| 1 | Robert RomanoPlace 1 · Grade Fr · Frostburg State | Fr | Frostburg State | 15:54 PR |
| 2 | Jared HallowPlace 2 · Grade - · Potomac State (W.Va.) | - | Potomac State (W.Va.) | 16:06 PR |
| 3 | Michael BurchlawPlace 3 · Grade Fr · Penn State Greater Allegheny | Fr | Penn State Greater Allegheny | 16:10 PR |
| 4 | Brett HoffmanPlace 4 · unattached | — | unattached | 16:13 |
| 5 | Garrett UrbanPlace 5 · Grade Sr · Pitt-Greensburg | Sr | Pitt-Greensburg | 16:36 PR |
| 6 | Greg DirlikPlace 6 · Grade Fr · Potomac State (W.Va.) | Fr | Potomac State (W.Va.) | 17:09 PR |
| 7 | Daniel SpannerPlace 7 · Grade Fr · Pitt-Greensburg | Fr | Pitt-Greensburg | 17:25 PR |
| 8 | Ellis MassiahPlace 8 · Grade Fr · Penn State Greater Allegheny | Fr | Penn State Greater Allegheny | 18:18 PR |
| 9 | Tyler LookabaughPlace 9 · Grade Jr · Pitt-Greensburg | Jr | Pitt-Greensburg | 18:19 PR |
| 10 | Matthew WhitleyPlace 10 · Grade Fr · Frostburg State | Fr | Frostburg State | 18:24 PR |
| 11 | Ben OsmondPlace 11 · unattached | — | unattached | 18:56 |
| 12 | Matthew SpencerPlace 12 · Grade - · Potomac State (W.Va.) | - | Potomac State (W.Va.) | 19:02 PR |
| 13 | Paul HusarPlace 13 · Grade - · Mount Aloysius | - | Mount Aloysius | 19:03 PR |
| 14 | Elsayed AbbassPlace 14 · Grade Fr · Pitt-Greensburg | Fr | Pitt-Greensburg | 19:07 PR |
| 15 | Chase PoolePlace 15 · Grade Fr · Westmoreland County (Pa.) CC | Fr | Westmoreland County (Pa.) CC | 19:26 PR |
| 16 | Nick FrankPlace 16 · Grade Jr · Mount Aloysius | Jr | Mount Aloysius | 19:33 PR |
| 17 | Zachary TalbertPlace 17 · Grade Fr · Frostburg State | Fr | Frostburg State | 19:34 PR |
| 18 | Andrew BradleyPlace 18 · Grade So · Penn State Greater Allegheny | So | Penn State Greater Allegheny | 19:51 PR |
| 19 | Pierce MillerPlace 19 · Grade So · Potomac State (W.Va.) | So | Potomac State (W.Va.) | 20:13 |
| 20 | Derek PribanicPlace 20 · Grade - · Penn State Greater Allegheny | - | Penn State Greater Allegheny | 20:34 PR |
| 21 | Hayden TranterPlace 21 · Grade Fr · Frostburg State | Fr | Frostburg State | 20:52 |
| 22 | Codie BuglarPlace 22 · Grade So · Penn State Greater Allegheny | So | Penn State Greater Allegheny | 21:04 |
| 23 | Michael KimmetPlace 23 · Grade Sr · Pitt-Greensburg | Sr | Pitt-Greensburg | 21:28 PR |
| 24 | Tim KestermontPlace 24 · Grade Jr · Mount Aloysius | Jr | Mount Aloysius | 21:33 |
| 25 | Jacob DrnachPlace 25 · CCAC | — | CCAC | 21:44 |
| 26 | Matthew ScuothorpePlace 26 · Grade - · Mount Aloysius | - | Mount Aloysius | 21:48 PR |
| 27 | Jason LohrPlace 27 · Grade Fr · Westmoreland County (Pa.) CC | Fr | Westmoreland County (Pa.) CC | 21:50 PR |
| 28 | Zachary GreenPlace 28 · Grade So · Potomac State (W.Va.) | So | Potomac State (W.Va.) | 22:15 |
| 29 | Robert PokoraPlace 29 · Grade So · Pitt-Greensburg | So | Pitt-Greensburg | 22:20 |
| 30 | Chris McHughPlace 30 · Grade So · Mount Aloysius | So | Mount Aloysius | 22:29 PR |
| 31 | Darius EicherPlace 31 · Grade - · Pitt-Greensburg | - | Pitt-Greensburg | 22:33 PR |
| 32 | Jacob KulpPlace 32 · Grade - · Pitt-Greensburg | - | Pitt-Greensburg | 22:42 PR |
| 33 | Aidan ShugarsPlace 33 · Grade - · Pennsylvania Highlands CC | - | Pennsylvania Highlands CC | 22:43 PR |
| 34 | Patrick CampionPlace 34 · Grade - · Mount Aloysius | - | Mount Aloysius | 22:55 PR |
| 35 | Glen WolfarthPlace 35 · Grade So · Pitt-Greensburg | So | Pitt-Greensburg | 23:45 |
| 36 | A.J. PapcunikPlace 36 · Grade - · Pennsylvania Highlands CC | - | Pennsylvania Highlands CC | 24:26 PR |
| 37 | Trevor SculthorpePlace 37 · Grade - · Mount Aloysius | - | Mount Aloysius | 24:31 PR |
| 38 | Michael HaluskaPlace 38 · Grade So · Mount Aloysius | So | Mount Aloysius | 25:30 PR |
| 39 | Daniel HarteisPlace 39 · Grade - · Mount Aloysius | - | Mount Aloysius | 26:39 PR |
| 40 | Marcus GareyPlace 40 · Grade - · Potomac State (W.Va.) | - | Potomac State (W.Va.) | 27:26 PR |
| 41 | Jesse KingPlace 41 · CCAC | — | CCAC | 28:52 |
| 42 | Aaron BurkePlace 42 · Grade - · Potomac State (W.Va.) | - | Potomac State (W.Va.) | 29:17 PR |
| 43 | Taaj BarnettPlace 43 · CCAC | — | CCAC | 29:20 |
| 44 | Matt ArmentoPlace 44 · CCAC | — | CCAC | 30:27 |