| 1 | Hudson StepperPlace 1 · Grade 10 · Trinity School | 10 | Trinity School | 15:22.5 PR |
| 2 | Caden YellenPlace 2 · Grade 11 · Trinity School | 11 | Trinity School | 15:23.2 PR |
| 3 | Andrew PatelPlace 3 · Grade 10 · Poly Prep Country Day | 10 | Poly Prep Country Day | 15:34.9 PR |
| 4 | August MillerPlace 4 · Grade 11 · Riverdale Country | 11 | Riverdale Country | 15:39.5 |
| 5 | Sam SleeperPlace 5 · Grade 9 · Dalton | 9 | Dalton | 15:40.3 |
| 6 | Joasaphat ValdezPlace 6 · Grade 11 · Collegiate | 11 | Collegiate | 15:43.7 |
| 7 | David LarenaPlace 7 · Grade 11 · Riverdale Country | 11 | Riverdale Country | 15:46.2 PR |
| 8 | Sachin LuftPlace 8 · Grade 10 · Trinity School | 10 | Trinity School | 16:01.2 |
| 9 | Elijah LeblangPlace 9 · Grade 12 · Riverdale Country | 12 | Riverdale Country | 16:02.8 PR |
| 10 | Jordan McNeilPlace 10 · Grade 11 · Dalton | 11 | Dalton | 16:05.1 PR |
| 11 | Noah SheffPlace 11 · Grade 12 · Dalton | 12 | Dalton | 16:05.5 PR |
| 12 | Chris XuPlace 12 · Grade 11 · Collegiate | 11 | Collegiate | 16:08.4 |
| 13 | Wynton CapellanPlace 13 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 16:11.3 |
| 14 | Enzo ScolaPlace 14 · Grade 12 · Collegiate | 12 | Collegiate | 16:11.7 |
| 15 | Bennett MosesPlace 15 · Grade 11 · Trinity School | 11 | Trinity School | 16:13.2 PR |
| 16 | Chase BlumenfeldPlace 16 · Grade 11 · Dalton | 11 | Dalton | 16:16.9 PR |
| 17 | Jackson MeadowcroftPlace 17 · Grade 9 · Dalton | 9 | Dalton | 16:20.0 |
| 18 | Ben JohnsonPlace 18 · Grade 11 · Dalton | 11 | Dalton | 16:24.8 |
| 19 | James KirkbridePlace 19 · Grade 9 · Hackley | 9 | Hackley | 16:25.0 |
| 20 | Owen HardartPlace 20 · Grade 9 · Hackley | 9 | Hackley | 16:25.3 PR |
| 21 | Jesse SchwartzPlace 21 · Grade 9 · Hackley | 9 | Hackley | 16:26.0 PR |
| 22 | Roan CaffreyPlace 22 · Grade 10 · Trinity School | 10 | Trinity School | 16:27.0 PR |
| 23 | Theodore SteelePlace 23 · Grade 11 · Trinity School | 11 | Trinity School | 16:28.5 |
| 24 | Parker HavlanPlace 24 · Grade 10 · Dalton | 10 | Dalton | 16:31.8 |
| 25 | Max FerreiraPlace 25 · Grade 11 · Collegiate | 11 | Collegiate | 16:32.4 PR |
| 26 | Finlay SandsPlace 26 · Grade 10 · Riverdale Country | 10 | Riverdale Country | 16:33.9 PR |
| 27 | Collins AboagyePlace 27 · Grade 11 · Riverdale Country | 11 | Riverdale Country | 16:34.1 PR |
| 28 | Steven SengerPlace 28 · Grade 10 · Hackley | 10 | Hackley | 16:38.7 PR |
| 29 | Declan DaileaderPlace 29 · Grade 11 · Collegiate | 11 | Collegiate | 16:40.5 |
| 30 | Williem HaleyPlace 30 · Grade 9 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 9 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 16:44.0 PR |
| 31 | Hart HicksPlace 31 · Grade 10 · Poly Prep Country Day | 10 | Poly Prep Country Day | 16:49.0 |
| 32 | Mark AlbrechtPlace 32 · Grade 11 · Horace Mann | 11 | Horace Mann | 16:49.2 |
| 33 | Xavier ChenPlace 33 · Grade 10 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 10 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 16:54.1 PR |
| 34 | Kadin HertzogPlace 34 · Grade 10 · Trinity School | 10 | Trinity School | 17:00.1 |
| 35 | Bram CohenPlace 35 · Grade 10 · Horace Mann | 10 | Horace Mann | 17:02.2 PR |
| 36 | Leo JacobsonPlace 36 · Grade 11 · Dalton | 11 | Dalton | 17:06.3 |
