| 1 | Jeremy JohnsonPlace 1 · Grade So · Berea | So | Berea | 20:57 PR |
| 2 | Austin GangerPlace 2 · Grade Fr · Trine | Fr | Trine | 21:32 PR |
| 3 | Joseph BrendelPlace 3 · Grade Sr · Berea | Sr | Berea | 21:51 PR |
| 4 | Alexander WallacePlace 4 · Grade Sr · Berea | Sr | Berea | 22:10 PR |
| 5 | Tarrance O'ConnerPlace 5 · Grade Sr · Berea | Sr | Berea | 22:11 PR |
| 6 | Isaac WonderlinPlace 6 · Grade Fr · Anderson (Ind.) | Fr | Anderson (Ind.) | 22:13 |
| 7 | Tim HuberPlace 7 · Grade Fr · Anderson (Ind.) | Fr | Anderson (Ind.) | 22:28 PR |
| 8 | Gabriel PenkPlace 8 · Grade Fr · Earlham | Fr | Earlham | 22:32 |
| 9 | Simon ConradPlace 9 · Grade Sr · Earlham | Sr | Earlham | 22:37 PR |
| 10 | Neal TardyPlace 10 · Grade So · Anderson (Ind.) | So | Anderson (Ind.) | 22:39 PR |
| 11 | Jacob BranamPlace 11 · Grade Fr · Anderson (Ind.) | Fr | Anderson (Ind.) | 22:44 PR |
| 12 | Aaron MastPlace 12 · Grade Fr · Trine | Fr | Trine | 22:48 PR |
| 13 | Garrett BenedictPlace 13 · Grade Fr · Trine | Fr | Trine | 22:58 PR |
| 14 | Zachary RaabPlace 14 · Grade So · Berea | So | Berea | 23:08 PR |
| 15 | Michael JamesPlace 15 · Grade Jr · Berea | Jr | Berea | 23:11 PR |
| 16 | Jeremiah StichterPlace 16 · Grade Sr · Anderson (Ind.) | Sr | Anderson (Ind.) | 23:23 PR |
| 17 | Adam SchaafPlace 17 · Grade Fr · Trine | Fr | Trine | 23:39 PR |
| 18 | William NiederhausPlace 18 · Grade Fr · Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | Fr | Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | 23:50 |
| 19 | Sam BaylissPlace 19 · Grade So · Anderson (Ind.) | So | Anderson (Ind.) | 23:52 PR |
| 20 | Colin ThompsonPlace 20 · Grade So · Trine | So | Trine | 23:54 PR |
| 21 | Casey MontiPlace 21 · Grade So · Berea | So | Berea | 24:05 PR |
| 22 | Barry ManleyPlace 22 · Grade Jr · Berea | Jr | Berea | 24:09 PR |
| 23 | Travis RiggPlace 23 · Grade Sr · Berea | Sr | Berea | 24:10 PR |
| 24 | Johnny Rezende-ShalomPlace 24 · Grade Jr · Earlham | Jr | Earlham | 24:12 PR |
| 25 | Patrick SmithPlace 25 · Grade Sr · Anderson (Ind.) | Sr | Anderson (Ind.) | 24:18 PR |
| 26 | Michael GreenwellPlace 26 · Grade - · Trine | - | Trine | 24:19 PR |
| 27 | Cody MartPlace 27 · Grade So · Trine | So | Trine | 24:23 PR |
| 28 | Erick HeckamanPlace 28 · Grade - · Trine | - | Trine | 24:27 PR |
| 29 | Charlie BoydPlace 29 · Grade Sr · Earlham | Sr | Earlham | 24:40 PR |
| 30 | Jakub LonskyPlace 30 · Grade Sr · Berea | Sr | Berea | 24:47 PR |
| 31 | Keith RunyanPlace 31 · Grade Jr · Earlham | Jr | Earlham | 24:53 PR |
| 32 | Michael GreenwellPlace 32 · Grade - · Trine | - | Trine | 25:06 |
| 33 | Duncan BarberPlace 33 · Grade So · Earlham | So | Earlham | 25:06 PR |
| 34 | Brock ArnoldPlace 34 · Grade So · Berea | So | Berea | 25:17 PR |
| 35 | Collin GoodinPlace 35 · Grade Fr · Trine | Fr | Trine | 25:22 PR |
| 36 | Seth FarleyPlace 36 · Grade Jr · Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | Jr | Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | 25:40 |
| 37 | Richard FoleyPlace 37 · Grade So · Berea | So | Berea | 25:50 PR |
| 38 | Harley NorthcutPlace 38 · Grade - · Trine | - | Trine | 26:02 PR |
| 39 | Andrew RowanPlace 39 · Grade Fr · Trine | Fr | Trine | 26:24 PR |
| 40 | John LowderPlace 40 · Grade Jr · Berea | Jr | Berea | 26:29 PR |
| 41 | Dylan CooperPlace 41 · Grade Fr · Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | Fr | Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | 26:31 |
| 42 | Tanner MasonPlace 42 · Grade Fr · Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | Fr | Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | 27:02 |
| 43 | Jared VanHookPlace 43 · Grade - · Trine | - | Trine | 27:24 PR |
| 44 | Nathan SparksPlace 44 · Grade So · Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | So | Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | 27:47 |
| 45 | Corey OserPlace 45 · Grade So · Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | So | Oakland City (Ind.) (Athletics Suspended) | 27:49 |
| 46 | Robert LanePlace 46 · Grade Sr · Earlham | Sr | Earlham | 28:17 PR |