| 1 | Kyle BasistaPlace 1 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 25:19 |
| 2 | Chad RobertsPlace 2 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 25:20 |
| 3 | Keith SolversonPlace 3 | — | — | 25:25 |
| 4 | Grant RussoPlace 4 · Denison | — | Denison | 25:54 |
| 5 | Eric HamnerPlace 5 | — | — | 26:02 |
| 6 | Nate RitzPlace 6 | — | — | 26:02 |
| 7 | Jared FrenchPlace 7 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 26:04 |
| 8 | Dusty KimePlace 8 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 26:11 |
| 9 | Jeremy LeePlace 9 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 26:17 |
| 10 | Zack WeinbergPlace 10 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 26:19 |
| 11 | James CastrilloPlace 11 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 26:23 |
| 12 | Chase SchneiderPlace 12 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 26:24 |
| 13 | Gary BowmanPlace 13 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 26:25 |
| 14 | J.D. WaltersPlace 14 · Muskingum | — | Muskingum | 26:29 |
| 15 | Austin StilesPlace 15 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 26:29 |
| 16 | Ty GriffinPlace 16 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 26:30 |
| 17 | David StefanikPlace 17 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 26:32 |
| 18 | Brad OrrPlace 18 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 26:37 |
| 19 | Jason BumbPlace 19 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 26:39 |
| 20 | Joel BendtsenPlace 20 · Denison | — | Denison | 26:40 |
| 21 | Dustin FordPlace 21 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 26:41 |
| 22 | Clay DavisPlace 22 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 26:44 |
| 23 | Dan WhislerPlace 23 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 26:47 |
| 24 | Nathan EllisPlace 24 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 26:49 |
| 25 | Matt DeleonPlace 25 | — | — | 26:50 |
| 26 | Ryan GarroPlace 26 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 27:00 |
| 27 | Chris FyockPlace 27 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 27:02 |
| 28 | Mark PoroPlace 28 · Mount Vernon Nazarene | — | Mount Vernon Nazarene | 27:06 |
| 29 | Mike SawickiPlace 29 | — | — | 27:09 |
| 30 | Justin MeesonPlace 30 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 27:11 |
| 31 | Christian SchlabacPlace 31 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 27:13 |
| 32 | Matt RepkingPlace 32 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 27:13 |
| 33 | Steve ClarkPlace 33 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 27:14 |
| 34 | Gabe SavagePlace 34 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 27:15 |
| 35 | Stephen BoedickerPlace 35 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 27:20 |
| 36 | Chris FinnPlace 36 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 27:22 |
| 37 | Skyler MosenthalPlace 37 · Denison | — | Denison | 27:22 |
| 38 | Kindy TicePlace 38 · Denison | — | Denison | 27:25 |
| 39 | Gary BrennemanPlace 39 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 27:28 |
| 40 | Thomas BuxtonPlace 40 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 27:30 |
| 41 | Graham TurlingtonPlace 41 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 27:33 |
| 42 | Nick PucilloPlace 42 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 27:36 |
| 43 | Lex HultquistPlace 43 · Denison | — | Denison | 27:46 |
| 44 | Tyler KreipkePlace 44 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 27:46 |
| 45 | Alex HavranPlace 45 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 27:49 |
| 46 | Eric HawleyPlace 46 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 27:50 |
| 47 | Kendall GulbrandsePlace 47 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 27:52 |
| 48 | Craig BakerPlace 48 · Denison | — | Denison | 27:53 |
| 49 | Kevin C. CraigoPlace 49 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 27:55 |
| 50 | Justin DrubaPlace 50 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 27:55 |
| 51 | Adam NunnsPlace 51 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 27:55 |
| 52 | Kevin FrickPlace 52 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 27:56 |
