| 1 | Alex BestPlace 1 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 19:02.78 |
| 2 | David TattoniPlace 2 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 19:03.38 |
| 3 | John BokmanPlace 3 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 19:16.34 |
| 4 | Nishad NalgundwarPlace 4 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 19:16.67 |
| 5 | Jason MagidPlace 5 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 20:26.43 |
| 6 | Justin EngPlace 6 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 20:27.73 |
| 7 | Olu IjandipePlace 7 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 20:43.91 |
| 8 | Johan SalasPlace 8 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 20:46.20 |
| 9 | Oliver CranePlace 9 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 20:47.27 |
| 10 | Brett ClanceyPlace 10 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 20:52.17 |
| 11 | Kevin ZouPlace 11 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 20:58.03 |
| 12 | Ryan LynchPlace 12 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 20:58.85 |
| 13 | Noah SilvermanPlace 13 · Pennington School | — | Pennington School | 21:09.28 |
| 14 | Jack DuganPlace 14 · George School | — | George School | 21:17.57 |
| 15 | Tomo ChoPlace 15 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 21:30.47 |
| 16 | Tony DangPlace 16 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 21:33.10 |
| 17 | Jackson VoynickPlace 17 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 21:41.91 |
| 18 | Mike PattersonPlace 18 · George School | — | George School | 21:43.34 |
| 19 | John FitzgeraldPlace 19 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 21:47.89 |
| 20 | Cesar GonzalezPlace 20 · Paterson Charter School | — | Paterson Charter School | 21:52.70 |
| 21 | Joankel HernandezPlace 21 · Paterson Charter School | — | Paterson Charter School | 21:54.15 |
| 22 | Fernando SoaresPlace 22 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 21:54.94 |
| 23 | Joseph HaggertyPlace 23 · Princeton Day | — | Princeton Day | 22:03.72 |
| 24 | Matt CelantanoPlace 24 · Pennington School | — | Pennington School | 22:05.53 |
| 25 | Michael CoiroPlace 25 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 22:20.99 |
| 26 | Andrew SosanyaPlace 26 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 22:23.91 |
| 27 | Byron SimmonsPlace 27 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 22:24.43 |
| 28 | Ydris FrazierPlace 28 · Paterson Charter School | — | Paterson Charter School | 22:34.77 |
| 29 | Jalen ThompsonPlace 29 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 22:40.81 |
| 30 | Frank ValentePlace 30 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 22:43.19 |
| 31 | Andy DelRosarioPlace 31 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 22:45.92 |
| 32 | Cedric AlbanoPlace 32 · Pennington School | — | Pennington School | 22:47.97 |
| 33 | Edmond SalmeronPlace 33 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 22:55.14 |
| 34 | Gerrit CraterPlace 34 · Pennington School | — | Pennington School | 22:58.28 |
| 35 | Matt GianottiPlace 35 · Princeton Day | — | Princeton Day | 23:01.83 |
| 36 | Adrian CeballoPlace 36 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 23:05.64 |
| 37 | Michael KingPlace 37 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 23:07.17 |
| 38 | Andy EricksonPlace 38 · Princeton Day | — | Princeton Day | 23:09.31 |
| 39 | Max Smith-DucatiPlace 39 · George School | — | George School | 23:09.66 |
| 40 | Justin RyuPlace 40 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 23:30.22 |
| 41 | Dan WilsonPlace 41 · George School | — | George School | 23:35.75 |
| 42 | Jason LaytonPlace 42 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 23:43.83 |
| 43 | Tyler MahlmannPlace 43 · George School | — | George School | 23:58.83 |
| 44 | Jesse ZhouPlace 44 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 24:19.33 |
| 45 | David AlvarezPlace 45 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 24:29.29 |
| 46 | Connor DurishPlace 46 · George School | — | George School | 25:01.16 |
| 47 | Naavik PatelPlace 47 · George School | — | George School | 25:03.37 |
| 48 | Tom CosgrovePlace 48 · Pennington School | — | Pennington School | 25:06.54 |
| 49 | Mia WongPlace 49 · Princeton Day | — | Princeton Day | 25:11.30 |
| 50 | Max NewmanPlace 50 · Princeton Day | — | Princeton Day | 25:14.46 |
| 51 | Rasheed AdewolePlace 51 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 25:37.07 |
| 52 | Elijah BarnesPlace 52 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 25:47.49 |
| 53 | Zach IzzardPlace 53 · Princeton Day | — | Princeton Day | 25:54.03 |
| 54 | Jason ThobornePlace 54 · Paterson Charter School | — | Paterson Charter School | 25:54.49 |
| 55 | Jamie GraysonPlace 55 · Pennington School | — | Pennington School | 26:20.48 |
| 56 | Matthew PrashkarPlace 56 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 26:33.79 |
| 57 | Nathan ZeleskoPlace 57 · George School | — | George School | 26:35.41 |
| 58 | Tom CifelliPlace 58 · George School | — | George School | 27:03.40 |
| 59 | Leo SmithPlace 59 · North Star Academy | — | North Star Academy | 27:15.63 |
| 60 | Henrik NkosiPlace 60 · North Star Academy | — | North Star Academy | 27:16.56 |
| 61 | Tatiana TorresPlace 61 · Paterson Charter School | — | Paterson Charter School | 27:36.06 |
| 62 | Emma ShainwaldPlace 62 · Princeton Day | — | Princeton Day | 28:43.33 |
| 63 | Bhrat NagalamadakaPlace 63 · Princeton Day | — | Princeton Day | 29:12.51 |
| 64 | Joshua MartinsPlace 64 · St. Benedicts | — | St. Benedicts | 29:35.36 |
| 65 | Julissa RojasPlace 65 · Paterson Charter School | — | Paterson Charter School | 30:04.06 |
| 66 | Iramecca MarhsallPlace 66 · Paterson Charter School | — | Paterson Charter School | 30:10.08 |
| 67 | Andrea GilPlace 67 · Paterson Charter School | — | Paterson Charter School | 30:20.55 |
| 68 | Arneris RojasPlace 68 · Paterson Charter School | — | Paterson Charter School | 30:21.00 |
| 69 | Brenet MudrowPlace 69 · North Star Academy | — | North Star Academy | 31:31.69 |
| 70 | Xaymara RiveriaPlace 70 · North Star Academy | — | North Star Academy | 31:37.14 |
| 71 | Jason KongPlace 71 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 32:07.77 |
| 72 | Sophie SpearsPlace 72 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 32:54.99 |
| 73 | Cassie FollmanPlace 73 · Peddie School | — | Peddie School | 33:59.63 |
| 74 | Dina AlterPlace 74 · Princeton Day | — | Princeton Day | 35:20.95 |
| 75 | Sajadah LondonPlace 75 · North Star Academy | — | North Star Academy | 36:08.81 |
| 76 | Raniya Martin-DavisPlace 76 · Paterson Charter School | — | Paterson Charter School | 37:55.07 |