| 1 | Colm MulliganPlace 1 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:18 |
| 2 | Peter LantzPlace 2 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:29 |
| 3 | Sam HetrickPlace 3 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:35 |
| 4 | Chad PakozdiPlace 4 · Una-Thiel | — | Una-Thiel | 7:43 |
| 5 | Patrick SharpPlace 5 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:35 |
| 6 | Caleb FreemanPlace 6 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:40 |
| 7 | Nick GalloPlace 7 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:35 |
| 8 | Joseph McAuliffePlace 8 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:40 |
| 9 | Zach WysePlace 9 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:40 |
| 10 | Lucas BradleyPlace 10 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:44 |
| 11 | Matt BeuermannPlace 11 · Thiel | — | Thiel | 7:42 |
| 12 | Cole JoostePlace 12 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:41 |
| 13 | Desmond CorradoPlace 13 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:42 |
| 14 | Mac PolnyPlace 14 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:49 |
| 15 | Adam CookPlace 15 · Allegheny Alumni | — | Allegheny Alumni | 7:45 |
| 16 | William NicholsPlace 16 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 8:12 |
| 17 | Charles BroussardPlace 17 · Chatham | — | Chatham | 8:17 |
| 18 | Tony KerrPlace 18 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 8:10 |
| 19 | Xavier GrovePlace 19 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 7:56 |
| 20 | Andrew YocumPlace 20 · Thiel | — | Thiel | 8:32 |
| 21 | E KelleyPlace 21 · Chatham | — | Chatham | 8:11 |
| 22 | Benjamin BrownPlace 22 · Chatham | — | Chatham | 8:26 |
| 23 | Brady WingeartPlace 23 · Chatham | — | Chatham | 8:48 |
| 24 | Jonathan JewettPlace 24 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 8:35 |
| 25 | Nick HayesPlace 25 · Psu-DuBois | — | Psu-DuBois | 8:35 |
| 26 | Nathaniel TurnerPlace 26 · Thiel | — | Thiel | 8:49 |
| 27 | Legion LakePlace 27 · Thiel | — | Thiel | 26:31 |
| 28 | Devon FlynnpearaultPlace 28 · Allegheny Alumni | — | Allegheny Alumni | 9:06 |
| 29 | Tristan MlynarekPlace 29 · Thiel | — | Thiel | 18:55 |
| 30 | Eliel CortezPlace 30 · Allegheny | — | Allegheny | 8:40 |
| 31 | Atai AituvarovPlace 31 · La Roche | — | La Roche | 9:18 |
| 32 | Oscar ContrerasPlace 32 · Carlow | — | Carlow | 9:19 |
| 33 | Rowan ThomasPlace 33 · Thiel | — | Thiel | 10:01 |
| 34 | Isaiah SteinPlace 34 · Carlow | — | Carlow | 9:03 |
| 35 | Demetrius BroadnaxPlace 35 · Chatham | — | Chatham | 9:19 |
| 36 | Marco PecconPlace 36 · Psu-Fayette | — | Psu-Fayette | 9:46 |
| 37 | Samuel LeonardPlace 37 · Psu-Fayette | — | Psu-Fayette | 10:10 |
| 38 | Ryan HannaPlace 38 · Psu-DuBois | — | Psu-DuBois | 10:06 |
| 39 | Byron GaskinsPlace 39 · Carlow | — | Carlow | 9:37 |
| 40 | Chris CorkinsPlace 40 · Allegheny Alumni | — | Allegheny Alumni | 10:46 |
| 41 | Chase HookPlace 41 · Psu-DuBois | — | Psu-DuBois | 10:18 |
| 42 | Stephen CulliananPlace 42 · Allegheny Alumni | — | Allegheny Alumni | 10:46 |
| 43 | Matt SvetzPlace 43 · Allegheny Alumni | — | Allegheny Alumni | 10:47 |
| 44 | Gavin McLainPlace 44 · Carlow | — | Carlow | 10:11 |
| 45 | Nathan StocktonPlace 45 · La Roche | — | La Roche | 34:03 |
| 46 | Joey MorrisonPlace 46 · Psu-DuBois | — | Psu-DuBois | 11:13 |
| 47 | Paul CoccaPlace 47 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 11:40 |
| 48 | Matt HoyPlace 48 · Allegheny Alumni | — | Allegheny Alumni | 11:04 |
| 49 | Patrick ChewningPlace 49 · La Roche | — | La Roche | 16:13 |