| 1. | Kyle WinterPlace 1. · Grade So · MarquetteUnofficial | So | Marquette | 1:54.39a | 10 |
| 2. | Jack SpilmanPlace 2. · Grade So · Miami (Ohio)Unofficial | So | Miami (Ohio) | 1:55.98a | 8 |
| 3. | Kyle EsberPlace 3. · Grade Fr · CincinnatiUnofficial | Fr | Cincinnati | 1:56.20a | 6 |
| 4. | Kyle NeyerPlace 4. · Grade Jr · CincinnatiUnofficial | Jr | Cincinnati | 1:56.59a | 5 |
| 5. | Sean JonesPlace 5. · UnattachedUnofficial | — | Unattached | 1:56.64a | 4 |
| 6. | Kevin BrownPlace 6. · Grade Fr · Miami (Ohio)Unofficial | Fr | Miami (Ohio) | 1:58.25a | 3 |
| 7. | Joe GuerraPlace 7. · Grade Jr · FindlayUnofficial | Jr | Findlay | 1:58.26a | 2 |
| 8. | Tony WilliamsonPlace 8. · Grade So · CincinnatiUnofficial | So | Cincinnati | 1:58.33a | 1 |
| 9. | Mike McCarthyPlace 9. · Grade Sr · MarquetteUnofficial | Sr | Marquette | 1:58.47a | — |
| 10. | Patrick MaagPlace 10. · Grade So · MarquetteUnofficial | So | Marquette | 1:59.03a | — |
| 11. | Spencer AgnewPlace 11. · Grade So · MarquetteUnofficial | So | Marquette | 1:59.04a PR | — |
| 12. | Blake JohnsonPlace 12. · Grade Jr · MarquetteUnofficial | Jr | Marquette | 1:59.08a | — |
| 13. | Kieren BroussardPlace 13. · Grade Fr · Kentucky StateUnofficial | Fr | Kentucky State | 1:59.19a | — |
| 14. | Simon BernardPlace 14. · Grade Sr · FindlayUnofficial | Sr | Findlay | 1:59.77a | — |
| 15. | Evan BaumPlace 15. · Grade Fr · CincinnatiUnofficial | Fr | Cincinnati | 2:00.46a PR | — |
| 16. | Eric HolbrookPlace 16. · Grade Sr · Shawnee State (Ohio)Unofficial | Sr | Shawnee State (Ohio) | 2:01.21a | — |
| 17. | Ben NathanPlace 17. · UnattachedUnofficial | — | Unattached | 2:01.32a | — |
| 18. | Dorian RumblePlace 18. · Grade Fr · Robert MorrisUnofficial | Fr | Robert Morris | 2:01.93a | — |
| 19. | Joe TarantoPlace 19. · Grade So · Rio Grande (Ohio)Unofficial | So | Rio Grande (Ohio) | 2:02.04a | — |
| 20. | Chase BeckmannPlace 20. · Grade So · CincinnatiUnofficial | So | Cincinnati | 2:02.24a PR | — |
| 21. | Tyler ConnPlace 21. · Grade Fr · Shawnee State (Ohio)Unofficial | Fr | Shawnee State (Ohio) | 2:02.40a | — |
| 22. | Matt DavisPlace 22. · Grade Fr · CincinnatiUnofficial | Fr | Cincinnati | 2:02.54a PR | — |
| 23. | Nicholas KobunskiPlace 23. · Grade Fr · XavierUnofficial | Fr | Xavier | 2:02.57a | — |
| 24. | Keith SchenkelPlace 24. · Grade Fr · XavierUnofficial | Fr | Xavier | 2:03.00a | — |
| 25. | Garrett McKnightPlace 25. · Grade Jr · MarquetteUnofficial | Jr | Marquette | 2:03.17a | — |
| 26. | Chris SpudicPlace 26. · Grade Fr · MarquetteUnofficial | Fr | Marquette | 2:03.24a PR | — |
| 27. | Jermaine DwightPlace 27. · Grade Fr · Robert MorrisUnofficial | Fr | Robert Morris | 2:03.26a PR | — |
| 28. | Jeremy HornickPlace 28. · Grade Fr · Shawnee State (Ohio)Unofficial | Fr | Shawnee State (Ohio) | 2:04.27a | — |
| 29. | Christopher HansonPlace 29. · Grade Fr · XavierUnofficial | Fr | Xavier | 2:04.30a | — |
| 30. | Colin WalthourPlace 30. · Grade Jr · FindlayUnofficial | Jr | Findlay | 2:04.31a | — |
| 31. | Evan BratcherPlace 31. · Grade Jr · WheelingUnofficial | Jr | Wheeling | 2:04.37a | — |
| 32. | Dan ShaferPlace 32. · Grade Fr · Wright StateUnofficial | Fr | Wright State | 2:04.67a PR | — |
| 33. | Matt MasonPlace 33. · Grade So · WheelingUnofficial | So | Wheeling | 2:05.77a PR | — |
| 34. | Brandon BrownPlace 34. · Grade So · Shawnee State (Ohio)Unofficial | So | Shawnee State (Ohio) | 2:05.86a PR | — |
| 35. | Luke ClorePlace 35. · Grade So · CedarvilleUnofficial | So | Cedarville | 2:06.06a | — |
| 36. | William GlennaPlace 36. · Grade So · Kentucky StateUnofficial | So | Kentucky State | 2:06.36a | — |
| 37. | Ken SchwieterPlace 37. · Grade Sr · XavierUnofficial | Sr | Xavier | 2:08.76a | — |
| 38. | Ethan BlaggPlace 38. · Grade Jr · CedarvilleUnofficial | Jr | Cedarville | 2:10.06a | — |
| 40. | Sam LewisPlace 40. · Grade Sr · XavierUnofficial | Sr | Xavier | 2:12.58a | — |
| 41. | Nick BonaventurePlace 41. · Grade So · WheelingUnofficial | So | Wheeling | 2:13.17a | — |