| 1 | Ada KoesselPlace 1 · Grade 12 · Spence | 12 | Spence | 19:33.19 PR |
| 2 | Naomi EisenPlace 2 · Grade 12 · Spence | 12 | Spence | 19:54.07 PR |
| 3 | Caitlin MorrowPlace 3 · Grade 12 · Hackley | 12 | Hackley | 20:39.50 PR |
| 4 | Hannah SandbultePlace 4 · Grade 10 · Spence | 10 | Spence | 20:43.53 PR |
| 5 | Emma CurranPlace 5 · Grade 12 · Hackley | 12 | Hackley | 20:47.87 PR |
| 6 | Daphne RomaryPlace 6 · Grade 9 · Spence | 9 | Spence | 20:55.06 PR |
| 7 | Orly RobertsPlace 7 · Grade 12 · Spence | 12 | Spence | 21:03.48 PR |
| 8 | Natalia PiszczatowskiPlace 8 · Grade 12 · Townsend Harris | 12 | Townsend Harris | 21:13.13 PR |
| 9 | Emily LiPlace 9 · Grade 10 · Horace Mann | 10 | Horace Mann | 21:18.76 PR |
| 10 | Kailynn KruckPlace 10 · Grade 11 · Monsignor McClancy | 11 | Monsignor McClancy | 21:25.11 PR |
| 11 | Lyla LamPlace 11 · Grade 10 · Spence | 10 | Spence | 21:26.14 PR |
| 12 | Vivienne HummPlace 12 · Grade 11 · Riverdale Country | 11 | Riverdale Country | 22:00.18 PR |
| 13 | Eliza RitchiePlace 13 · Grade 10 · Riverdale Country | 10 | Riverdale Country | 22:17.50 PR |
| 14 | Beatrice KoffeyPlace 14 · Grade 10 · Spence | 10 | Spence | 22:34.11 PR |
| 15 | Sophia ChenPlace 15 · Grade 12 · Townsend Harris | 12 | Townsend Harris | 22:36.43 PR |
| 16 | Cordelia HartingPlace 16 · Grade 12 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 12 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 22:47.29 PR |
| 17 | Maine SigelPlace 17 · Grade 11 · Horace Mann | 11 | Horace Mann | 22:51.20 PR |
| 18 | Ashley PrattPlace 18 · Grade 11 · Ursuline School (NY) | 11 | Ursuline School (NY) | 22:58.82 PR |
| 19 | Manyata ChhetriPlace 19 · Grade 12 · Townsend Harris | 12 | Townsend Harris | 23:05.15 PR |
| 20 | Alice LyuPlace 20 · Grade 11 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 11 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 23:08.48 |
| 21 | Gabrielle AmorosinoPlace 21 · Grade 12 · Poly Prep Country Day | 12 | Poly Prep Country Day | 23:11.24 PR |
| 22 | Sophia DabbraccioPlace 22 · Grade 12 · The Stony Brook | 12 | The Stony Brook | 23:15.46 PR |
| 23 | Fiona Loy ChanPlace 23 · Grade 12 · Townsend Harris | 12 | Townsend Harris | 23:22.82 PR |
| 24 | Mary AllenPlace 24 · Grade 12 · Ursuline School (NY) | 12 | Ursuline School (NY) | 23:26.50 PR |
| 25 | Leighton DevittPlace 25 · Grade 11 · Ursuline School (NY) | 11 | Ursuline School (NY) | 23:34.05 PR |
| 26 | Sarina JaveriPlace 26 · Grade 11 · Riverdale Country | 11 | Riverdale Country | 23:37.89 PR |
| 27 | Rachel SommersPlace 27 · Grade 9 · Spence | 9 | Spence | 23:44.59 PR |
| 28 | Aoife SmithPlace 28 · Grade 9 · Ursuline School (NY) | 9 | Ursuline School (NY) | 23:49.75 PR |
| 29 | Elyse BogatyPlace 29 · Grade 11 · Poly Prep Country Day | 11 | Poly Prep Country Day | 23:50.95 PR |
| 30 | Deanna MalekiPlace 30 · Grade 12 · Townsend Harris | 12 | Townsend Harris | 23:54.09 PR |
| 31 | Julia GolecPlace 31 · Grade 12 · Monsignor McClancy | 12 | Monsignor McClancy | 23:57.65 PR |
| 32 | Elizabeth SpencerPlace 32 · Grade 11 · Hackley | 11 | Hackley | 23:57.72 PR |
| 33 | Caroline RyuPlace 33 · Grade 11 · Hackley | 11 | Hackley | 23:59.95 PR |
