| 1 | Peter KramerPlace 1 · Grade Sr · Queens (N.Y.) | Sr | Queens (N.Y.) | 28:35 |
| 2 | Patrick GoldbergPlace 2 · Grade Fr · Mount Saint Vincent | Fr | Mount Saint Vincent | 28:41 |
| 3 | Tyler BayPlace 3 · Grade Jr · Queens (N.Y.) | Jr | Queens (N.Y.) | 28:45 |
| 4 | Andrew NadlerPlace 4 · Grade Jr · Queens (N.Y.) | Jr | Queens (N.Y.) | 29:00 |
| 5 | Andrew MayerPlace 5 · Grade - · Queens (N.Y.) | - | Queens (N.Y.) | 29:16 |
| 6 | Scott KulmPlace 6 · Grade Fr · Cooper Union | Fr | Cooper Union | 29:17 |
| 7 | Andrew PatePlace 7 · Grade - · Staten Island | - | Staten Island | 29:50 |
| 8 | Dillon ScibelliPlace 8 · Grade Fr · Queens (N.Y.) | Fr | Queens (N.Y.) | 29:58 |
| 9 | James BuckleyPlace 9 · Grade Fr · John Jay | Fr | John Jay | 30:06 |
| 10 | Peter ChinniciPlace 10 · Grade - · Queens (N.Y.) | - | Queens (N.Y.) | 30:10 |
| 11 | Tevin BrownPlace 11 · Grade Fr · John Jay | Fr | John Jay | 30:16 |
| 12 | David CobbPlace 12 · Grade - · CCNY | - | CCNY | 30:20 |
| 13 | Adam Al-HaraizehPlace 13 · Grade Fr · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | Fr | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 30:22 |
| 14 | Christopher DelVecchioPlace 14 · Grade Fr · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | Fr | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 30:24 |
| 15 | Samuel ObisanyaPlace 15 · Grade So · Staten Island | So | Staten Island | 30:29 |
| 16 | Guy MuroloPlace 16 · Grade Sr · Queens (N.Y.) | Sr | Queens (N.Y.) | 30:31 |
| 17 | Ian BrinkPlace 17 · Grade Sr · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | Sr | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 30:32 |
| 18 | Scott ColelloPlace 18 · Grade Sr · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | Sr | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 30:40 |
| 19 | Justin MillsPlace 19 · Grade Fr · Staten Island | Fr | Staten Island | 30:47 |
| 20 | Jesse Posl-RhinehartPlace 20 · Grade - · New School (N.Y.) | - | New School (N.Y.) | 30:56 PR |
| 21 | Daniel MarinPlace 21 · Grade Jr · New School (N.Y.) | Jr | New School (N.Y.) | 31:16 PR |
| 22 | Jian-Dominique BennetPlace 22 · Grade - · Cooper Union | - | Cooper Union | 31:32 PR |
| 23 | John RalstonPlace 23 · Grade - · New School (N.Y.) | - | New School (N.Y.) | 31:43 PR |
| 24 | Jesus MedinaPlace 24 · Grade Jr · York (N.Y.) | Jr | York (N.Y.) | 31:58 PR |
| 25 | Frederick De La RosaPlace 25 · Grade Jr · John Jay | Jr | John Jay | 32:00 |
| 26 | James GoldbergPlace 26 · Grade Jr · Mount Saint Vincent | Jr | Mount Saint Vincent | 32:04 |
| 27 | Ismail OluwoPlace 27 · Grade So · York (N.Y.) | So | York (N.Y.) | 32:05 |
| 28 | Yaakor BresslerPlace 28 · Grade - · CUNY Brooklyn | - | CUNY Brooklyn | 32:16 PR |
| 29 | Kenneth MorellaPlace 29 · Grade Fr · Staten Island | Fr | Staten Island | 32:20 |
| 30 | Franklin VenturaPlace 30 · Grade - · Bronx CC | - | Bronx CC | 32:26 PR |
| 31 | Jaspreet CheemaPlace 31 · Grade - · John Jay | - | John Jay | 32:27 |
| 32 | Moshe BresslerPlace 32 · Grade Jr · CUNY Brooklyn | Jr | CUNY Brooklyn | 32:33 PR |
| 33 | Anthony ParsonsPlace 33 · Grade - · York (N.Y.) | - | York (N.Y.) | 32:40 |
| 34 | Marcelo Bravo-LopezPlace 34 · Grade Fr · Lehman | Fr | Lehman | 32:46 |
| 35 | Steven VargasPlace 35 · Grade - · John Jay | - | John Jay | 32:48 |
| 36 | Statler WillandPlace 36 · Grade Sr · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | Sr | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 32:57 |
| 37 | Khalid HalwaniPlace 37 · Grade Fr · Staten Island | Fr | Staten Island | 32:58 |
| 38 | Mostafa ElbasalPlace 38 · Grade - · York (N.Y.) | - | York (N.Y.) | 33:22 PR |
