| 1 | Gavin OliverPlace 1 · Grade 11 · Monsignor Donovan | 11 | Monsignor Donovan | 16:02.57 |
| 2 | Connor BassolinoPlace 2 · Grade 12 · Oratory Prep | 12 | Oratory Prep | 16:26.57 |
| 3 | James NolanPlace 3 · Grade 12 · Oratory Prep | 12 | Oratory Prep | 16:32.41 PR |
| 4 | Dominic MoscatelloPlace 4 · Grade 9 · Christian Brothers Academy | 9 | Christian Brothers Academy | 16:36.79 |
| 5 | Justin VentimigliaPlace 5 · Grade 10 · Christian Brothers Academy | 10 | Christian Brothers Academy | 16:44.37 PR |
| 6 | Nicholas MarxPlace 6 · Grade 11 · Christian Brothers Academy | 11 | Christian Brothers Academy | 16:48.77 |
| 7 | Daniel WatsonPlace 7 · Grade 10 · Immaculata | 10 | Immaculata | 16:56.55 |
| 8 | Matthew O'ReillyPlace 8 · Grade 12 · Delbarton | 12 | Delbarton | 17:04.37 |
| 9 | Michael RomeroPlace 9 · Grade 11 · Christian Brothers Academy | 11 | Christian Brothers Academy | 17:11.15 |
| 10 | Gideon RiveraPlace 10 · Grade 9 · Christian Brothers Academy | 9 | Christian Brothers Academy | 17:12.52 |
| 11 | Preston SousaPlace 11 · Grade 10 · Immaculata | 10 | Immaculata | 17:14.60 |
| 12 | Harry AndersonPlace 12 · Grade 11 · St Peters Prep | 11 | St Peters Prep | 17:14.91 |
| 13 | Lucien BretPlace 13 · Grade 11 · Delbarton | 11 | Delbarton | 17:23.76 PR |
| 14 | Timothy EllingsonPlace 14 · Grade 11 · Notre Dame | 11 | Notre Dame | 17:27.19 |
| 15 | Benjamin ChaPlace 15 · Grade 11 · Bergen Catholic | 11 | Bergen Catholic | 17:29.67 |
| 16 | Matthew FicPlace 16 · Grade 11 · Delbarton | 11 | Delbarton | 17:31.31 |
| 17 | Aldan PhilipsonPlace 17 · Grade 10 · Christian Brothers Academy | 10 | Christian Brothers Academy | 17:41.34 |
| 18 | Kevin EllingsonPlace 18 · Grade 9 · Notre Dame | 9 | Notre Dame | 17:43.48 PR |
| 19 | Chase LynchPlace 19 · Grade 12 · Oratory Prep | 12 | Oratory Prep | 17:44.21 PR |
| 20 | John McCabePlace 20 · Grade 11 · St Peters Prep | 11 | St Peters Prep | 17:46.73 |
| 21 | Stephen PolefkoPlace 21 · Grade 9 · Oratory Prep | 9 | Oratory Prep | 17:47.43 PR |
| 22 | Todd SmithPlace 22 · Grade 11 · Delbarton | 11 | Delbarton | 17:51.76 |
| 23 | Maddox KimPlace 23 · Grade 10 · St Peters Prep | 10 | St Peters Prep | 17:52.01 |
| 24 | Harry SanghaPlace 24 · Grade 10 · St Peters Prep | 10 | St Peters Prep | 17:52.94 |
| 25 | Henry GilfillanPlace 25 · Grade 11 · St Peters Prep | 11 | St Peters Prep | 17:53.06 |
| 26 | Reece WilsonPlace 26 · Grade 10 · Pope John XXIII | 10 | Pope John XXIII | 17:53.76 |
| 27 | Matthew HeyerPlace 27 · Grade 10 · Delbarton | 10 | Delbarton | 17:56.14 |
| 28 | Karl KrajewskiPlace 28 · Grade 10 · Morris Catholic | 10 | Morris Catholic | 17:56.47 PR |
| 29 | Alexander KieschkePlace 29 · Grade 12 · Oratory Prep | 12 | Oratory Prep | 17:58.41 PR |
