| 1. | Andrew HeaneyPlace 1. · Welland, ONUnofficial | — | Welland, ON | 1:50.62a |
| 2. | Nectaly BarbosaPlace 2. · Grade 12 · ProsserUnofficial | 12 | Prosser | 1:53.02a PR |
| 3. | Jamar JonesPlace 3. · Grade 12 · G.W. Carver(Engineering & Science)Unofficial | 12 | G.W. Carver(Engineering & Science) | 1:53.14a PR |
| 4. | Justin DuncanPlace 4. · wellamd, ONUnofficial | — | wellamd, ON | 1:53.49a |
| 5. | Lionell WilliamsPlace 5. · Staten Island, NYUnofficial | — | Staten Island, NY | 1:53.52a |
| 6. | Maxwell BrunoPlace 6. · Grade 11 · Indian HillsUnofficial | 11 | Indian Hills | 1:54.33a PR |
| 7. | Darryll OliverPlace 7. · Brooklyn, NYUnofficial | — | Brooklyn, NY | 1:54.45a |
| 8. | Chris FerryPlace 8. · West Chester, PAUnofficial | — | West Chester, PA | 1:54.70a |
| 9. | Matt FrawleyPlace 9. · Grade 12 · Monsignor FarrellUnofficial | 12 | Monsignor Farrell | 1:54.95a PR |
| 10. | Matt StewartPlace 10. · Grade 12 · BrooklineUnofficial | 12 | Brookline | 1:55.02a PR |
| 11. | Patrick BlackiePlace 11. · Grade 12 · Seton Hall PrepUnofficial | 12 | Seton Hall Prep | 1:55.13a PR |
| 12. | Lance RollerPlace 12. · Grade 11 · Walter PanasUnofficial | 11 | Walter Panas | 1:55.17a PR |
| 13. | Mike WalrathPlace 13. · Grade 12 · LaramieUnofficial | 12 | Laramie | 1:55.23a PR |
| 14. | Kris HaynesPlace 14. · Grade 12 · Mt Anthony UnionUnofficial | 12 | Mt Anthony Union | 1:55.42a PR |
| 15. | Richard WestPlace 15. · Welland, ONUnofficial | — | Welland, ON | 1:55.92a |
| 16. | Gigi GibiliscoPlace 16. · Grade 12 · Notre DameUnofficial | 12 | Notre Dame | 1:55.92a PR |
| 17. | Eric StrandPlace 17. · Grade 12 · Campbell CountyUnofficial | 12 | Campbell County | 1:56.17a PR |
| 18. | Jermey McAllisterPlace 18. · Scotia, NYUnofficial | — | Scotia, NY | 1:56.27a |
| 19. | Lawrence CampbellPlace 19. · Grade 11 · PeekskillUnofficial | 11 | Peekskill | 1:56.73a PR |
| 20. | John GrayPlace 20. · Grade 12 · Southern RegionalUnofficial | 12 | Southern Regional | 1:57.18a |
| 21. | Mathieu RaymondPlace 21. · Grade 12 · College LavalUnofficial | 12 | College Laval | 1:57.29a PR |
| 22. | Jason ApwahPlace 22. · Grade 12 · RoxburyUnofficial | 12 | Roxbury | 1:57.42a PR |
| 23. | Mark HoganPlace 23. · Grade 12 · CentrevilleUnofficial | 12 | Centreville | 1:57.46a PR |
| 24. | Josh PerryPlace 24. · Grade 12 · NaugatuckUnofficial | 12 | Naugatuck | 1:57.78a PR |
| 25. | Chad RogersPlace 25. · Grade 11 · DeMatha CatholicUnofficial | 11 | DeMatha Catholic | 1:58.19a PR |
| 26. | Olivier CollinPlace 26. · Vaudreuil-Dorion, QUnofficial | — | Vaudreuil-Dorion, Q | 1:58.21a |
| 27. | Michael KimmelPlace 27. · Grade 12 · NorthernUnofficial | 12 | Northern | 1:59.01a PR |
