| 1 | Eddie RicoPlace 1 · Calumet | — | Calumet | 16:38 |
| 2 | Henry LeePlace 2 · Gary Roosevelt | — | Gary Roosevelt | 16:47 |
| 3 | Jacob BennettPlace 3 · Andrean | — | Andrean | 17:00 |
| 4 | Blake WilliamsPlace 4 · Munster | — | Munster | 17:00 |
| 5 | Joe KolavoPlace 5 · Crown Point | — | Crown Point | 17:05 |
| 6 | Garett BonkPlace 6 · Andrean | — | Andrean | 17:08 |
| 7 | Logan KochPlace 7 · Crown Point | — | Crown Point | 17:11 |
| 8 | Cody WillisPlace 8 · Lowell | — | Lowell | 17:13 |
| 9 | Matthew AbnerPlace 9 · Hobart | — | Hobart | 17:14 |
| 10 | Corbin MassaPlace 10 · Merrillville | — | Merrillville | 17:20 |
| 11 | Brendan GeorgasPlace 11 · Munster | — | Munster | 17:21 |
| 12 | David FeitzPlace 12 · Lowell | — | Lowell | 17:21 |
| 13 | Justin AllenPlace 13 · Hobart | — | Hobart | 17:22 |
| 14 | Jonathan JimenezPlace 14 · Andrean | — | Andrean | 17:23 |
| 15 | Kale LiechtyPlace 15 · Hobart | — | Hobart | 17:25 |
| 16 | Joe RattazziPlace 16 · Crown Point | — | Crown Point | 17:28 |
| 17 | David GladysPlace 17 · Hanover Central | — | Hanover Central | 17:32 |
| 18 | Alex HernandezPlace 18 · Highland | — | Highland | 17:33 |
| 19 | Phil MalettaPlace 19 · Andrean | — | Andrean | 17:36 |
| 20 | Davie PatteePlace 20 · Lowell | — | Lowell | 17:46 |
| 21 | Matt St. AmourPlace 21 · Lake Central | — | Lake Central | 17:47 |
| 22 | Marc St. AmourPlace 22 · Lake Central | — | Lake Central | 17:50 |
| 23 | Jeff JustusPlace 23 · Munster | — | Munster | 17:50 |
| 24 | Zack UrevigPlace 24 · Crown Point | — | Crown Point | 17:51 |
| 25 | Tad JameyfieldPlace 25 · Highland | — | Highland | 17:51 |
| 26 | Kenton PrattPlace 26 · Lake Central | — | Lake Central | 17:52 |
| 27 | Michael RainboltPlace 27 · Lake Central | — | Lake Central | 17:56 |
| 28 | Aaron WatsonPlace 28 · Hanover Central | — | Hanover Central | 17:57 |
| 29 | Adam BecerraPlace 29 · Andrean | — | Andrean | 17:58 |
| 30 | Derek SmithPlace 30 · Hanover Central | — | Hanover Central | 17:59 |
| 31 | Jovan AndjelichPlace 31 · Munster | — | Munster | 18:00 |
| 32 | Anthony JanigaPlace 32 · Andrean | — | Andrean | 18:12 |
| 33 | Federico Olaosobikan MunsterPlace 33 · 68 | — | 68 | 18:16 |
| 34 | Kenny HamiltonPlace 34 · Munster | — | Munster | 18:18 |
| 35 | Zach WiersmaPlace 35 · Lowell | — | Lowell | 18:24 |
| 36 | Sam KasmarkPlace 36 · Munster | — | Munster | 18:25 |
| 37 | Charles HuffnaglePlace 37 · Hanover Central | — | Hanover Central | 18:27 |
| 38 | Brian GallasPlace 38 · Highland | — | Highland | 18:27 |
| 39 | Brian BowmanPlace 39 · Hobart | — | Hobart | 18:30 |
| 40 | Dan MoserPlace 40 · Highland | — | Highland | 18:35 |
| 41 | Steven BergPlace 41 · Hanover Central | — | Hanover Central | 18:37 |
| 42 | Cameron ThomasPlace 42 · Lowell | — | Lowell | 18:38 |
| 43 | Allan AppiahPlace 43 · Highland | — | Highland | 18:38 |
| 44 | Chris JelewskiPlace 44 · Lake Central | — | Lake Central | 18:40 |
| 45 | Jake PontonPlace 45 · Lake Central | — | Lake Central | 18:41 |
| 46 | Kyle DunlapPlace 46 · Highland | — | Highland | 18:41 |
| 47 | Joey StiglitzPlace 47 · Highland | — | Highland | 18:41 |
| 48 | Craig JordanPlace 48 · Calumet | — | Calumet | 18:47 |
| 49 | Aaron MartinezPlace 49 · Hammond Gavit | — | Hammond Gavit | 18:48 |
| 50 | Dustin DenisiukPlace 50 · Calumet | — | Calumet | 18:51 |
| 51 | Kyle KaciusPlace 51 · Lake Central | — | Lake Central | 18:51 |
| 52 | Joseph AlvarezPlace 52 · Andrean | — | Andrean | 18:59 |
| 53 | Tim GalosPlace 53 · Hammond Gavit | — | Hammond Gavit | 19:01 |
| 54 | David WeiandPlace 54 · Lowell | — | Lowell | 19:06 |
| 55 | Daniel MartinezPlace 55 · Hobart | — | Hobart | 19:07 |
| 56 | Anthony GaryPlace 56 · Hobart | — | Hobart | 19:09 |
| 57 | Mike JordanPlace 57 · Calumet | — | Calumet | 19:14 |
| 58 | Andrew FederPlace 58 · Crown Point | — | Crown Point | 19:25 |
| 59 | Michael ManchaPlace 59 · Hanover Central | — | Hanover Central | 19:30 |
| 60 | Jacob LambPlace 60 · Lowell | — | Lowell | 19:34 |
| 61 | Kyle DavisPlace 61 · Crown Point | — | Crown Point | 19:41 |
| 62 | Esteban CorralPlace 62 · Hammond Gavit | — | Hammond Gavit | 19:51 |
| 63 | Brian WittPlace 63 · Crown Point | — | Crown Point | 20:14 |
| 64 | Charles KallasPlace 64 · Hammond Gavit | — | Hammond Gavit | 20:15 |
| 65 | Jose PalmerinPlace 65 · Hammond Gavit | — | Hammond Gavit | 20:17 |
| 66 | Jeremy OlsonPlace 66 · Hanover Central | — | Hanover Central | 20:19 |
| 67 | Cyle KasperPlace 67 · Calumet | — | Calumet | 20:21 |
| 68 | Kip MolchanPlace 68 · Hobart | — | Hobart | 20:47 |
| 69 | Michael ClarkPlace 69 · Calumet | — | Calumet | 21:41 |
| 70 | Joe PoteetePlace 70 · Hammond Gavit | — | Hammond Gavit | 21:47 |
| 71 | Tom NovakPlace 71 · Hammond Gavit | — | Hammond Gavit | 21:49 |