| 1 | Sena ArakawaPlace 1 · Grade 8 · Harrison | 8 | Harrison | 4:06.45 PR |
| 2 | Scarlett Kramer-BuehlerPlace 2 · Grade 8 · Harrison | 8 | Harrison | 4:14.88 PR |
| 3 | Isabella valPlace 3 · Grade 8 · Ardsley | 8 | Ardsley | 4:15.33 PR |
| 4 | Emma CampbellPlace 4 · Grade 8 · Van Wyck | 8 | Van Wyck | 4:17.02 PR |
| 5 | Elizabeth HurleyPlace 5 · Grade 8 · Clarkstown | 8 | Clarkstown | 4:21.52 PR |
| 6 | Riley QuaidPlace 6 · Grade 8 · Hendrick Hudson | 8 | Hendrick Hudson | 4:22.43 PR |
| 7 | Alexia CorvinoPlace 7 · Grade 8 · Harrison | 8 | Harrison | 4:25.22 PR |
| 8 | Olivia YounPlace 8 · Grade 8 · New Rochelle | 8 | New Rochelle | 4:26.58 PR |
| 9 | Riley FlechaPlace 9 · Grade 8 · Carmel | 8 | Carmel | 4:31.46 PR |
| 10 | Claire KischakPlace 10 · Grade 8 · Carmel | 8 | Carmel | 4:32.28 PR |
| 11 | Briana Oliveros ValerioPlace 11 · Grade 8 · New Rochelle | 8 | New Rochelle | 4:32.35 PR |
| 12 | Evie FollettPlace 12 · Grade 8 · Carmel | 8 | Carmel | 4:32.46 PR |
| 13 | Gabriella KoisPlace 13 · Grade 8 · Carmel | 8 | Carmel | 4:33.75 PR |
| 14 | Luna PalaciosPlace 14 · Grade 8 · Nyack | 8 | Nyack | 4:35.91 PR |
| 15 | Rosina Rehman PerowskyPlace 15 · Grade 8 · Nyack | 8 | Nyack | 4:37.22 PR |
| 16 | Alexa VenaPlace 16 · Grade 8 · Van Wyck | 8 | Van Wyck | 4:38.14 PR |
| 17 | Margaret HoffmanPlace 17 · Grade 8 · New Rochelle | 8 | New Rochelle | 4:38.16 PR |
| 18 | Abigail TovmasianPlace 18 · Grade 8 · Clarkstown | 8 | Clarkstown | 4:38.57 PR |
| 19 | Sofia RamosPlace 19 · Grade 8 · Carmel | 8 | Carmel | 4:39.28 PR |
| 20 | Clara FergusonPlace 20 · Grade 8 · Pelham | 8 | Pelham | 4:40.43 PR |
| 21 | Olivia ConwayPlace 21 · Grade 8 · Ardsley | 8 | Ardsley | 4:42.75 PR |
| 22 | Nyalise PettifordPlace 22 · Grade 8 · Carmel | 8 | Carmel | 4:45.78 PR |
| 23 | Indigo KingPlace 23 · Grade 8 · Pelham | 8 | Pelham | 4:47.91 PR |
| 24 | Charlotte AmatoPlace 24 · Grade 8 · Ardsley | 8 | Ardsley | 4:49.55 PR |
| 25 | Racheal MuirheadPlace 25 · Grade 8 · Ardsley | 8 | Ardsley | 4:50.72 PR |
| 26 | Malaya MontanoPlace 26 · Grade 8 · Nyack | 8 | Nyack | 4:56.82 PR |
| 27 | Alexis ManciniPlace 27 · Grade 8 · Van Wyck | 8 | Van Wyck | 4:57.68 PR |
| 28 | Olivia RialPlace 28 · Grade 8 · Hendrick Hudson | 8 | Hendrick Hudson | 4:58.15 PR |
| 29 | Nora DevilbissPlace 29 · Grade 8 · Nyack | 8 | Nyack | 4:58.39 PR |
| 30 | Palmina CaroniaPlace 30 · Grade 8 · Pelham | 8 | Pelham | 5:04.71 PR |
| 31 | Molly CampbellPlace 31 · Grade 8 · Clarkstown | 8 | Clarkstown | 5:05.02 PR |
| 32 | Dalia BatesPlace 32 · Grade 8 · Nyack | 8 | Nyack | 5:07.50 PR |
| 33 | Khloe YangPlace 33 · Grade 8 · Pelham | 8 | Pelham | 5:09.61 PR |
| 34 | McKenzie AndersonPlace 34 · Grade 8 · Hendrick Hudson | 8 | Hendrick Hudson | 5:12.19 PR |
| 35 | Aoibhe LennonPlace 35 · Grade 8 · Ardsley | 8 | Ardsley | 5:14.72 PR |
| 36 | Olivia PetriPlace 36 · Grade 8 · Ardsley | 8 | Ardsley | 5:15.33 PR |
| 37 | Sophie LennaPlace 37 · Grade 8 · Harrison | 8 | Harrison | 5:17.44 PR |
| 38 | Olivia LaytonPlace 38 · Grade 8 · Clarkstown | 8 | Clarkstown | 5:25.08 PR |
| 39 | Nia PazPlace 39 · Grade 8 · Harrison | 8 | Harrison | 5:27.40 PR |
| 40 | Taylor WangPlace 40 · Grade 8 · Hendrick Hudson | 8 | Hendrick Hudson | 5:37.36 PR |
| 41 | Charlie OeserPlace 41 · Grade 8 · New Rochelle | 8 | New Rochelle | 5:38.98 PR |
| 42 | Martina SchusterPlace 42 · Grade 8 · Nyack | 8 | Nyack | 5:42.14 PR |
| 43 | Samantha UmrichinPlace 43 · Grade 8 · Clarkstown | 8 | Clarkstown | 5:43.04 PR |
| 44 | Samantha KraytmanPlace 44 · Grade 8 · Ardsley | 8 | Ardsley | 5:45.75 PR |
| — | Giuliana SantangeloGrade 7 · Carmel | 7 | Carmel | DNF PR |
| — | Violet Di LorenzoGrade 7 · Harrison | 7 | Harrison | DNF PR |