| 1 | Dominic StrohPlace 1 · Shippensburg | — | Shippensburg | 4:17.63I |
| 2 | Sean WeidnerPlace 2 · Lock Haven | — | Lock Haven | 4:17.78 |
| 3 | Mike KolorPlace 3 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:18.97 |
| 4 | John KirnaPlace 4 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 4:23.08 |
| 5 | Mikael HausePlace 5 · Misericordia | — | Misericordia | 4:23.46 |
| 6 | Zachary WilliamsPlace 6 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 4:24.02 |
| 7 | Zach TramaPlace 7 · Elizabethtow | — | Elizabethtow | 4:24.10 |
| 8 | Chad SussmanPlace 8 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 4:25.59 |
| 9 | Adam HarrigerPlace 9 · Elizabethtow | — | Elizabethtow | 4:26.43 |
| 10 | Santo BellePlace 10 · Seton Hill | — | Seton Hill | 4:27.42 |
| 11 | Eric HeatwolePlace 11 · Bloomsburg | — | Bloomsburg | 4:28.50 |
| 12 | Mitchell CoakleyPlace 12 · Lock Haven | — | Lock Haven | 4:28.62 |
| 13 | Naeb MengisteabPlace 13 · Kutztown | — | Kutztown | 4:28.78 |
| 14 | William ChandlerPlace 14 · Dickinson | — | Dickinson | 4:28.88 |
| 15 | Jake PlachkoPlace 15 · Bloomsburg | — | Bloomsburg | 4:29.46 |
| 16 | Josh CoakleyPlace 16 · West Chester | — | West Chester | 4:29.51 |
| 17 | Matthew TaddeoPlace 17 · Bucknell | — | Bucknell | 4:30.04 |
| 18 | Scott DavernPlace 18 · Lock Haven | — | Lock Haven | 4:30.05 |
| 19 | James WilsonPlace 19 · Bloomsburg | — | Bloomsburg | 4:30.74 |
| 20 | Colin EberhardtPlace 20 · Susquehanna | — | Susquehanna | 4:33.57 |
| 21 | Nate PardoePlace 21 · Messiah | — | Messiah | 4:33.97 |
| 22 | Jonphilip McGillPlace 22 · S.W.I.F.T. r | — | S.W.I.F.T. r | 4:34.19 |
| 23 | Connor HolmPlace 23 · Shippensburg | — | Shippensburg | 4:34.58 |
| 24 | Brandon HolveckPlace 24 · Unattached | — | Unattached | 4:38.34 |
| 25 | Killian McNallyPlace 25 · Pitt.-Johnst | — | Pitt.-Johnst | 4:39.22 |
| 26 | Andrew LeskoPlace 26 · Elizabethtow | — | Elizabethtow | 4:40.22 |
| 27 | Trever ReedPlace 27 · Misericordia | — | Misericordia | 4:40.35 |
| 28 | Michael LewisPlace 28 · Lock Haven | — | Lock Haven | 4:41.58 |
| 29 | Dmytro KunstbeckPlace 29 · Juniata | — | Juniata | 4:42.09 |
| 30 | Patrick NolanPlace 30 · Dickinson | — | Dickinson | 4:43.27 |
| 31 | Zachary MoodyPlace 31 · Misericordia | — | Misericordia | 4:43.70 |
| 32 | Jonathan BuytenhuysPlace 32 · Lock Haven | — | Lock Haven | 4:44.13 |
| 33 | Darren LabenbergPlace 33 · Elizabethtow | — | Elizabethtow | 4:44.22 |
| 34 | Nick AngelinaPlace 34 · West Chester | — | West Chester | 4:44.98 |
| 35 | Eli LauePlace 35 · Dickinson | — | Dickinson | 4:45.08 |
| 36 | Ben MartinPlace 36 · Juniata | — | Juniata | 4:46.50 |
| 37 | Kyle ZenchakPlace 37 · Pitt.-Johnst | — | Pitt.-Johnst | 4:47.39 |
| 38 | James HorwatPlace 38 · Pitt.-Johnst | — | Pitt.-Johnst | 4:48.49 |
| 39 | Adam BarleyPlace 39 · Messiah | — | Messiah | 4:49.95 |
| 40 | William McCarthyPlace 40 · Dickinson | — | Dickinson | 5:00.24 |
| 41 | Alex BensleyPlace 41 · Dickinson | — | Dickinson | 5:06.37 |
| 42 | Kadeem WillisPlace 42 · Psu-Harrisbu | — | Psu-Harrisbu | 5:10.45 |
| 43 | Justin DeLuzioPlace 43 · Gwynedd-Merc | — | Gwynedd-Merc | 5:16.65 |
| 44 | Connor HouseknechtPlace 44 · Misericordia | — | Misericordia | 5:17.31 |