| 53 | Erik ReedPlace 53 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 27:56 |
| 54 | Mitchell ThomasPlace 54 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 28:04 |
| 55 | Tyson SniderPlace 55 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 28:04 |
| 56 | Tony GustinPlace 56 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 28:04 |
| 57 | Ian ThomasPlace 57 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 28:07 |
| 58 | David CaldwellPlace 58 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 28:08 |
| 59 | Peter MacLeodPlace 59 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 28:10 |
| 60 | Travis IsenbergPlace 60 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 28:12 |
| 61 | Randy TerrellPlace 61 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 28:13 |
| 62 | Garret Andre-JohnsPlace 62 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 28:14 |
| 63 | Zak PhillipsPlace 63 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 28:14 |
| 64 | John ThatcherPlace 64 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 28:17 |
| 65 | Clark MoserPlace 65 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 28:20 |
| 66 | Joe EvansPlace 66 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 28:23 |
| 67 | Atlantis TroutmanPlace 67 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 28:24 |
| 68 | Mike JacobyPlace 68 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 28:25 |
| 69 | Ben McPheronPlace 69 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 28:25 |
| 70 | Jackson StultsPlace 70 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 28:27 |
| 71 | Matt DieterichPlace 71 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 28:28 |
| 72 | Robert RomeoPlace 72 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 28:31 |
| 73 | Kyle BeatyPlace 73 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 28:33 |
| 74 | Derek BischakPlace 74 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 28:34 |
| 75 | Chaz RicePlace 75 · Mount Vernon Nazarene | — | Mount Vernon Nazarene | 28:35 |
| 76 | Jacob SchoenleinPlace 76 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 28:38 |
| 77 | Ben LynchPlace 77 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 28:39 |
| 78 | Ben McCombsPlace 78 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 28:40 |
| 79 | Bryan McIntyrePlace 79 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 28:41 |
| 80 | Josh AnstinePlace 80 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 28:46 |
| 81 | Scott WolfePlace 81 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 28:50 |
| 82 | Andrew MeiersPlace 82 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 28:51 |
| 83 | Phil HiltnerPlace 83 · Denison | — | Denison | 28:52 |
| 84 | Eric GreenPlace 84 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 28:52 |
| 85 | Steve PaullinPlace 85 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 28:54 |
| 86 | Matt DixonPlace 86 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 28:55 |
| 87 | Jake SweeneyPlace 87 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 28:56 |
| 88 | Dylan McElfreshPlace 88 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 28:58 |
| 89 | Homer CobbPlace 89 · Charleston | — | Charleston | 29:03 |
| 90 | Nick EdmondsPlace 90 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 29:05 |
| 91 | Zach StiversonPlace 91 · Mount Vernon Nazarene | — | Mount Vernon Nazarene | 29:06 |
| 92 | Cody PontiusPlace 92 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 29:09 |
| 93 | Kyle BarrettPlace 93 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 29:09 |
| 94 | Tom BrumlikPlace 94 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 29:11 |
| 95 | Dominique O\'NealPlace 95 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 29:11 |
| 96 | Stephen WoodsPlace 96 · Capital | — | Capital | 29:12 |
| 97 | Eric ThatcherPlace 97 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 29:13 |
| 98 | Andrew PikePlace 98 · Oberlin | — | Oberlin | 29:14 |
| 99 | Alex SimkoPlace 99 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 29:15 |
| 100 | Seth ThomasPlace 100 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 29:15 |
| 101 | Kyle GriffithPlace 101 · Capital | — | Capital | 29:16 |