| 30 | Nicholas KatsgiannisPlace 30 · Grade 9 · Pope John XXIII | 9 | Pope John XXIII | 17:59.81 |
| 31 | Henry MayPlace 31 · Grade 12 · Union Catholic Reg | 12 | Union Catholic Reg | 18:06.62 PR |
| 32 | Simeon SalinsPlace 32 · Grade 11 · Notre Dame | 11 | Notre Dame | 18:09.78 |
| 33 | Julius LunaPlace 33 · Grade 11 · Paramus Catholic | 11 | Paramus Catholic | 18:10.89 PR |
| 34 | Gabriel HowardPlace 34 · Grade 11 · St Peters Prep | 11 | St Peters Prep | 18:12.62 |
| 35 | Jack FalconePlace 35 · Grade 11 · Bergen Catholic | 11 | Bergen Catholic | 18:13.65 |
| 36 | Jacob SutphinPlace 36 · Grade 10 · Union Catholic Reg | 10 | Union Catholic Reg | 18:14.69 |
| 37 | Sal MehalarisPlace 37 · Grade 11 · Seton Hall Prep | 11 | Seton Hall Prep | 18:18.90 |
| 38 | Matthew BenzPlace 38 · Grade 10 · Bergen Catholic | 10 | Bergen Catholic | 18:28.95 PR |
| 39 | Jack FlynnPlace 39 · Grade 10 · Seton Hall Prep | 10 | Seton Hall Prep | 18:32.59 PR |
| 40 | Chad VassalloPlace 40 · Grade 10 · Oratory Prep | 10 | Oratory Prep | 18:33.53 |
| 41 | Jonathan GelsPlace 41 · Grade 10 · Delbarton | 10 | Delbarton | 18:41.33 |
| 42 | Sal SignorinoPlace 42 · Lumen Gentium | — | Lumen Gentium | 18:42.21 |
| 43 | Greyson AstlePlace 43 · Grade 9 · Oratory Prep | 9 | Oratory Prep | 18:44.15 |
| 44 | Walter SuhPlace 44 · Grade 11 · Bergen Catholic | 11 | Bergen Catholic | 18:45.70 PR |
| 45 | Neil Van KirkPlace 45 · Grade 12 · Delbarton | 12 | Delbarton | 19:01.33 |
| 46 | Brady BaxterPlace 46 · Grade 11 · Morris Catholic | 11 | Morris Catholic | 19:03.09 |
| 47 | Daniel CabarcasPlace 47 · Grade 10 · Immaculata | 10 | Immaculata | 19:04.44 |
| 48 | Andrew BarabasPlace 48 · Grade 10 · Bergen Catholic | 10 | Bergen Catholic | 19:08.66 |
| 49 | Kyle PumaradaPlace 49 · Grade 10 · St Peters Prep | 10 | St Peters Prep | 19:08.82 |
| 50 | Kiernan KinneyPlace 50 · Grade 10 · St Rose | 10 | St Rose | 19:15.22 |
| 51 | Declan BrownPlace 51 · Grade 12 · Pope John XXIII | 12 | Pope John XXIII | 19:16.21 PR |
| 52 | Matt WernerPlace 52 · Grade 12 · Seton Hall Prep | 12 | Seton Hall Prep | 19:17.76 |
| 53 | Samuel RodriguezPlace 53 · Grade 9 · Morris Catholic | 9 | Morris Catholic | 19:19.07 |
| 54 | Colby MannionPlace 54 · Grade 10 · Immaculata | 10 | Immaculata | 19:20.37 PR |
| 55 | Michael TuohyPlace 55 · Grade 11 · Bergen Catholic | 11 | Bergen Catholic | 19:23.87 |
| 56 | Malachi MichelPlace 56 · Grade 12 · Seton Hall Prep | 12 | Seton Hall Prep | 19:27.53 |
| 57 | Nick MizzoniPlace 57 · Grade 10 · Pope John XXIII | 10 | Pope John XXIII | 19:29.22 |
| 58 | Dylan SimonelliPlace 58 · Grade 11 · Pope John XXIII | 11 | Pope John XXIII | 19:30.90 PR |
| 59 | Nolan KrebsPlace 59 · Grade 11 · Monsignor Donovan | 11 | Monsignor Donovan | 19:40.60 |