| 28. | Cas LoxsomPlace 28. · New Haven, CTUnofficial | — | New Haven, CT | 1:59.29a |
| 29. | Scott DavisPlace 29. · Delmar, NYUnofficial | — | Delmar, NY | 1:59.36a |
| 30. | George ArcarolaPlace 30. · Queens, NYUnofficial | — | Queens, NY | 1:59.37a |
| 31. | Dan SchwartzPlace 31. · Grade 12 · Lincoln-Sudbury RegionalUnofficial | 12 | Lincoln-Sudbury Regional | 1:59.41a PR |
| 32. | Stephen GrantPlace 32. · Grade 12 · SandwichUnofficial | 12 | Sandwich | 1:59.46a PR |
| 33. | Andrew EspositoPlace 33. · Grade 11 · LedyardUnofficial | 11 | Ledyard | 1:59.73a PR |
| 34. | Dan FrostPlace 34. · Smithtown, NYUnofficial | — | Smithtown, NY | 1:59.97a |
| 35. | Vincent GangemiPlace 35. · Staten Island, NYUnofficial | — | Staten Island, NY | 2:00.63a |
| 36. | Tim RosenbaumPlace 36. · Grade 12 · GriswoldUnofficial | 12 | Griswold | 2:00.89a |
| 37. | Darell HandlerPlace 37. · Grade 12 · North ShoreUnofficial | 12 | North Shore | 2:01.07a PR |
| 38. | Warren LanePlace 38. · Brooklyn, NYUnofficial | — | Brooklyn, NY | 2:01.54a |
| 39. | Bobby OnyeukwuPlace 39. · Atlanta, GAUnofficial | — | Atlanta, GA | 2:01.77a |
| 40. | Corey JordanPlace 40. · Grade 11 · StarkvilleUnofficial | 11 | Starkville | 2:02.28a PR |
| 41. | Kevin LewisPlace 41. · Brooklyn, NYUnofficial | — | Brooklyn, NY | 2:02.49a |
| 42. | John GammarielloPlace 42. · Grade 12 · Palmyra-MacedonUnofficial | 12 | Palmyra-Macedon | 2:02.55a PR |
| 43. | Ralton BrownPlace 43. · Grade 12 · Poly (Long Beach)Unofficial | 12 | Poly (Long Beach) | 2:02.61a PR |
| 44. | Lloyd FosterPlace 44. · Grade 11 · DeMatha CatholicUnofficial | 11 | DeMatha Catholic | 2:02.88a |
| 45. | Knight KevinPlace 45. · Queens, NYUnofficial | — | Queens, NY | 2:02.93a |
| 46. | Desmond WinterPlace 46. · Queens, NYUnofficial | — | Queens, NY | 2:02.96a |
| 47. | Dennis ScruggsPlace 47. · Grade 11 · BellportUnofficial | 11 | Bellport | 2:04.17a PR |
| 48. | christopher BufordPlace 48. · Bronx, NYUnofficial | — | Bronx, NY | 2:04.39a |
| 49. | Nick ColantounoPlace 49. · Grade 12 · Lincoln-Sudbury RegionalUnofficial | 12 | Lincoln-Sudbury Regional | 2:04.62a PR |
| 50. | Ty OlsonPlace 50. · Grade 12 · Maria CarrilloUnofficial | 12 | Maria Carrillo | 2:06.11a PR |
| 51. | Matt CainPlace 51. · Grade 11 · Brockport CentralUnofficial | 11 | Brockport Central | 2:06.38a PR |
| 52. | Brandon HillPlace 52. · Grade 10 · PeekskillUnofficial | 10 | Peekskill | 2:06.51a PR |
| 53. | Timond ChubbPlace 53. · Lithonia, GAUnofficial | — | Lithonia, GA | 2:15.57a |
| 54. | Dominique SeabrookPlace 54. · Grade 12 · LakewoodUnofficial | 12 | Lakewood | 2:17.59a PR |