| 102 | Andrew StoreyPlace 102 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 29:17 |
| 103 | Ian HankinsPlace 103 · Muskingum | — | Muskingum | 29:17 |
| 104 | Andrew BloomPlace 104 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 29:18 |
| 105 | Rob M. MoneyPlace 105 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 29:21 |
| 106 | Kyle HermanPlace 106 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 29:22 |
| 107 | Matt KleinknechtPlace 107 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 29:22 |
| 108 | Kyle KrigbaumPlace 108 · Charleston | — | Charleston | 29:23 |
| 109 | Jon AndersonPlace 109 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 29:24 |
| 110 | Matt PerkettPlace 110 · Denison | — | Denison | 29:27 |
| 111 | Kiron RoyPlace 111 · Oberlin | — | Oberlin | 29:27 |
| 112 | Emerson RhoadPlace 112 · Capital | — | Capital | 29:29 |
| 113 | Patrick RachowPlace 113 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 29:29 |
| 114 | Sean L. LemkePlace 114 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 29:30 |
| 115 | Harrison MarkelPlace 115 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 29:30 |
| 116 | Lukas KromerPlace 116 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 29:31 |
| 117 | Tom AluisePlace 117 · Muskingum | — | Muskingum | 29:32 |
| 118 | Vinny FreedmanPlace 118 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 29:34 |
| 119 | Cody MorrisonPlace 119 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 29:34 |
| 120 | Eric ClarkPlace 120 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 29:35 |
| 121 | David EddyPlace 121 | — | — | 29:36 |
| 122 | Don FlemingPlace 122 · Oberlin | — | Oberlin | 29:36 |
| 123 | Mike MenagePlace 123 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 29:38 |
| 124 | Scott WilliamsPlace 124 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 29:38 |
| 125 | Kyle BabcockPlace 125 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 29:40 |
| 126 | Greg LyonPlace 126 · Denison | — | Denison | 29:41 |
| 127 | Jeff DriscollPlace 127 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 29:44 |
| 128 | Jay WellikPlace 128 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 29:45 |
| 129 | Rick CarlsonPlace 129 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 29:46 |
| 130 | Kyle WinterrrowdPlace 130 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 29:50 |
| 131 | Evan StairPlace 131 · Charleston | — | Charleston | 29:50 |
| 132 | Taylor CantrilPlace 132 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 29:59 |
| 133 | Dustin HardbargerPlace 133 · Glenville State | — | Glenville State | 30:03 |
| 134 | Jeremy SouderPlace 134 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 30:05 |
| 135 | Michael ShirarPlace 135 · Denison | — | Denison | 30:11 |
| 136 | Brent R. RubyPlace 136 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 30:13 |
| 137 | Matt MacKenziePlace 137 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 30:15 |
| 138 | Taylor SowersPlace 138 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 30:17 |
| 139 | Daniel WhonsetlerPlace 139 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 30:19 |
| 140 | Brad NeumannPlace 140 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 30:22 |
| 141 | Sean JessupPlace 141 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 30:23 |
| 142 | Josh ManorePlace 142 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 30:24 |
| 143 | Mike EblinPlace 143 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 30:27 |
| 144 | Jonathan CrookPlace 144 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 30:28 |
| 145 | Justin MetzgerPlace 145 · Muskingum | — | Muskingum | 30:33 |
| 146 | Dan RaffertyPlace 146 · Denison | — | Denison | 30:34 |
| 147 | James LewisPlace 147 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 30:34 |
| 148 | Tyler CongrovePlace 148 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 30:37 |
| 149 | John SullivanPlace 149 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 30:43 |
| 150 | Corey MehlPlace 150 · Charleston | — | Charleston | 30:44 |
| 151 | Maxfield SheaPlace 151 · Oberlin | — | Oberlin | 30:45 |
