| 1 | Paul WhiteleyPlace 1 · Grade - · Kansas State | - | Kansas State | 23:01.6 |
| 2 | Richard AndersonPlace 2 · Grade - · Winona State | - | Winona State | 23:10 PR |
| 3 | Leslie HegedusPlace 3 · Grade So · Central State | So | Central State | 23:40 |
| 4 | John MulhollandPlace 4 · Grade - · Loras | - | Loras | 23:46 |
| 5 | Warren HallPlace 5 · Grade Sr · Wabash | Sr | Wabash | 23:56 |
| 6 | Jerry RobinsonPlace 6 · Grade So · Wabash | So | Wabash | 24:00 |
| 7 | Warner WirtaPlace 7 · Grade - · Kansas State | - | Kansas State | 24:03 |
| 8 | Ron ReinhartPlace 8 · Grade Jr · Wabash | Jr | Wabash | 24:04 |
| 9 | Patrick MurphyPlace 9 · Grade - · South Dakota State | - | South Dakota State | 24:05 |
| 10 | Richard ShireyPlace 10 · Grade - · Slippery Rock | - | Slippery Rock | 24:10 |
| 11 | Dewey PistulkaPlace 11 · Grade - · South Dakota State | - | South Dakota State | 24:13 PR |
| 12 | Dennis MathesonPlace 12 · Grade - · Kansas State | - | Kansas State | 24:14 |
| 13 | Josh RugaPlace 13 · Grade - · Central State | - | Central State | 24:17 |
| 14 | William SweetPlace 14 · Grade - · Buffalo State | - | Buffalo State | 24:18 |
| 15 | James StoddardPlace 15 · Grade - · South Dakota State | - | South Dakota State | 24:20 |
| 16 | Ron BolePlace 16 · Grade - · Macalester | - | Macalester | 24:24 PR |
| 17 | Nathaniel FosterPlace 17 · Grade - · Central State | - | Central State | 24:26 |
| 18 | Marvin KochPlace 18 · Grade - · Minnesota State | - | Minnesota State | 24:27 |
| 19 | Frank SchweizerPlace 19 · Grade - · Minnesota State | - | Minnesota State | 24:31 |
| 20 | Theodore NelsonPlace 20 · Grade - · Minnesota State | - | Minnesota State | 24:36 |
| 21 | James MittlestadtPlace 21 · Grade - · Minnesota State | - | Minnesota State | 24:37 |
| 22 | David DonaldsonPlace 22 · Grade - · South Dakota State | - | South Dakota State | 24:38 |
| 23 | Bill CarsonPlace 23 · Grade - · Wheaton (Ill.) | - | Wheaton (Ill.) | 24:39 |
| 24 | Homer LatimerPlace 24 · Grade - · Cornell | - | Cornell | 24:40 PR |
| 25 | Ken GaultPlace 25 · Grade - · Union (Tenn.) | - | Union (Tenn.) | 24:44 |
| 26 | Guido WernickePlace 26 · Grade - · Case Western Reserve | - | Case Western Reserve | 24:50 PR |
| 27 | James McCormickPlace 27 · Grade - · South Dakota State | - | South Dakota State | 24:51 |
| 28 | James BurnettPlace 28 · Grade - · Central State | - | Central State | 24:52 |
| 29 | James HughesPlace 29 · Grade Sr · Buffalo State | Sr | Buffalo State | 24:55 |
| 30 | David OhldePlace 30 · Grade - · Kansas State | - | Kansas State | 24:56 PR |
| 31 | Richard StrakowskiPlace 31 · Grade - · DePauw | - | DePauw | 24:57 |
| 32 | Dwight StruckmanPlace 32 · Grade - · South Dakota State | - | South Dakota State | 25:05 |
| 33 | Patrick MooneyPlace 33 · Grade - · Slippery Rock | - | Slippery Rock | 25:07 |
| 34 | Robert LewisPlace 34 · Grade - · Truman | - | Truman | 25:08 |
| 35 | Troy RaseyPlace 35 · Grade - · Slippery Rock | - | Slippery Rock | 25:09 |
| 36 | Preston GrantPlace 36 · Grade - · Chicago | - | Chicago | 25:10 |
| 37 | Bill EvansPlace 37 · Grade - · Wheaton (Ill.) | - | Wheaton (Ill.) | 25:15 |
| 38 | John (Jack) McLaughlinPlace 38 · Grade So · Buffalo State | So | Buffalo State | 25:16 |
| 39 | Ed ThompsonPlace 39 · Grade - · DePauw | - | DePauw | 25:17 |
| 40 | Bill HopkinsPlace 40 · Grade - · Union (Tenn.) | - | Union (Tenn.) | 25:18 |
| 41 | Grant Van HornePlace 41 · Grade - · Wabash | - | Wabash | 25:19 |
| 42 | Richard MittlestadtPlace 42 · Grade - · Minnesota State | - | Minnesota State | 25:22 |
| 43 | Dave WeePlace 43 · Grade - · St. Olaf | - | St. Olaf | 25:30 |
| 44 | Dale MeddockPlace 44 · Grade - · Slippery Rock | - | Slippery Rock | 25:31 |
