| 1 | Brandon LoyerPlace 1 · Grade SR · Rose-Hulman | SR | Rose-Hulman | 4:25.04 |
| 2 | Andrew De JongPlace 2 · Grade SO · Washington U. | SO | Washington U. | 4:30.09 |
| 3 | Joseph DrabotPlace 3 · Grade SO · Bellarmine | SO | Bellarmine | 4:33.57 |
| 4 | Vince StephenPlace 4 · Grade SR · Washington U. | SR | Washington U. | 4:33.64 |
| 5 | Frederik ErnstPlace 5 · Grade FR · Mississippi College | FR | Mississippi College | 4:35.73 |
| 6 | Steve SkydelPlace 6 · Grade FR · Washington U. | FR | Washington U. | 4:38.12 |
| 7 | Jonah WoodsPlace 7 · Grade SO · Wabash | SO | Wabash | 4:40.45 |
| 8 | Andrew BrakePlace 8 · Grade SO · Wabash | SO | Wabash | 4:43.13 |
| 9 | Charles StatlerPlace 9 · Grade JR · Rose-Hulman | JR | Rose-Hulman | 4:43.88 |
| 10 | Carter WhalenPlace 10 · Grade FR · Bellarmine | FR | Bellarmine | 4:49.02 |
| 1 | Zac ChristensenPlace 1 · Grade FR · Washington U. | FR | Washington U. | 4:31.90 |
| 2 | Chris BlaggPlace 2 · Grade FR · Washington U. | FR | Washington U. | 4:38.25 |
| 3 | Thomas FruhaufPlace 3 · Grade FR · Washington U. | FR | Washington U. | 4:42.24 |
| 4 | Kevin WuestPlace 4 · Grade FR · Rose-Hulman | FR | Rose-Hulman | 4:49.97 |
| 5 | Daniel FeltisPlace 5 · Grade FR · Wabash | FR | Wabash | 4:53.56 |
| 6 | Kyle SpraguePlace 6 · Grade JR · Transylvania | JR | Transylvania | 4:54.75 |
| 7 | Cameron ConnPlace 7 · Grade SO · Rose-Hulman | SO | Rose-Hulman | 4:58.63 |
| 8 | Robbie WunderlichPlace 8 · Grade SO · Wabash | SO | Wabash | 5:02.61 |