| 1 | Kirk SaundersPlace 1 · Grade So · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | So | Anderson (Ind.) | 26:53 |
| 2 | Jacob NaegeliPlace 2 · Grade Jr · EarlhamUnofficial | Jr | Earlham | 26:58 |
| 3 | Taylor HolmesPlace 3 · Grade Jr · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | Jr | Anderson (Ind.) | 27:10 |
| 4 | Taylor LowryPlace 4 · Grade Fr · Vincennes (IN)Unofficial | Fr | Vincennes (IN) | 27:13 |
| 5 | Eric LinnPlace 5 · Grade So · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | So | Anderson (Ind.) | 27:43 |
| 6 | Jake WyattPlace 6 · Grade Jr · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | Jr | Anderson (Ind.) | 27:55 |
| 7 | D.J. TaylorPlace 7 · Grade Fr · Vincennes (IN)Unofficial | Fr | Vincennes (IN) | 27:59 |
| 8 | Emby DuncanPlace 8 · Grade Jr · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | Jr | Anderson (Ind.) | 28:01 |
| 9 | Matt St. AmourPlace 9 · Grade Jr · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | Jr | Anderson (Ind.) | 28:05 |
| 10 | Jeremiah StichterPlace 10 · Grade Fr · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | Fr | Anderson (Ind.) | 28:16 |
| 11 | Drew BeatyPlace 11 · Grade Sr · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | Sr | Anderson (Ind.) | 28:27 |
| 12 | Simon ConradPlace 12 · Grade Fr · EarlhamUnofficial | Fr | Earlham | 28:31 |
| 13 | Justin TaylorPlace 13 · Grade So · IU East (Ind.)Unofficial | So | IU East (Ind.) | 28:40 |
| 14 | Kevin IkerdPlace 14 · Grade Fr · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | Fr | Anderson (Ind.) | 29:03 |
| 15 | Marc St.amourPlace 15 · Grade Jr · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | Jr | Anderson (Ind.) | 29:11 |
| 16 | Michael BanningPlace 16 · Grade Fr · Cincinnati Christian (Ohio)Unofficial | Fr | Cincinnati Christian (Ohio) | 29:14 |
| 17 | Chaven DavidsonPlace 17 · Grade Fr · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | Fr | Anderson (Ind.) | 29:32 |
| 18 | Ryan DaughertyPlace 18 · Grade So · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | So | Anderson (Ind.) | 29:43 |
| 38 | Emily PfleidererPlace 38 · Grade So · EarlhamUnofficial | So | Earlham | 29:47 PR |
| 19 | Brandon ArnettPlace 19 · Grade Fr · IU East (Ind.)Unofficial | Fr | IU East (Ind.) | 29:49 PR |
| 20 | Patrick SmithPlace 20 · Grade Fr · IU East (Ind.)Unofficial | Fr | IU East (Ind.) | 30:02 PR |
| 21 | Aaron MyersPlace 21 · Grade Fr · IU East (Ind.)Unofficial | Fr | IU East (Ind.) | 30:06 |
| 22 | Cole CarvourPlace 22 · Grade Fr · EarlhamUnofficial | Fr | Earlham | 30:16 |
| 23 | Andrew AbbottPlace 23 · Grade So · Anderson (Ind.)Unofficial | So | Anderson (Ind.) | 30:21 |
| 24 | Charlie BoydPlace 24 · Grade Fr · EarlhamUnofficial | Fr | Earlham | 30:27 |
| 25 | Kelsey RowlandPlace 25 · Grade So · Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended)Unofficial | So | Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | 30:38 |
| 26 | Robert LanePlace 26 · Grade Fr · EarlhamUnofficial | Fr | Earlham | 31:21 |
| 27 | Gary BozemanPlace 27 · Grade Fr · Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended)Unofficial | Fr | Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | 31:28 PR |
| 28 | Cyrus DudgeonPlace 28 · Grade Sr · EarlhamUnofficial | Sr | Earlham | 31:46 |
| 29 | Josh CaptainPlace 29 · Grade Jr · Cincinnati Christian (Ohio)Unofficial | Jr | Cincinnati Christian (Ohio) | 31:56 |
| 30 | Clint WetzelPlace 30 · Grade Fr · Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended)Unofficial | Fr | Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | 32:11 |
| 31 | Tim LowmanPlace 31 · Grade Jr · IU East (Ind.)Unofficial | Jr | IU East (Ind.) | 32:12 |
| 32 | Wilmer ChavarriaPlace 32 · Grade Jr · EarlhamUnofficial | Jr | Earlham | 32:17 |
| 33 | Jarred LefflerPlace 33 · Grade Fr · Vincennes (IN)Unofficial | Fr | Vincennes (IN) | 32:39 |
| 34 | Matthew KuhnPlace 34 · Grade Fr · Cincinnati Christian (Ohio)Unofficial | Fr | Cincinnati Christian (Ohio) | 34:44 |
| 35 | Tyler PryPlace 35 · Grade Jr · EarlhamUnofficial | Jr | Earlham | 36:00 |
| 36 | Severiano LopezPlace 36 · Grade Fr · Vincennes (IN)Unofficial | Fr | Vincennes (IN) | 39:29 PR |
| 37 | Michael DelaneyPlace 37 · Grade So · Vincennes (IN)Unofficial | So | Vincennes (IN) | 41:02 |
| 38 | David BortonPlace 38 · Grade Sr · Cincinnati Christian (Ohio)Unofficial | Sr | Cincinnati Christian (Ohio) | 45:36 |