| 39 | Janssel NunezPlace 39 · Grade Fr · CCNY | Fr | CCNY | 33:26 |
| 40 | William JoyettePlace 40 · Grade - · Medgar Evers | - | Medgar Evers | 33:33 PR |
| 41 | Bobby DourountoudakisPlace 41 · Grade Fr · John Jay | Fr | John Jay | 33:35 |
| 42 | Williams GonzalezPlace 42 · Grade Fr · York (N.Y.) | Fr | York (N.Y.) | 33:39 PR |
| 43 | Kaher AhmadPlace 43 · Grade Fr · John Jay | Fr | John Jay | 33:41 |
| 44 | Jonathan SantiagoPlace 44 · Grade - · York (N.Y.) | - | York (N.Y.) | 34:06 PR |
| 45 | Adams OmedePlace 45 · Grade - · John Jay | - | John Jay | 34:26 |
| 46 | James WilkinsPlace 46 · Grade Jr · Mount Saint Vincent | Jr | Mount Saint Vincent | 35:02 |
| 47 | Seamus DouglasPlace 47 · Grade - · Mount Saint Vincent | - | Mount Saint Vincent | 35:45 |
| 48 | Yelson RodriguezPlace 48 · Grade - · Bronx CC | - | Bronx CC | 35:56 |
| 49 | Caleb JeanPlace 49 · Grade So · John Jay | So | John Jay | 36:13 |
| 50 | Chase WarrenPlace 50 · Grade - · York (N.Y.) | - | York (N.Y.) | 36:31 PR |
| 51 | Rashad ShermanPlace 51 · Grade - · New School (N.Y.) | - | New School (N.Y.) | 36:32 PR |
| 52 | Jiovanni FierroPlace 52 · Grade Jr · John Jay | Jr | John Jay | 36:34 |
| 53 | Patrick KettylePlace 53 · Grade Fr · Staten Island | Fr | Staten Island | 37:23 |
| 54 | Usman AliPlace 54 · Grade So · CCNY | So | CCNY | 37:28 PR |
| 55 | Dashaun MichiePlace 55 · Grade So · Lehman | So | Lehman | 37:35 |
| 56 | Emil MathiasenPlace 56 · Grade - · Staten Island | - | Staten Island | 37:39 PR |
| 57 | Justin GinsbergPlace 57 · Grade - · CUNY Brooklyn | - | CUNY Brooklyn | 37:53 |
| 58 | Christian BaskervillePlace 58 · Grade Fr · John Jay | Fr | John Jay | 37:54 |
| 59 | Brad DavisPlace 59 · Grade Fr · John Jay | Fr | John Jay | 37:59 PR |
| 60 | Alec BluntPlace 60 · Grade - · New School (N.Y.) | - | New School (N.Y.) | 38:25 PR |
| 61 | Jemaal AlexanderPlace 61 · Grade Sr · CCNY | Sr | CCNY | 38:40 |
| 62 | Kevin MageePlace 62 · Grade - · Mount Saint Vincent | - | Mount Saint Vincent | 39:12 |
| 63 | Augusto BlancoPlace 63 · Grade - · Lehman | - | Lehman | 39:15 |
| 64 | Joey JerezPlace 64 · Grade - · CUNY Brooklyn | - | CUNY Brooklyn | 40:14 |
| 65 | Jose UmanaPlace 65 · Grade - · CUNY Brooklyn | - | CUNY Brooklyn | 40:27 PR |
| 66 | Jordan JohnsonPlace 66 · Grade - · CUNY Brooklyn | - | CUNY Brooklyn | 40:42 |
| 67 | Christopher AugustinPlace 67 · Grade Jr · CUNY Brooklyn | Jr | CUNY Brooklyn | 40:43 |
| 68 | Christopher WelshPlace 68 · Grade - · Medgar Evers | - | Medgar Evers | 41:31 PR |
| 69 | Wendal DavisPlace 69 · Grade - · Medgar Evers | - | Medgar Evers | 41:40 PR |
| 70 | Nico GalvanPlace 70 · Grade - · New School (N.Y.) | - | New School (N.Y.) | 42:01 PR |
| 71 | Zubaib AwanPlace 71 · Grade - · CUNY Brooklyn | - | CUNY Brooklyn | 42:10 PR |
| 72 | Christopher LaingPlace 72 · Grade Jr · CCNY | Jr | CCNY | 42:25 |
| 73 | Gabriel MarroquinPlace 73 · Grade - · Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | - | Mount Saint Mary (N.Y.) | 43:13 |
| 74 | Jephtee NougaissePlace 74 · Grade - · Medgar Evers | - | Medgar Evers | 43:30 PR |
| 75 | Terrell WilliamsPlace 75 · Grade - · Bronx CC | - | Bronx CC | 43:31 PR |
| 76 | Jordan ClarkePlace 76 · Grade - · Bronx CC | - | Bronx CC | 43:51 PR |
| 77 | Justin QuinonesPlace 77 · Grade - · Lehman | - | Lehman | 44:38 PR |
| 78 | Victor PerezPlace 78 · Grade - · Lehman | - | Lehman | 44:44 PR |
| 79 | Junior DorcentPlace 79 · Grade - · Medgar Evers | - | Medgar Evers | 46:04 PR |
| 80 | Paul McgovernPlace 80 · Grade Jr · Mount Saint Vincent | Jr | Mount Saint Vincent | 50:04 |
| 81 | Aaron MunizPlace 81 · Grade So · Lehman | So | Lehman | 58:00 |