| 60 | Sean HenryPlace 60 · Grade 11 · St Rose | 11 | St Rose | 19:42.28 |
| 61 | Greg GurbiszPlace 61 · Grade 11 · St Thomas Aquinas (Bishop Ahr 1983-2019) | 11 | St Thomas Aquinas (Bishop Ahr 1983-2019) | 19:43.86 |
| 62 | Nicholas TemplesPlace 62 · Grade 11 · Immaculata | 11 | Immaculata | 19:43.98 |
| 63 | Kevin PeoplesPlace 63 · Grade 10 · Seton Hall Prep | 10 | Seton Hall Prep | 19:45.20 |
| 64 | Markus McParlandPlace 64 · Grade 11 · Notre Dame | 11 | Notre Dame | 19:49.56 |
| 65 | Nick BoyanowskiPlace 65 · Grade 11 · Pope John XXIII | 11 | Pope John XXIII | 19:51.56 |
| 66 | Stephen ZotajPlace 66 · Grade 12 · Paramus Catholic | 12 | Paramus Catholic | 19:57.40 |
| 67 | Shaun AppertPlace 67 · Grade 12 · Notre Dame | 12 | Notre Dame | 19:59.83 |
| 68 | Louis CortinaPlace 68 · Grade 10 · Immaculata | 10 | Immaculata | 20:00.33 |
| 69 | Brian DuffPlace 69 · Grade 10 · Bergen Catholic | 10 | Bergen Catholic | 20:14.63 |
| 70 | Leonardi NicholasPlace 70 · Grade 11 · St John Vianney | 11 | St John Vianney | 20:24.74 |
| 71 | Antonio DiazPlace 71 · Grade 11 · Notre Dame | 11 | Notre Dame | 20:27.27 |
| 72 | Jackson MelchiorePlace 72 · Grade 11 · Seton Hall Prep | 11 | Seton Hall Prep | 20:28.50 |
| 73 | Emmitt EnricoPlace 73 · Grade 10 · Morris Catholic | 10 | Morris Catholic | 20:31.48 PR |
| 74 | Eli SturtzPlace 74 · Grade 10 · Morris Catholic | 10 | Morris Catholic | 20:36.21 PR |
| 75 | Colton CherryPlace 75 · Grade 11 · Monsignor Donovan | 11 | Monsignor Donovan | 20:54.94 |
| 76 | Keith VanFleetPlace 76 · Lumen Gentium | — | Lumen Gentium | 20:58.66 |
| 77 | Salvatore RenoPlace 77 · Grade 10 · St Thomas Aquinas (Bishop Ahr 1983-2019) | 10 | St Thomas Aquinas (Bishop Ahr 1983-2019) | 21:02.56 |
| 78 | Evan ToroPlace 78 · Grade 10 · Paramus Catholic | 10 | Paramus Catholic | 21:05.18 |
| 79 | Henry MacDonaldPlace 79 · Lumen Gentium | — | Lumen Gentium | 21:09.28 |
| 80 | Derek WittenburgPlace 80 · Grade 12 · Notre Dame | 12 | Notre Dame | 21:42.55 |
| 81 | Luciano FormicaPlace 81 · Grade 12 · St John Vianney | 12 | St John Vianney | 21:46.73 |
| 82 | Rex SanclimentiPlace 82 · Lumen Gentium | — | Lumen Gentium | 22:21.40 |
| 83 | Raymond LiuPlace 83 · Grade 12 · St John Vianney | 12 | St John Vianney | 22:24.92 |
| 84 | Matteo FormicaPlace 84 · Grade 12 · St John Vianney | 12 | St John Vianney | 22:25.66 |
| 85 | John BlomquistPlace 85 · Grade 12 · St Rose | 12 | St Rose | 22:55.24 |
| 86 | Luke McArthurPlace 86 · Grade 12 · St Thomas Aquinas (Bishop Ahr 1983-2019) | 12 | St Thomas Aquinas (Bishop Ahr 1983-2019) | 23:19.44 |
| 87 | Ryan CohenPlace 87 · Grade 10 · Morris Catholic | 10 | Morris Catholic | 23:46.24 |
| 88 | Aidan TrowbridgePlace 88 · Lumen Gentium | — | Lumen Gentium | 23:59.80 |