| 1 | Bryan LessPlace 1 · Grade Sr · Mount Union | Sr | Mount Union | 25:39 |
| 2 | Ryan PricePlace 2 · Grade Jr · Mount Union | Jr | Mount Union | 25:52 |
| 3 | JOE EBYPlace 3 · Grade Jr · Mount Union | Jr | Mount Union | 25:58 |
| 4 | Ryan HochstetlerPlace 4 · Grade Jr · Mount Union | Jr | Mount Union | 26:10 |
| 5 | Chris PaulettPlace 5 · Grade Fr · Mount Union | Fr | Mount Union | 26:18 |
| 6 | Matt SuttlePlace 6 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 26:26 |
| 7 | Nate CrowleyPlace 7 · Grade So · Mount Union | So | Mount Union | 26:33 |
| 8 | Joel DagenhardtPlace 8 · Grade So · Walsh | So | Walsh | 26:38 |
| 9 | John SoehnlenPlace 9 · Grade Sr · Walsh | Sr | Walsh | 26:40 PR |
| 10 | Sean GallagherPlace 10 · Grade Jr · Westminster (Pa.) | Jr | Westminster (Pa.) | 27:18 |
| 11 | Jason SigmundPlace 11 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 27:31 |
| 12 | Steve MacklePlace 12 · Grade Fr · Walsh | Fr | Walsh | 27:34 |
| 13 | Mike FullerPlace 13 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 27:34 |
| 14 | Dan WoodsPlace 14 · Grade So · Mount Union | So | Mount Union | 27:35 |
| 15 | John LibertPlace 15 · Grade Jr · Westminster (Pa.) | Jr | Westminster (Pa.) | 27:45 PR |
| 16 | Dan BeckwithPlace 16 · Westminster (Pa.) | — | Westminster (Pa.) | 27:47 PR |
| 17 | Bill CrimPlace 17 · Grade Fr · Walsh | Fr | Walsh | 27:47 PR |
| 18 | Ryan CollinsPlace 18 · Grade So · Walsh | So | Walsh | 27:49 PR |
| 19 | Bryan MackrellPlace 19 · Westminster (Pa.) | — | Westminster (Pa.) | 28:02 |
| 20 | Nick AukermanPlace 20 · Grade So · Walsh | So | Walsh | 28:03 |
| 21 | Michael GregoryPlace 21 · Grade Fr · Case Western Reserve | Fr | Case Western Reserve | 28:05 |
| 22 | James RodemsPlace 22 · Grade Fr · Allegheny (Pa.) | Fr | Allegheny (Pa.) | 28:06 PR |
| 23 | Ryan LaddPlace 23 · Grade Fr · Mount Union | Fr | Mount Union | 28:07 |
| 24 | Brad ZerbePlace 24 · Grade So · Westminster (Pa.) | So | Westminster (Pa.) | 28:07 PR |
| 25 | Mike CleverPlace 25 · Grade So · Westminster (Pa.) | So | Westminster (Pa.) | 28:08 PR |
| 26 | Marcus CorvinoPlace 26 · Grade So · Westminster (Pa.) | So | Westminster (Pa.) | 28:14 PR |
| 27 | deForest CarterPlace 27 · Grade - · Allegheny (Pa.) | - | Allegheny (Pa.) | 28:16 PR |
| 28 | Matt OberlyPlace 28 · Grade Fr · Mount Union | Fr | Mount Union | 28:17 |
| 29 | Carl SmithPlace 29 · Allegheny (Pa.) | — | Allegheny (Pa.) | 28:27 PR |
| 30 | Joey BeallPlace 30 · Grade Sr · Mount Union | Sr | Mount Union | 28:28 |
| 31 | Tim DeWittPlace 31 · Grade Fr · Walsh | Fr | Walsh | 28:34 PR |
| 32 | Tim SnyderPlace 32 · Grade Jr · Westminster (Pa.) | Jr | Westminster (Pa.) | 28:43 |
| 33 | Ben ParkerPlace 33 · Grade Jr · Mount Union | Jr | Mount Union | 28:46 |
| 34 | Josh DrabPlace 34 · Grade So · Westminster (Pa.) | So | Westminster (Pa.) | 28:48 PR |
| 35 | Matt SaracinaPlace 35 · Grade Fr · Walsh | Fr | Walsh | 28:49 PR |
| 36 | Corey DrabertPlace 36 · Grade Jr · Allegheny (Pa.) | Jr | Allegheny (Pa.) | 28:52 |
| 37 | Jeff HathornPlace 37 · Grade Fr · Allegheny (Pa.) | Fr | Allegheny (Pa.) | 28:57 PR |
| 38 | Koji MasudaPlace 38 · Grade So · Mount Union | So | Mount Union | 29:01 |
| 39 | Sean FlynnPlace 39 · Grade - · Allegheny (Pa.) | - | Allegheny (Pa.) | 29:08 PR |
| 40 | Brendan McIntyrePlace 40 · Grade Fr · Allegheny (Pa.) | Fr | Allegheny (Pa.) | 29:15 PR |
| 41 | Mike VuceticPlace 41 · Grade Fr · Case Western Reserve | Fr | Case Western Reserve | 29:20 PR |
| 42 | David DobbinsPlace 42 · Westminster (Pa.) | — | Westminster (Pa.) | 29:24 |
| 43 | Andy MonnotPlace 43 · Grade - · Allegheny (Pa.) | - | Allegheny (Pa.) | 29:26 PR |
| 44 | Mark DelaneyPlace 44 · Grade - · Allegheny (Pa.) | - | Allegheny (Pa.) | 29:34 PR |
| 45 | Matt NiederstPlace 45 · Grade Jr · Allegheny (Pa.) | Jr | Allegheny (Pa.) | 29:50 |
| 46 | Brent BauknechtPlace 46 · Grade Fr · Mount Union | Fr | Mount Union | 29:52 |
| 47 | Chris BarnabiPlace 47 · Grade So · Westminster (Pa.) | So | Westminster (Pa.) | 30:02 PR |
| 48 | Tom PizonPlace 48 · Westminster (Pa.) | — | Westminster (Pa.) | 30:08 |
| 49 | John BurkeyPlace 49 · Grade Fr · Mount Union | Fr | Mount Union | 30:11 |
| 50 | Ryan JordanhazyPlace 50 · Grade Fr · Allegheny (Pa.) | Fr | Allegheny (Pa.) | 30:31 |
| 51 | Dave PalowskiPlace 51 · Grade So · Case Western Reserve | So | Case Western Reserve | 30:35 PR |
| 52 | Rob StrongPlace 52 · Grade Jr · Walsh | Jr | Walsh | 30:38 |
| 53 | Kevin DobbinsPlace 53 · Westminster (Pa.) | — | Westminster (Pa.) | 31:23 |
| 54 | Mike WilliamsPlace 54 · Grade Fr · Walsh | Fr | Walsh | 31:36 PR |
| 55 | Joe VitulloPlace 55 · Westminster (Pa.) | — | Westminster (Pa.) | 31:55 |
| 56 | Jordan HindsPlace 56 · Grade Fr · Westminster (Pa.) | Fr | Westminster (Pa.) | 32:23 PR |
| 57 | Anton MartzPlace 57 · Grade - · Allegheny (Pa.) | - | Allegheny (Pa.) | 33:33 |
| 58 | Ron BrownPlace 58 · Westminster (Pa.) | — | Westminster (Pa.) | 33:48 |
| 59 | Chris MiwaPlace 59 · Grade - · Allegheny (Pa.) | - | Allegheny (Pa.) | 33:55 PR |
