| 1 | Ryan CarrollPlace 1 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 19:56.29 |
| 2 | Corey LyonsPlace 2 · Grade Sr · Mary Washington | Sr | Mary Washington | 20:33.70 PR |
| 3 | Kevin SperayPlace 3 · Grade So · Mary Washington | So | Mary Washington | 20:41.80 PR |
| 4 | Julian MenkPlace 4 · Grade Jr · Mary Washington | Jr | Mary Washington | 20:46.50 PR |
| 5 | Chris MarkhamPlace 5 · Grade Fr · Mary Washington | Fr | Mary Washington | 21:00.06 |
| 6 | Andrew RichardsonPlace 6 · Grade So · Christopher Newport | So | Christopher Newport | 21:00.72 PR |
| 7 | James ThomsonPlace 7 · Grade Fr · Christopher Newport | Fr | Christopher Newport | 21:01.04 PR |
| 8 | Jeff BransonPlace 8 · Grade Sr · Mary Washington | Sr | Mary Washington | 21:01.92 PR |
| 9 | Nick EghtessadPlace 9 · Grade So · Mary Washington | So | Mary Washington | 21:09.31 PR |
| 10 | Charles PruittPlace 10 · Grade Fr · Christopher Newport | Fr | Christopher Newport | 21:10.72 PR |
| 11 | Chris AndersonPlace 11 · Grade Jr · Mary Washington | Jr | Mary Washington | 21:13.35 PR |
| 12 | Phil DevinePlace 12 · Grade So · Mary Washington | So | Mary Washington | 21:16.15 PR |
| 13 | Will BrunerPlace 13 · Grade Fr · Christopher Newport | Fr | Christopher Newport | 21:22.09 PR |
| 14 | Nate DawesPlace 14 · Grade Sr · Mary Washington | Sr | Mary Washington | 21:33.35 PR |
| 15 | Chris SandovalPlace 15 · Grade Fr · Mary Washington | Fr | Mary Washington | 21:35.58 |
| 16 | Corey RosenbergPlace 16 · Grade Fr · Christopher Newport | Fr | Christopher Newport | 21:37.62 PR |
| 17 | Daniel RichardPlace 17 · Grade Jr · Christopher Newport | Jr | Christopher Newport | 21:51.27 PR |
| 18 | Ian GrangerPlace 18 · Grade Fr · Mary Washington | Fr | Mary Washington | 21:58.49 PR |
| 19 | Dylan FreemanPlace 19 · Grade Fr · Christopher Newport | Fr | Christopher Newport | 22:16.95 PR |
| 20 | Kevin McCarthyPlace 20 · Grade Fr · Mary Washington | Fr | Mary Washington | 22:23.86 PR |
| 21 | Eric GinsburgPlace 21 · Grade Sr · Christopher Newport | Sr | Christopher Newport | 22:53.19 PR |
| 22 | Graham LarsonPlace 22 · Grade - · Christopher Newport | - | Christopher Newport | 23:04.94 PR |
| 23 | James KingPlace 23 · Grade Jr · Mary Washington | Jr | Mary Washington | 23:11.15 PR |
| 24 | Matthew MargopoulosPlace 24 · Grade Fr · Christopher Newport | Fr | Christopher Newport | 23:37.59 PR |
| 25 | Sydney MachokotoPlace 25 · Grade - · Methodist | - | Methodist | 23:53.13 |
| 26 | Tom HudsonPlace 26 · Grade So · Mary Washington | So | Mary Washington | 23:56.26 PR |
| 27 | Tate HouffPlace 27 · Grade So · Mary Washington | So | Mary Washington | 24:11.88 |
| 28 | Patrick ConnellyPlace 28 · Grade - · Methodist | - | Methodist | 24:13.60 PR |
| 29 | David PittardPlace 29 · Grade Fr · Methodist | Fr | Methodist | 24:13.82 PR |
| 30 | Eduardo RieraPlace 30 · Grade - · Methodist | - | Methodist | 24:16.30 PR |
| 31 | Mason MendenhallPlace 31 · Grade Fr · Mary Washington | Fr | Mary Washington | 24:45.06 PR |
| 32 | Jaqwese WilliamsPlace 32 · Grade - · Chowan | - | Chowan | 25:04.15 PR |
| 33 | Ferdinand MeggsPlace 33 · Grade - · Chowan | - | Chowan | 25:55.80 PR |
| 34 | Shawn DaleyPlace 34 · Grade - · Chowan | - | Chowan | 26:29.99 PR |
| 35 | Donte SmithPlace 35 · Grade Jr · Methodist | Jr | Methodist | 27:13.80 PR |
| 36 | Jack JonesPlace 36 · Grade - · Chowan | - | Chowan | 27:33.03 PR |
| 37 | Adam KernsPlace 37 · Grade - · Chowan | - | Chowan | 27:56.88 PR |
| 38 | Jerrell RalphPlace 38 · Grade Fr · Chowan | Fr | Chowan | 30:16.39 PR |
| 39 | Claude FarringtonPlace 39 · Grade - · Methodist | - | Methodist | 31:24.65 PR |