| 1 | Naomi WistnerPlace 1 · Williamsville North | — | Williamsville North | 18:55 |
| 2 | Gwen StokesPlace 2 · Fredonia | — | Fredonia | 19:56 |
| 3 | Rachel LuczakPlace 3 · Immaculata | — | Immaculata | 20:02 |
| 4 | Mikaila BollesPlace 4 · Williamsville North | — | Williamsville North | 20:03 |
| 5 | Megan McMullenPlace 5 · Aquinas | — | Aquinas | 20:10 |
| 6 | Emily BrownPlace 6 · Fredonia | — | Fredonia | 20:25 |
| 7 | Meadow WistnerPlace 7 · Williamsville North | — | Williamsville North | 20:32 |
| 8 | Libby BenzerPlace 8 · Immaculata | — | Immaculata | 20:33 |
| 9 | Mary Frances GagePlace 9 · Williamsville North | — | Williamsville North | 20:44 |
| 10 | Rebecca ThompsonPlace 10 · Webster Shroeder | — | Webster Shroeder | 20:45 |
| 11 | Mickey KnappPlace 11 · Aquinas | — | Aquinas | 20:47 |
| 12 | Cameron PerryPlace 12 · Pembroke | — | Pembroke | 20:50 |
| 13 | Sydney SwanPlace 13 · Fredonia | — | Fredonia | 20:56 |
| 14 | Claire FoleyPlace 14 · Nichols | — | Nichols | 20:58 |
| 15 | Elizabeth CarneyPlace 15 · Webster Shroeder | — | Webster Shroeder | 21:08 |
| 16 | Lauren GaumePlace 16 · Immaculata | — | Immaculata | 21:26 |
| 17 | Alia ZeidPlace 17 · Williamsville North | — | Williamsville North | 21:28 |
| 18 | Hailey MillerPlace 18 · Nichols | — | Nichols | 21:30 |
| 19 | Joanna O'SullivanPlace 19 · Aquinas | — | Aquinas | 21:30 |
| 20 | Anna RickardPlace 20 · Roy-Hart | — | Roy-Hart | 21:31 |
| 21 | Kelsey ClemnyPlace 21 · Roy-Hart | — | Roy-Hart | 21:31 |
| 22 | Ellie GarrityPlace 22 · Williamsville North | — | Williamsville North | 21:41 |
| 23 | Emily BrigmanPlace 23 · Lancaster | — | Lancaster | 21:49 |
| 24 | Rebekka TanPlace 24 · Webster Shroeder | — | Webster Shroeder | 21:56 |
| 25 | Anna SchmitzPlace 25 · Immaculata | — | Immaculata | 22:03 |
| 26 | Adelyn CarneyPlace 26 · Webster Shroeder | — | Webster Shroeder | 22:03 |
| 27 | Kayla LeoPlace 27 · Immaculata | — | Immaculata | 22:13 |
| 28 | Maitland LangworthyPlace 28 · Fredonia | — | Fredonia | 22:14 |
| 29 | Morgan BremerPlace 29 · Immaculata | — | Immaculata | 22:31 |
| 30 | Brianna WalkerPlace 30 · Webster Shroeder | — | Webster Shroeder | 22:32 |
| 31 | Olivia KucharskiPlace 31 · Lancaster | — | Lancaster | 22:33 |
| 32 | Aurora MerwinPlace 32 · Fredonia | — | Fredonia | 22:34 |
| 33 | Abbi CharvatPlace 33 · Nichols | — | Nichols | 22:36 |
| 34 | Makila MeansPlace 34 · Niagara Falls | — | Niagara Falls | 22:41 |
| 35 | Jenna NeumaierPlace 35 · Lancaster | — | Lancaster | 22:46 |
| 36 | Clare PivaurunasPlace 36 · Immaculata | — | Immaculata | 22:50 |
| 37 | Kate FiorellaPlace 37 · Fredonia | — | Fredonia | 23:05 |
| 38 | Gianna BushPlace 38 · Niagara Falls | — | Niagara Falls | 23:14 |
| 39 | Emily DysonPlace 39 · Pembroke | — | Pembroke | 23:19 |
| 40 | Claire StokesPlace 40 · Fredonia | — | Fredonia | 23:25 |