| 37 | Oliver EpsteinPlace 37 · Grade 12 · Trinity School | 12 | Trinity School | 17:08.3 |
| 38 | Sid SinghPlace 38 · Grade 9 · Dalton | 9 | Dalton | 17:12.0 PR |
| 39 | Cillian O'RorkePlace 39 · Grade 9 · Hackley | 9 | Hackley | 17:13.3 |
| 40 | Eric ChudyPlace 40 · Grade 12 · Riverdale Country | 12 | Riverdale Country | 17:19.2 PR |
| 41 | Theo McAllister-NevinsPlace 41 · Grade 10 · Trinity School | 10 | Trinity School | 17:20.4 PR |
| 42 | James BorthwickPlace 42 · Grade 12 · Riverdale Country | 12 | Riverdale Country | 17:24.2 PR |
| 43 | Nakul SethiPlace 43 · Grade 10 · Horace Mann | 10 | Horace Mann | 17:24.2 PR |
| 44 | Augustus 'Gus ChiPlace 44 · Grade 10 · Trinity School | 10 | Trinity School | 17:30.9 PR |
| 45 | Vihaan AgarwalPlace 45 · Grade 10 · Hackley | 10 | Hackley | 17:32.4 |
| 46 | Eli PrawerPlace 46 · Grade 11 · Riverdale Country | 11 | Riverdale Country | 17:33.5 |
| 47 | Zachary BenderPlace 47 · Grade 12 · Trinity School | 12 | Trinity School | 17:34.3 PR |
| 48 | Max ClipperPlace 48 · Grade 9 · Hackley | 9 | Hackley | 17:36.6 PR |
| 49 | Kush UpadhyayaPlace 49 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 17:36.7 PR |
| 50 | Nicholas SaitaPlace 50 · Grade 10 · Horace Mann | 10 | Horace Mann | 17:43.2 |
| 51 | Arjun DesaiPlace 51 · Grade 9 · Horace Mann | 9 | Horace Mann | 17:46.1 |
| 52 | Gabriel EscallonPlace 52 · Grade 9 · Hackley | 9 | Hackley | 17:52.5 |
| 53 | Alexander BelmanPlace 53 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 17:54.0 PR |
| 54 | Connor WattsPlace 54 · Grade 11 · Dalton | 11 | Dalton | 17:56.2 |
| 55 | Sebastian JimenezPlace 55 · Grade 11 · Hackley | 11 | Hackley | 17:56.4 PR |
| 56 | James SimmonsPlace 56 · Grade 10 · Dalton | 10 | Dalton | 17:58.0 |
| 57 | Carter HebardPlace 57 · Grade 12 · Trinity School | 12 | Trinity School | 17:58.5 |
| 58 | Wyatt SimpsonPlace 58 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 17:59.6 PR |
| 59 | William OuthwaitePlace 59 · Grade 9 · Horace Mann | 9 | Horace Mann | 18:06.8 |
| 60 | David KulmanPlace 60 · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 18:07.5 PR |
| 61 | Nicholas TongPlace 61 · Grade 10 · Horace Mann | 10 | Horace Mann | 18:08.5 PR |
| 62 | John MowreyPlace 62 · Grade 10 · Horace Mann | 10 | Horace Mann | 18:13.1 PR |
| 63 | Raphael BenaimPlace 63 · Grade 9 · Dalton | 9 | Dalton | 18:13.6 PR |
| 64 | Theo SchwiderPlace 64 · Grade 11 · Riverdale Country | 11 | Riverdale Country | 18:14.1 |
| 65 | Sebastian ArmandPlace 65 · Grade 10 · Riverdale Country | 10 | Riverdale Country | 18:31.3 |
| 66 | Marcos EstevezPlace 66 · Grade 10 · Dalton | 10 | Dalton | 18:38.9 PR |
| 67 | Archer BerhalterPlace 67 · Grade 9 · Hackley | 9 | Hackley | 18:48.6 PR |
| 68 | Evan KimPlace 68 · Grade 11 · Dalton | 11 | Dalton | 18:52.5 |
| 69 | Hadrian ChodryPlace 69 · Grade 11 · Riverdale Country | 11 | Riverdale Country | 18:53.5 |
| 70 | Ben WeidmanPlace 70 · Grade 11 · Dalton | 11 | Dalton | 18:57.2 |
| 71 | Tien MawhinneyPlace 71 · Grade 11 · Dalton | 11 | Dalton | 19:00.1 PR |
| 72 | Rohan VariaPlace 72 · Grade 11 · Riverdale Country | 11 | Riverdale Country | 20:31.5 |
| 73 | William ChovanecPlace 73 · Grade 10 · Trinity School | 10 | Trinity School | 21:15.1 PR |