.A | — | B.A.A | 4:45.36 |
| 101 | Colin JohnsonPlace 101 · Marist | — | Marist | 4:47.55 |
| 102 | Ian LambePlace 102 · GBTC | — | GBTC | 4:48.66 |
| 103 | Michael GraselaPlace 103 · Fitchburg St | — | Fitchburg St | 4:48.84 |
| 104 | Solomon BelayPlace 104 · Boston U. | — | Boston U. | 4:49.65 |
| 105 | Adam HarderPlace 105 · GBTC | — | GBTC | 4:51.20 |
| 106 | Bryan JohnstonPlace 106 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:51.42 |
| 107 | John SurabianPlace 107 · St. Anselm | — | St. Anselm | 4:51.57 |
| 108 | Max KronbergPlace 108 · Gordon | — | Gordon | 4:51.60 |
| 109 | Adam GreenspanPlace 109 · GBTC | — | GBTC | 4:56.06 |
| 110 | Paul CouturePlace 110 · Salem State | — | Salem State | 4:56.10 |
| 111 | Jonath MiganowiczPlace 111 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:58.35 |
| 112 | Kevin SheehanPlace 112 · Bridgewater | — | Bridgewater | 4:58.77 |
| 113 | Justin DeRosaPlace 113 · Salem State | — | Salem State | 5:02.84 |
| 114 | Brent GleasonPlace 114 · Bridgewater | — | Bridgewater | 5:03.07 |
| 115 | George WrightPlace 115 · Emerging Eli | — | Emerging Eli | 5:03.75 |
| 116 | Adrian MahoneyPlace 116 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 5:10.74 |
| — | Dan Darcy · Bentley | — | Bentley | DNF |