| 1 | Chloe DufaillyPlace 1 · Grade 10 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 10 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 16:53.70 |
| 2 | Maya PerazzoPlace 2 · Grade 10 · Dominican Academy | 10 | Dominican Academy | 17:38.20 PR |
| 3 | Amelia TrejgisPlace 3 · Grade 10 · Monsignor McClancy | 10 | Monsignor McClancy | 17:51.40 PR |
| 4 | Juliana CollacoPlace 4 · Grade 10 · Monsignor McClancy | 10 | Monsignor McClancy | 18:27.20 PR |
| 5 | Gabriella JamesPlace 5 · Grade 10 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 10 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 18:47.90 |
| 6 | Ava FescinaPlace 6 · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 18:54.10 |
| 7 | Sophie RosemondPlace 7 · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 18:54.30 |
| 8 | Ava GuerreroPlace 8 · Grade 10 · Monsignor McClancy | 10 | Monsignor McClancy | 18:56.00 PR |
| 9 | Leanne LoPlace 9 · Grade 10 · St Francis Prep | 10 | St Francis Prep | 19:12.80 PR |
| 10 | Mika HalseyPlace 10 · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 19:29.20 PR |
| 11 | Elizabeth MunozPlace 11 · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 19:37.90 PR |
| 12 | Lucia LeoniPlace 12 · Grade 10 · Saint Vincent Ferrer | 10 | Saint Vincent Ferrer | 19:38.80 |
| 13 | Kyla WestonPlace 13 · Grade 10 · Cardinal Spellman | 10 | Cardinal Spellman | 19:40.90 PR |
| 14 | Alexandra WalshPlace 14 · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 19:45.00 PR |
| 15 | Lena OlkPlace 15 · Grade 10 · Monsignor McClancy | 10 | Monsignor McClancy | 19:57.70 PR |
| 16 | Lilly CarusoPlace 16 · Grade 10 · St Francis Prep | 10 | St Francis Prep | 20:12.50 PR |
| 17 | Amelia TyszukPlace 17 · Grade 10 · Monsignor McClancy | 10 | Monsignor McClancy | 20:30.30 PR |
| 18 | Caroline RuessPlace 18 · Grade 10 · Xaverian | 10 | Xaverian | 20:41.80 PR |
| 19 | Ava ColuccioPlace 19 · Grade 10 · Xaverian | 10 | Xaverian | 20:48.00 PR |
| 20 | Christina ChrisanthopoulosPlace 20 · Grade 10 · St Francis Prep | 10 | St Francis Prep | 20:55.70 PR |
| 21 | Somiyah QuinonesPlace 21 · Grade 10 · Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 10 | Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 21:07.40 PR |
| 22 | Alexa ShaurovPlace 22 · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 21:09.60 PR |
| 23 | Gabriella GatlinPlace 23 · Grade 10 · St Johns Preparatory | 10 | St Johns Preparatory | 21:20.00 |
| 24 | Brianna MeeganPlace 24 · Grade 10 · Maria Regina | 10 | Maria Regina | 21:21.30 |
| 25 | Maya WierzbickiPlace 25 · Grade 10 · St Francis Prep | 10 | St Francis Prep | 21:36.30 PR |
| 26 | Eliana CasianoPlace 26 · Grade 10 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 10 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 21:40.70 PR |
| 27 | Siella ManzPlace 27 · Grade 10 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 10 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 21:52.30 |
| 28 | Violet ReyPlace 28 · Grade 10 · St Francis Prep | 10 | St Francis Prep | 22:02.20 PR |
| 29 | Alice DauphinPlace 29 · Grade 10 · St Francis Prep | 10 | St Francis Prep | 22:15.10 PR |
| 30 | Madison StantonPlace 30 · Grade 10 · Cardinal Spellman | 10 | Cardinal Spellman | 22:24.50 |
| 31 | Kristina CassPlace 31 · Grade 10 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 10 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 22:24.50 PR |
| 32 | Fiona AllenPlace 32 · Grade 10 · Dominican Academy | 10 | Dominican Academy | 22:34.80 |
| 33 | Shayla RoddyPlace 33 · Grade 10 · Maria Regina | 10 | Maria Regina | 22:35.50 PR |
| 34 | Charlotte LipsonPlace 34 · Grade 10 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 10 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 22:36.30 PR |
| 35 | Francesca BilelloPlace 35 · Grade 10 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 10 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 22:37.50 PR |
| 36 | Veronica PerriPlace 36 · Grade 10 · Cardinal Spellman | 10 | Cardinal Spellman | 23:15.50 PR |
| 37 | Amy CaceresPlace 37 · Grade 10 · Cardinal Spellman | 10 | Cardinal Spellman | 23:19.70 PR |
| 38 | Olivia MuccigrossoPlace 38 · Grade 10 · Xaverian | 10 | Xaverian | 23:34.50 |
| 39 | Keziah NoblePlace 39 · Grade 10 · Saint Vincent Ferrer | 10 | Saint Vincent Ferrer | 23:38.50 PR |
| 40 | Camila GuerreroPlace 40 · Grade 10 · Monsignor McClancy | 10 | Monsignor McClancy | 23:39.10 |
| 41 | Promise TerryPlace 41 · Grade 10 · Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 10 | Bishop Loughlin Memorial | 24:19.30 PR |
| 42 | Miamarie CruzPlace 42 · Grade 10 · Dominican Academy | 10 | Dominican Academy | 24:32.10 PR |
| 43 | Addison AmeneirosPlace 43 · Grade 10 · Xaverian | 10 | Xaverian | 24:44.40 |
| 44 | Madison MartinezPlace 44 · Grade 10 · Dominican Academy | 10 | Dominican Academy | 25:02.40 |
| 45 | Taylor BrownPlace 45 · Grade 10 · Cardinal Spellman | 10 | Cardinal Spellman | 25:39.40 |
| 46 | Sofia CarruzzoPlace 46 · Grade 10 · Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 10 | Notre Dame (Manhattan) | 25:54.90 PR |
| 47 | Jiani YangPlace 47 · Grade 10 · St Johns Preparatory | 10 | St Johns Preparatory | 26:12.00 PR |
| 48 | Madison FlowersPlace 48 · Grade 10 · Cardinal Spellman | 10 | Cardinal Spellman | 26:17.40 |
| 49 | Olivia FlynnPlace 49 · Grade 10 · Maria Regina | 10 | Maria Regina | 26:42.90 PR |
| 50 | Alyssa TupsaitongPlace 50 · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 26:45.30 PR |
| 51 | Ariel GuthriePlace 51 · Grade 10 · Cardinal Spellman | 10 | Cardinal Spellman | 26:48.10 PR |
| 52 | Bella ZambranoPlace 52 · Grade 10 · Archbishop Molloy | 10 | Archbishop Molloy | 26:53.90 PR |
| 53 | Cameron BrownPlace 53 · Grade 10 · Cardinal Spellman | 10 | Cardinal Spellman | 27:09.90 PR |