| 1. | Marco PompiljPlace 1. · Grade 10 · Collegiate | 10 | Collegiate | 4:31.22a |
| 2. | Mike GradyPlace 2. · Grade 10 · East Meadow | 10 | East Meadow | 4:32.51a |
| 3. | Scott PourshalchiPlace 3. · Grade 10 · Roslyn | 10 | Roslyn | 4:41.45a PR |
| 4. | Darren GuzmanPlace 4. · Grade 10 · Teaneck | 10 | Teaneck | 4:48.40a PR |
| 5. | Kevin VinolasPlace 5. · Grade 10 · Minisink Valley | 10 | Minisink Valley | 4:50.52a |
| 6. | Derek SmithPlace 6. · Grade 10 · Harborfields | 10 | Harborfields | 4:52.02a |
| 7. | Corey MullinsPlace 7. · Grade 10 · Danbury | 10 | Danbury | 4:52.60a |
| 8. | John WeedPlace 8. · Grade 10 · Valley Stream Central | 10 | Valley Stream Central | 4:53.61a |
| 9. | William YarinskyPlace 9. · Grade 10 · Bronx High School of Science | 10 | Bronx High School of Science | 4:53.94a PR |
| 10. | Juan GuzmanPlace 10. · Grade 10 · Susan Wagner | 10 | Susan Wagner | 4:54.54a |
| 11. | Ron LivchitsPlace 11. · Grade 10 · Midwood | 10 | Midwood | 4:55.78a PR |
| 12. | Eric ChenPlace 12. · Grade 12 · Stuyvesant | 12 | Stuyvesant | 4:56.22a |
| 13. | Ikechukwu EgbunamPlace 13. · Grade 10 · Midwood | 10 | Midwood | 4:59.89a |
| 14. | Prathiep GugendiramPlace 14. · Grade 10 · Susan Wagner | 10 | Susan Wagner | 5:00.42a PR |
| 15. | Yasin MehmoodPlace 15. · Grade 10 · Midwood | 10 | Midwood | 5:02.70a |
| 16. | Ken CaldwellPlace 16. · Grade 10 · Danbury | 10 | Danbury | 5:03.03a |
| 17. | Nicholas Bienen EsayianPlace 17. · Grade 10 · Bronx High School of Science | 10 | Bronx High School of Science | 5:03.69a PR |
| 18. | Dan LillyPlace 18. · Grade - · Warwick Valley | - | Warwick Valley | 5:05.99a PR |
| 19. | Jack WilsonPlace 19. · Grade 10 · Harborfields | 10 | Harborfields | 5:06.55a |
| 20. | Eamon WoodsPlace 20. · Grade 10 · Stuyvesant | 10 | Stuyvesant | 5:07.51a PR |
| 21. | Zachariah OoiPlace 21. · Grade 10 · Townsend Harris | 10 | Townsend Harris | 5:07.62a PR |
| 22. | Joseph EspinozaPlace 22. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:08.88a |
| 23. | Owen SeeryPlace 23. · Grade 10 · Harborfields | 10 | Harborfields | 5:09.31a PR |
| 24. | Youssouf DoumbiaPlace 24. · Grade - · Frank J. Macchiarola | - | Frank J. Macchiarola | 5:12.42a PR |
| 25. | Grant BoydPlace 25. · Grade 10 · Newburgh Free Academy | 10 | Newburgh Free Academy | 5:12.75a PR |
| 26. | Matthew CoriPlace 26. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:14.46a PR |
| 27. | Billy AndersonPlace 27. · Grade 10 · Syosset | 10 | Syosset | 5:14.53a |
| 28. | Josue Jacques CaidorPlace 28. · Grade 10 · Clara Barton | 10 | Clara Barton | 5:15.40a PR |
| 29. | Joe NafashPlace 29. · Grade 10 · Warwick Valley | 10 | Warwick Valley | 5:15.90a PR |
| 30. | George LaraiaPlace 30. · Grade 10 · Minisink Valley | 10 | Minisink Valley | 5:17.60a PR |
| 31. | Jermaine BarnswellPlace 31. · Grade 10 · Benjamin Banneker Academy | 10 | Benjamin Banneker Academy | 5:17.60a |
| 32. | Christian YorksPlace 32. · Grade 10 · Warwick Valley | 10 | Warwick Valley | 5:18.22a PR |
| 33. | Yashsvi SharmaPlace 33. · Grade 10 · Townsend Harris | 10 | Townsend Harris | 5:20.46a |
| 34. | Guilherme DA SilvaPlace 34. · Grade - · Susan Wagner | - | Susan Wagner | 5:27.74a PR |
| 35. | Billy HebserPlace 35. · Grade 10 · Syosset | 10 | Syosset | 5:29.05a PR |
| 36. | Christopher WoodhousePlace 36. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:31.13a |
| 37. | Mohammed DewjiPlace 37. · Grade 10 · Syosset | 10 | Syosset | 5:32.01a PR |
| 38. | Harry PrevorPlace 38. · Grade 10 · Syosset | 10 | Syosset | 5:33.43a |
| 39. | Robin KumaratungaPlace 39. · Grade 10 · Susan Wagner | 10 | Susan Wagner | 5:33.53a PR |
| 40. | James DowdPlace 40. · Grade 10 · Suffern | 10 | Suffern | 5:34.34a |
| 41. | Will ButlerPlace 41. · Grade 10 · Harborfields | 10 | Harborfields | 5:36.23a PR |
| 42. | Kevin TanPlace 42. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:36.46a |
| 43. | Alex HatziioannouPlace 43. · Grade 10 · Syosset | 10 | Syosset | 5:36.68a PR |
| 44. | Ryan AndersonPlace 44. · Grade 10 · Syosset | 10 | Syosset | 5:36.79a |
| 45. | Evan LernerPlace 45. · Grade - · Bronx High School of Science | - | Bronx High School of Science | 5:37.40a PR |
| 46. | Maynard SantosPlace 46. · Grade 10 · St Johns Preparatory | 10 | St Johns Preparatory | 5:39.48a PR |
| 47. | Jahrazrah SelassiePlace 47. · Grade - · Frank J. Macchiarola | - | Frank J. Macchiarola | 5:39.70a PR |
| 48. | Jordan RoyPlace 48. · Grade 10 · McKee/Staten Island Tech | 10 | McKee/Staten Island Tech | 5:41.76a |
| 49. | Darius KwakPlace 49. · Grade 10 · Syosset | 10 | Syosset | 5:45.62a PR |
| 50. | Thomas OdermattPlace 50. · Grade 10 · St Johns Preparatory | 10 | St Johns Preparatory | 5:54.10a PR |
| 51. | Aharon PitkowskyPlace 51. · Grade 10 · Bronx High School of Science | 10 | Bronx High School of Science | 5:54.46a PR |
| 52. | Delencio Blanco-HolsteadPlace 52. · Grade 12 · Valley Stream Central | 12 | Valley Stream Central | 6:13.43a PR |
| 53. | John KennedyPlace 53. · Grade 10 · Newburgh Free Academy | 10 | Newburgh Free Academy | 6:47.01a |