| 34 | Allie ValetPlace 34 · Grade 8 · The Stony Brook | 8 | The Stony Brook | 24:11.62 PR |
| 35 | Abigail CochranPlace 35 · Grade 10 · Ethical Culture Fieldston | 10 | Ethical Culture Fieldston | 24:15.75 PR |
| 36 | Zoe GregoriusPlace 36 · Grade 9 · Spence | 9 | Spence | 24:18.56 |
| 37 | Kayla MenonPlace 37 · Grade 12 · Hackley | 12 | Hackley | 24:20.97 PR |
| 38 | Emma KanekoPlace 38 · Grade 10 · Horace Mann | 10 | Horace Mann | 24:35.90 PR |
| 39 | Zoe RuffiniPlace 39 · Grade 11 · West End | 11 | West End | 24:53.15 PR |
| 40 | Caitlin SetnessPlace 40 · Grade 10 · Ursuline School (NY) | 10 | Ursuline School (NY) | 25:09.49 PR |
| 41 | Layan SowPlace 41 · Grade 12 · Hackley | 12 | Hackley | 25:13.73 PR |
| 42 | Kavya MahindruPlace 42 · Grade 12 · Ursuline School (NY) | 12 | Ursuline School (NY) | 25:26.25 PR |
| 43 | Olivia LeePlace 43 · Grade 9 · Townsend Harris | 9 | Townsend Harris | 25:45.26 PR |
| 44 | India BaxterPlace 44 · Grade 10 · Horace Mann | 10 | Horace Mann | 25:48.77 PR |
| 45 | Selene LiPlace 45 · Grade 9 · Horace Mann | 9 | Horace Mann | 25:53.93 PR |
| 46 | Avery KellyPlace 46 · Grade 11 · Poly Prep Country Day | 11 | Poly Prep Country Day | 26:11.16 PR |
| 47 | Ella CharenPlace 47 · Grade 12 · Riverdale Country | 12 | Riverdale Country | 26:16.18 PR |
| 48 | Maeve AlonsoPlace 48 · Grade 9 · Horace Mann | 9 | Horace Mann | 26:44.72 PR |
| 49 | Ella ChenPlace 49 · Grade 10 · Townsend Harris | 10 | Townsend Harris | 26:46.72 PR |
| 50 | Isabel Magliulo-orsiniPlace 50 · Grade 12 · Monsignor McClancy | 12 | Monsignor McClancy | 26:54.52 PR |
| 51 | Maya KantrowitzPlace 51 · Grade 10 · West End | 10 | West End | 26:58.52 PR |
| 52 | Sena ShewPlace 52 · Grade 11 · Townsend Harris | 11 | Townsend Harris | 27:00.29 PR |
| 53 | Alice CampbellPlace 53 · Grade 10 · Horace Mann | 10 | Horace Mann | 27:05.98 PR |
| 54 | Clara LINPlace 54 · Grade 11 · West End | 11 | West End | 27:40.63 PR |
| 55 | Maddie DragoPlace 55 · Grade 9 · The Stony Brook | 9 | The Stony Brook | 27:56.26 PR |
| 56 | Scarlett O'SheaPlace 56 · Grade 9 · Ursuline School (NY) | 9 | Ursuline School (NY) | 28:08.96 PR |
| 57 | Eloise EdisPlace 57 · Grade 12 · Horace Mann | 12 | Horace Mann | 28:59.92 PR |
| 58 | Audrey BeachPlace 58 · Grade 9 · Ursuline School (NY) | 9 | Ursuline School (NY) | 29:02.10 PR |
| 59 | Molly SpeakerPlace 59 · Grade 10 · Poly Prep Country Day | 10 | Poly Prep Country Day | 29:24.18 PR |
| 60 | Ashling O'GradyPlace 60 · Grade 12 · Monsignor McClancy | 12 | Monsignor McClancy | 29:25.61 PR |
| 61 | Ivy MoPlace 61 · Grade 11 · Horace Mann | 11 | Horace Mann | 29:58.21 PR |
| 62 | Elba RodriguezPlace 62 · Grade 12 · Monsignor McClancy | 12 | Monsignor McClancy | 31:25.43 PR |
| 63 | Rowan O'GradyPlace 63 · Grade 12 · Monsignor McClancy | 12 | Monsignor McClancy | 34:04.59 PR |
| 64 | Chloe RocPlace 64 · Grade 11 · The Stony Brook | 11 | The Stony Brook | 34:07.71 PR |
| 65 | Baili LawrencePlace 65 · Grade 9 · The Stony Brook | 9 | The Stony Brook | 34:10.71 PR |
| 66 | Sadie BrancalePlace 66 · Grade 10 · The Stony Brook | 10 | The Stony Brook | 34:54.33 PR |
| — | Emma BonettoGrade 11 · Poly Prep Country Day | 11 | Poly Prep Country Day | DNF PR |