| 41 | Madison BairdPlace 41 · Williamsville North | — | Williamsville North | 23:27 |
| 42 | Gracie NewmanPlace 42 · Nichols | — | Nichols | 23:30 |
| 43 | Indigo CollierPlace 43 · Aquinas | — | Aquinas | 23:31 |
| 44 | Ashley AmantiaPlace 44 · Niagara Falls | — | Niagara Falls | 23:32 |
| 45 | Kaitlyn DolanPlace 45 · Nichols | — | Nichols | 23:48 |
| 46 | Colleen UlrichPlace 46 · Roy-Hart | — | Roy-Hart | 23:49 |
| 47 | Lily ShumanPlace 47 · Nichols | — | Nichols | 24:00 |
| 48 | Kameryn DuellPlace 48 · Warsaw | — | Warsaw | 24:03 |
| 49 | Kaitlynn TuohyPlace 49 · Grand Island | — | Grand Island | 24:09 |
| 50 | Mariah FriedmannPlace 50 · Pembroke | — | Pembroke | 24:10 |
| 51 | Genna BaldassarrePlace 51 · Grand Island | — | Grand Island | 24:10 |
| 52 | Tabitha WechlerPlace 52 · Lancaster | — | Lancaster | 24:14 |
| 53 | Stephanie StreetPlace 53 · Lancaster | — | Lancaster | 24:15 |
| 54 | Katelyn DiBenedettoPlace 54 · Roy-Hart | — | Roy-Hart | 24:15 |
| 55 | Maricella FusilloPlace 55 · Grand Island | — | Grand Island | 24:20 |
| 56 | Kennedy LangPlace 56 · Roy-Hart | — | Roy-Hart | 24:29 |
| 57 | Jennette DiLauraPlace 57 · Grand Island | — | Grand Island | 24:32 |
| 58 | Vanessa ShoresPlace 58 · Grand Island | — | Grand Island | 24:41 |
| 59 | Elizabeth GeiserPlace 59 · Webster Shroeder | — | Webster Shroeder | 24:43 |
| 60 | Olivia JohnsonPlace 60 · Grand Island | — | Grand Island | 24:50 |
| 61 | Kayla MazukiewiczPlace 61 · Lancaster | — | Lancaster | 24:53 |
| 62 | Shayne BulmerPlace 62 · Roy-Hart | — | Roy-Hart | 24:57 |
| 63 | Emily ShermanPlace 63 · Notre Dame | — | Notre Dame | 25:00 |
| 64 | Alyssa EaganPlace 64 · Niagara Falls | — | Niagara Falls | 25:04 |
| 65 | Samantha DoktorPlace 65 · Pembroke | — | Pembroke | 25:06 |
| 66 | Jessica BukowskiPlace 66 · Notre Dame | — | Notre Dame | 25:19 |
| 67 | Lena O'NeillPlace 67 · Nichols | — | Nichols | 25:37 |
| 68 | Aya FakihPlace 68 · Niagara Falls | — | Niagara Falls | 26:29 |
| 69 | Sarah GiamerdinoPlace 69 · Aquinas | — | Aquinas | 26:52 |
| 70 | Hannah NagowskiPlace 70 · Lancaster | — | Lancaster | 27:01 |
| 71 | Anna KabelPlace 71 · Notre Dame | — | Notre Dame | 27:04 |
| 72 | Abbey PeabodyPlace 72 · Aquinas | — | Aquinas | 27:06 |
| 73 | Sandy SparksPlace 73 · Roy-Hart | — | Roy-Hart | 27:20 |
| 74 | Misty RutzenPlace 74 · Roy-Hart | — | Roy-Hart | 27:26 |
| 75 | Samira HossainPlace 75 · Aquinas | — | Aquinas | 29:22 |
| 76 | Lauren WorthyPlace 76 · Aquinas | — | Aquinas | 29:22 |
| 77 | Kathryn MillerPlace 77 · Warsaw | — | Warsaw | 29:29 |
| 78 | Kelsey HillburgerPlace 78 · Notre Dame | — | Notre Dame | 29:37 |
| 79 | Alyssa TavinoPlace 79 · Aquinas | — | Aquinas | 29:47 |
| 80 | Samantha NickersonPlace 80 · Notre Dame | — | Notre Dame | 31:56 |
| 81 | Samantha CarneyPlace 81 · Notre Dame | — | Notre Dame | 34:14 |