| 1 | Ryan HollandPlace 1 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 6:08 |
| 2 | Joe VigilantePlace 2 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 6:12 |
| 3 | John BatistaPlace 3 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 6:13 |
| 4 | Alejandro BrancalePlace 4 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 6:16 |
| 5 | Jerem CassamassinoPlace 5 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 6:18 |
| 6 | Cole DigiacomoPlace 6 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 6:19 |
| 7 | Kent HandlowitchPlace 7 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 6:24 |
| 8 | Alex GambinoPlace 8 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 6:26 |
| 9 | James SchneiderPlace 9 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 6:28 |
| 10 | Dan KwiatkowskiPlace 10 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 6:29 |
| 11 | Daniel MurphyPlace 11 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 6:30 |
| 12 | Joseph CottonePlace 12 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 6:36 |
| 13 | Joe AlbanoPlace 13 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 6:36 |
| 14 | Christian MartinezPlace 14 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 6:38 |
| 15 | Bryan ElliotPlace 15 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 6:40 |
| 16 | Shane KimballPlace 16 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 6:41 |
| 17 | Dan MacriPlace 17 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 6:44 |
| 18 | Frank MorgantiPlace 18 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 6:45 |
| 19 | Tullis GardnerPlace 19 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 6:46 |
| 20 | Victor PolizzottoPlace 20 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 6:48 |
| 21 | Patrick LynchPlace 21 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 6:49 |
| 22 | Kyle SinclairPlace 22 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 6:52 |
| 23 | Sean TorresPlace 23 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 6:54 |
| 24 | Nick MartelloPlace 24 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 6:56 |
| 25 | Johncarlo DacuntaPlace 25 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 6:59 |
| 26 | Liam HardingPlace 26 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 7:11 |
| 27 | Joe JayPlace 27 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 7:12 |
| 28 | Joseph LeporePlace 28 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 7:22 |
| 29 | Joseph ArnonePlace 29 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 7:26 |
| 30 | Kevin KidneyPlace 30 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 7:28 |
| 31 | Anthony GangemiPlace 31 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 7:32 |
| 32 | Michael RotondoPlace 32 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 7:35 |
| 33 | Bassel AbdelkaderPlace 33 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 7:48 |
| 34 | Vincent CatanzaroPlace 34 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 7:50 |
| 35 | Damian HammondPlace 35 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 7:50 |
| 36 | Robert MandryPlace 36 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 7:52 |
| 37 | James AmmirattiPlace 37 · Msgr. Farrell | — | Msgr. Farrell | 7:58 |
| 38 | Michael BovaPlace 38 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 8:04 |
| 39 | Stephen McLaughlinPlace 39 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 8:10 |
| 40 | Matthew MoutonPlace 40 · St. Peter's | — | St. Peter's | 8:32 |
| 41 | Peter TrapanesePlace 41 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 8:59 |
| 42 | Michael LosiPlace 42 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 9:40 |
| 43 | Matt NucciaroniPlace 43 · St. Joseph Sea | — | St. Joseph Sea | 10:23 |