| 1 | Joshua BreardPlace 1 · Grade Sr · Kenyon | Sr | Kenyon | 19:14.50 PR |
| 2 | Charlie BlackmerPlace 2 · Grade So · Kenyon | So | Kenyon | 19:18.10 PR |
| 3 | Colter (Colt) MurphyPlace 3 · Grade Sr · Kenyon | Sr | Kenyon | 19:25.20 PR |
| 4 | Lucas EiselePlace 4 · Grade Sr · Wittenberg | Sr | Wittenberg | 19:29.30 PR |
| 5 | Will JacksonPlace 5 · Grade Fr · Denison | Fr | Denison | 19:37.20 PR |
| 6 | Dylan SibbittPlace 6 · Grade Sr · Kenyon | Sr | Kenyon | 19:47.60 PR |
| 7 | Noah CyrPlace 7 · Grade Sr · Denison | Sr | Denison | 19:54.70 PR |
| 8 | Adam SkidmorePlace 8 · Grade Fr · Kenyon | Fr | Kenyon | 19:58.20 PR |
| 9 | Liam NewmanPlace 9 · Grade Sr · Oberlin | Sr | Oberlin | 20:00.40 PR |
| 10 | Charlie EndresPlace 10 · Grade Sr · Oberlin | Sr | Oberlin | 20:06.00 PR |
| 11 | Jacob BlubaughPlace 11 · Grade So · Ohio Wesleyan | So | Ohio Wesleyan | 20:14.10 |
| 12 | Leo WisnefskiPlace 12 · Grade JR · Unattached | JR | Unattached | 20:15.80 |
| 13 | Will GordonPlace 13 · Grade Jr · Oberlin | Jr | Oberlin | 20:17.70 PR |
| 14 | Ryan FarisPlace 14 · Grade Fr · Oberlin | Fr | Oberlin | 20:20.90 PR |
| 15 | Charlie MenzelPlace 15 · Grade So · Kenyon | So | Kenyon | 20:21.40 |
| 16 | Henry RodriguesPlace 16 · Grade Sr · Kenyon | Sr | Kenyon | 20:21.60 PR |
| 17 | Caleb LowPlace 17 · Grade So · Kenyon | So | Kenyon | 20:21.70 PR |
| 18 | Champ BlosePlace 18 · Grade Fr · Kenyon | Fr | Kenyon | 20:22.50 PR |
| 19 | Owen RodstromPlace 19 · Grade Sr · Kenyon | Sr | Kenyon | 20:30.60 PR |
| 20 | Sebastian KlimchakPlace 20 · Grade Fr · Denison | Fr | Denison | 20:30.80 PR |
| 21 | Phinnigan SpindlerPlace 21 · Grade So · Denison | So | Denison | 20:36.30 PR |
| 22 | Cooper TanskiPlace 22 · Grade Fr · Oberlin | Fr | Oberlin | 20:38.90 PR |
| 23 | Noah BergPlace 23 · Grade Fr · Kenyon | Fr | Kenyon | 20:45.60 PR |
| 24 | Noah HopkinsPlace 24 · Grade Sr · Kenyon | Sr | Kenyon | 20:45.80 PR |
| 25 | Jack EvansPlace 25 · Grade So · Denison | So | Denison | 20:49.00 PR |
| 26 | William FontanaPlace 26 · Grade Fr · Denison | Fr | Denison | 20:53.40 PR |
| 27 | Luke GalikPlace 27 · Grade Fr · Kenyon | Fr | Kenyon | 20:55.00 |
| 28 | John SchaalPlace 28 · Grade Fr · Kenyon | Fr | Kenyon | 20:58.00 PR |
| 29 | Hudson JonesPlace 29 · Grade So · Denison | So | Denison | 20:59.20 PR |
| 30 | Dylan RyznarPlace 30 · Grade So · Kenyon | So | Kenyon | 21:00.10 PR |
