| 1 | Joseph HughesPlace 1 · Grade Jr · Southern Virginia | Jr | Southern Virginia | 16:27.5 |
| 2 | Taylor WeilandPlace 2 · Grade Fr · Southern Virginia | Fr | Southern Virginia | 16:28.2 PR |
| 3 | Luke BuckwalterPlace 3 · Grade So · Eastern Mennonite | So | Eastern Mennonite | 17:25.1 PR |
| 4 | Noah BangaPlace 4 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 17:36.7 PR |
| 5 | Mason FerrarioPlace 5 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 17:39.2 PR |
| 6 | Gary RogersPlace 6 · Grade So · Southern Virginia | So | Southern Virginia | 17:44.2 PR |
| 7 | Patrick DevinePlace 7 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 17:47.1 PR |
| 8 | Carter JohnsonPlace 8 · Grade Sr · Southern Virginia | Sr | Southern Virginia | 17:58.7 |
| 9 | Ben HuyardPlace 9 · Grade Jr · Eastern Mennonite | Jr | Eastern Mennonite | 18:32.5 |
| 10 | Nick PorcaroPlace 10 · Grade Fr · Eastern Mennonite | Fr | Eastern Mennonite | 18:40.4 PR |
| 11 | Nick Gutierrez FrancoPlace 11 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 18:45.2 PR |
| 12 | Berrett TiraPlace 12 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 18:45.6 PR |
| 13 | Logan BoydPlace 13 · Grade Fr · Eastern Mennonite | Fr | Eastern Mennonite | 18:54.4 PR |
| 14 | Easton HigleyPlace 14 · Grade Fr · Southern Virginia | Fr | Southern Virginia | 18:57.2 PR |
| 15 | Alex BelislePlace 15 · Grade Jr · Eastern Mennonite | Jr | Eastern Mennonite | 18:58.8 |
| 16 | Carson RedmonPlace 16 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 19:20.2 PR |
| 17 | Sam MyersPlace 17 · Grade So · Eastern Mennonite | So | Eastern Mennonite | 19:22.6 PR |
| 18 | Colin KirkwoodPlace 18 · Grade Sr · James Madison University Club | Sr | James Madison University Club | 19:27.2 PR |
| 19 | Henry GemerekPlace 19 · Grade So · James Madison University Club | So | James Madison University Club | 19:28.2 PR |
| 20 | Truman MeyerPlace 20 · Grade So · Southern Virginia | So | Southern Virginia | 19:41.7 PR |
| 21 | Ethan KanagyPlace 21 · Grade Jr · Eastern Mennonite | Jr | Eastern Mennonite | 20:24.2 PR |
| 22 | Daniel MeyerPlace 22 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 20:24.4 PR |
| 23 | Clayton KauffmanPlace 23 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 20:24.9 |
| 24 | Abenezer AbebePlace 24 · Grade Jr · Eastern Mennonite | Jr | Eastern Mennonite | 20:30.9 |
| 25 | Noah BuckwalterPlace 25 · Grade So · Eastern Mennonite | So | Eastern Mennonite | 20:53.5 PR |
| 26 | Dylan SwisherPlace 26 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 20:58.4 PR |
| 27 | Sam WrightPlace 27 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 21:54.0 PR |
| 28 | Soren DoucettePlace 28 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 22:47.2 PR |
| 29 | Matthew HowertonPlace 29 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 22:53.3 PR |
| 30 | Landon BakerPlace 30 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 23:40.5 PR |
| 31 | Jackson HamrickPlace 31 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 23:40.9 PR |
| 32 | Jason SamuelsPlace 32 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 24:20.6 PR |
| 33 | Ben ClosterPlace 33 · Grade - · James Madison University Club | - | James Madison University Club | 25:13.9 PR |