| 45 | Albert (Al) HuffPlace 45 · Grade Sr · Wabash | Sr | Wabash | 25:32 |
| 46 | Larry KrohnPlace 46 · Grade - · Minnesota State | - | Minnesota State | 25:33 |
| 47 | Anthony BarulichPlace 47 · Grade - · Truman | - | Truman | 25:34 |
| 48 | Gonzalo JavierPlace 48 · Grade - · Kansas State | - | Kansas State | 25:35 |
| 49 | David EleesonPlace 49 · Grade - · South Dakota State | - | South Dakota State | 25:37 |
| 50 | James McFaddenPlace 50 · Grade - · Truman | - | Truman | 25:38 |
| 51 | David EmansPlace 51 · Grade - · DePauw | - | DePauw | 25:39 |
| 52 | Theoda SmithPlace 52 · Grade - · Central State | - | Central State | 25:40 |
| 53 | Louis SuttonPlace 53 · Grade - · Slippery Rock | - | Slippery Rock | 25:41 |
| 54 | Lynn ReedPlace 54 · Grade - · Kansas State | - | Kansas State | 25:42 PR |
| 55 | Steve DialPlace 55 · Grade - · Ball State | - | Ball State | 25:43 |
| 56 | Steve SkjoldPlace 56 · Grade - · Macalester | - | Macalester | 25:44 PR |
| 57 | Dave JohnsonPlace 57 · Grade - · Ball State | - | Ball State | 25:54 |
| 58 | Angelo GioiosaPlace 58 · Grade - · Slippery Rock | - | Slippery Rock | 26:00 |
| 59 | William SimpsonPlace 59 · Grade - · Central State | - | Central State | 26:03 PR |
| 60 | Paul BurkhartPlace 60 · Grade - · Wheaton (Ill.) | - | Wheaton (Ill.) | 26:06 |
| 61 | Marc EricksonPlace 61 · Grade - · Wheaton (Ill.) | - | Wheaton (Ill.) | 26:08 |
| 62 | Walter StewartPlace 62 · Grade - · DePauw | - | DePauw | 26:09 |
| 63 | Thomas BlakePlace 63 · Grade - · DePauw | - | DePauw | 26:10 |
| 64 | Ed GatkePlace 64 · Grade - · Wheaton (Ill.) | - | Wheaton (Ill.) | 26:14 |
| 65 | Paul MunsellPlace 65 · Grade - · Wheaton (Ill.) | - | Wheaton (Ill.) | 26:15 |
| 66 | Wayne CobbPlace 66 · Grade - · Wabash | - | Wabash | 26:19 |
| 67 | George WithbroePlace 67 · Grade - · MIT | - | MIT | 26:23 PR |
| 68 | Thomas HoffmanPlace 68 · Grade - · Union (N.Y.) | - | Union (N.Y.) | 26:25 PR |
| 69 | David RouthPlace 69 · Grade - · Ball State | - | Ball State | 26:27 PR |
| 70 | George ShireyPlace 70 · Grade - · Slippery Rock | - | Slippery Rock | 26:30 PR |
| 71 | Walt LippardPlace 71 · Grade - · Wabash | - | Wabash | 26:37 |
| 72 | William NessPlace 72 · Grade - · Minnesota State | - | Minnesota State | 26:44 |
| 73 | Robert FoxPlace 73 · Grade - · DePauw | - | DePauw | 26:53 |
| 74 | Dave MalloyPlace 74 · Grade - · Union (Tenn.) | - | Union (Tenn.) | 26:54 PR |
| 75 | Emery EllisPlace 75 · Grade - · Central State | - | Central State | 26:55 |
| 76 | Robert MullenPlace 76 · Grade - · MIT | - | MIT | 27:01 PR |
| 77 | Pete KrollPlace 77 · Grade - · DePauw | - | DePauw | 27:02 |
| 78 | John TeplePlace 78 · Grade - · Ball State | - | Ball State | 27:05 PR |
| 79 | Dwight WhipplePlace 79 · Grade - · Wheaton (Ill.) | - | Wheaton (Ill.) | 27:06 PR |
| 80 | Daniel OliverPlace 80 · Grade - · MIT | - | MIT | 27:25 PR |
| 81 | Herbert WegenerPlace 81 · Grade - · MIT | - | MIT | 27:38 PR |
| 82 | Paul PrescottPlace 82 · Grade - · Ball State | - | Ball State | 27:40 |
| 83 | Max ReePlace 83 · Grade - · Ball State | - | Ball State | 27:53 PR |
| 84 | Edward McCartneyPlace 84 · Grade - · MIT | - | MIT | 28:05 PR |
| 85 | Bob AgeePlace 85 · Grade - · Union (Tenn.) | - | Union (Tenn.) | 28:53 PR |
| 86 | Roger WeissingerPlace 86 · Grade - · MIT | - | MIT | 29:02 PR |
| 87 | Albert PittmanPlace 87 · Grade - · Union (Tenn.) | - | Union (Tenn.) | 29:12 PR |
| 88 | Herbert GrievesPlace 88 · Grade - · MIT | - | MIT | 29:21 PR |
| 89 | Ronald GoldsteinPlace 89 · Grade - · Ball State | - | Ball State | 29:36 PR |
| 90 | Gayle AlexanderPlace 90 · Grade - · Union (Tenn.) | - | Union (Tenn.) | 31:00 PR |