| 152 | Phil HardymonPlace 152 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 30:51 |
| 153 | Nathan WirrigPlace 153 · Capital | — | Capital | 30:53 |
| 154 | Sean DunnePlace 154 · Oberlin | — | Oberlin | 30:54 |
| 155 | Tony BakerPlace 155 · Oberlin | — | Oberlin | 30:55 |
| 156 | Andrew KepplerPlace 156 · Capital | — | Capital | 31:04 |
| 157 | Zach FerresPlace 157 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 31:05 |
| 158 | Tim MurphyPlace 158 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 31:09 |
| 159 | Ian StaffordPlace 159 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 31:13 |
| 160 | Josh MatthewsPlace 160 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 31:18 |
| 161 | Brandon HunterPlace 161 · Ohio Wesleyan | — | Ohio Wesleyan | 31:23 |
| 162 | Ben WibberleyPlace 162 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 31:24 |
| 163 | Dustin WinePlace 163 · Mount Vernon Nazarene | — | Mount Vernon Nazarene | 31:33 |
| 164 | Nick AnnarinoPlace 164 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 31:34 |
| 165 | Nick RaderPlace 165 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 31:40 |
| 166 | Tim GrubbPlace 166 · Mount Vernon Nazarene | — | Mount Vernon Nazarene | 31:40 |
| 167 | Alex ShiflerPlace 167 · Glenville State | — | Glenville State | 31:48 |
| 168 | Johnathan JacksonPlace 168 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 31:53 |
| 169 | Daniel ButlerPlace 169 · Oberlin | — | Oberlin | 32:02 |
| 170 | Nick CorkillPlace 170 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 32:02 |
| 171 | Kazuki IkedoPlace 171 · Mount Union | — | Mount Union | 32:05 |
| 172 | David ClarkPlace 172 · Mount Vernon Nazarene | — | Mount Vernon Nazarene | 32:10 |
| 173 | Todd JohnsonPlace 173 · Denison | — | Denison | 32:11 |
| 174 | Matt GearingerPlace 174 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 32:13 |
| 175 | Andrew ReppPlace 175 · DePauw | — | DePauw | 32:14 |
| 176 | Kevin HoskinsPlace 176 · Tiffin | — | Tiffin | 32:16 |
| 177 | Kraig ReiberPlace 177 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 32:18 |
| 178 | Brent StarkPlace 178 | — | — | 32:18 |
| 179 | Zach TugglePlace 179 · Mount Vernon Nazarene | — | Mount Vernon Nazarene | 32:23 |
| 180 | Tony MillhousePlace 180 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 32:24 |
| 181 | Andrew SmithPlace 181 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 32:36 |
| 182 | Josh MyersPlace 182 · Charleston | — | Charleston | 32:42 |
| 183 | Kris ReePlace 183 · Otterbein | — | Otterbein | 32:43 |
| 184 | Eric BecherPlace 184 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 32:43 |
| 185 | Adam SheetzPlace 185 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 32:59 |
| 186 | Zack LinkPlace 186 · Capital | — | Capital | 32:59 |
| 187 | Ben HawesPlace 187 · Mount Vernon Nazarene | — | Mount Vernon Nazarene | 33:03 |
| 188 | Daren StaughPlace 188 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 33:18 |
| 189 | Curtis WildmanPlace 189 · Glenville State | — | Glenville State | 33:21 |
| 190 | Joey OliverPlace 190 · Muskingum | — | Muskingum | 33:32 |
| 191 | Danny LittlePlace 191 · Wilmington | — | Wilmington | 33:36 |
| 192 | David HearnePlace 192 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 33:41 |
| 193 | Sean DaughertyPlace 193 · Ohio Northern | — | Ohio Northern | 33:47 |
| 194 | Ray AllenPlace 194 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 34:04 |
| 195 | Andrew WhitemanPlace 195 · Oberlin | — | Oberlin | 34:05 |
| 196 | Corey PullenPlace 196 · Charleston | — | Charleston | 34:06 |
| 197 | Allan DovePlace 197 · Glenville State | — | Glenville State | 34:06 |
| 198 | John StanleyPlace 198 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 34:21 |
| 199 | Adam BeelerPlace 199 · Wittenberg | — | Wittenberg | 34:51 |
| 200 | Alex CerierPlace 200 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 35:18 |
| 201 | Lou GusbarPlace 201 · Charleston | — | Charleston | 35:22 |
| 202 | Cris SommervillePlace 202 · Glenville State | — | Glenville State | 35:32 |
| 203 | Josh ChapmanPlace 203 · Glenville State | — | Glenville State | 35:47 |
| 204 | Michael GallikPlace 204 · Rose-Hulman | — | Rose-Hulman | 36:29 |
| 205 | Andre ClayburnPlace 205 · Capital | — | Capital | 36:51 |