| 31 | Elijah Van farowePlace 31 · Grade Sr · Denison | Sr | Denison | 21:00.70 PR |
| 32 | Ivan PanovPlace 32 · Grade Fr · Denison | Fr | Denison | 21:07.10 PR |
| 33 | Lucas WeaverPlace 33 · Grade Jr · Ohio Wesleyan | Jr | Ohio Wesleyan | 21:18.20 PR |
| 34 | Austin KlingPlace 34 · Grade Fr · Ohio Wesleyan | Fr | Ohio Wesleyan | 21:21.60 PR |
| 35 | Grant HirschPlace 35 · Grade So · Oberlin | So | Oberlin | 21:26.60 PR |
| 36 | Toby Wells-SpackmanPlace 36 · Grade So · Oberlin | So | Oberlin | 21:30.30 PR |
| 37 | Cole ClodgoPlace 37 · Grade Jr · Denison | Jr | Denison | 21:40.90 PR |
| 38 | Jackson BeemerPlace 38 · Grade Fr · Kenyon | Fr | Kenyon | 21:45.00 |
| 39 | Casey SmothersPlace 39 · Grade Fr · Oberlin | Fr | Oberlin | 21:47.10 PR |
| 40 | Jay PatelPlace 40 · Grade Fr · Wittenberg | Fr | Wittenberg | 21:47.90 PR |
| 41 | Perry JacksonPlace 41 · Grade Jr · Ohio Wesleyan | Jr | Ohio Wesleyan | 21:51.20 |
| 42 | Jonah WaltzPlace 42 · Grade Jr · Denison | Jr | Denison | 21:52.20 |
| 43 | Jimmy BakerPlace 43 · Grade Sr · Kenyon | Sr | Kenyon | 21:57.90 PR |
| 44 | Adam VeottePlace 44 · Grade Fr · Wittenberg | Fr | Wittenberg | 21:59.10 PR |
| 45 | Rosario ScaratoPlace 45 · Grade Fr · Denison | Fr | Denison | 21:59.30 PR |
| 46 | John CoffinPlace 46 · Grade Fr · Kenyon | Fr | Kenyon | 22:00.30 |
| 47 | Jackson FrichtlPlace 47 · Grade Fr · Denison | Fr | Denison | 22:01.30 PR |
| 48 | Xavier PlattPlace 48 · Grade Sr · Ohio Wesleyan | Sr | Ohio Wesleyan | 22:01.30 |
| 49 | Haden KirkhamPlace 49 · Grade Jr · Ohio Wesleyan | Jr | Ohio Wesleyan | 22:06.70 PR |
| 50 | Theo HordonPlace 50 · Grade Jr · Kenyon | Jr | Kenyon | 22:12.50 |
| 51 | Simon SwaiPlace 51 · Grade Fr · Oberlin | Fr | Oberlin | 22:39.40 PR |
| 52 | Tyler TangPlace 52 · Grade Sr · Ohio Wesleyan | Sr | Ohio Wesleyan | 22:46.80 |
| 53 | Naveen VemulapalliPlace 53 · Grade Fr · Denison | Fr | Denison | 22:56.60 PR |
| 54 | Elijah DayPlace 54 · Grade Fr · Denison | Fr | Denison | 22:58.50 PR |
| 55 | Henry HorsleyPlace 55 · Grade Fr · Kenyon | Fr | Kenyon | 23:05.00 PR |
| 56 | Ben NortonPlace 56 · Grade SR · Unattached | SR | Unattached | 23:45.60 |
| 57 | Colby SpraguePlace 57 · Grade So · Ohio Wesleyan | So | Ohio Wesleyan | 23:53.50 |
| 58 | Tully Valentine-MaherPlace 58 · Grade Fr · Oberlin | Fr | Oberlin | 24:18.20 PR |
| 59 | Taylor InsyxiengmayPlace 59 · Grade Sr · Wittenberg | Sr | Wittenberg | 25:00.50 PR |
