| 1. | Kenya GastonPlace 1. · Grade Sr · Temple | Sr | Temple | 40.32a PR |
| 2. | Nia LundyPlace 2. · Grade 12 · New Horizon Track | 12 | New Horizon Track | 40.62a |
| 3. | Shantal RousePlace 3. · Grade Fr · Kingsborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Kingsborough (N.Y.) CC | 40.90a PR |
| 4. | Niasia BoonePlace 4. · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 41.12a PR |
| 5. | Kathy Ann CadetPlace 5. · Grade Sr · Manhattan University | Sr | Manhattan University | 41.38a PR |
| 6. | Kenya HymanPlace 6. · Grade So · Wagner | So | Wagner | 41.42a PR |
| 7. | Miracle NwobuPlace 7. · Grade So · Wagner | So | Wagner | 41.44a |
| 8. | J'Renda RiveraPlace 8. · Grade Jr · St. Francis Brooklyn (Athletics Ended 2023) | Jr | St. Francis Brooklyn (Athletics Ended 2023) | 41.57a PR |
| 9. | T'reyah JohnsonPlace 9. · Grade Fr · LIU | Fr | LIU | 41.61a PR |
| 10. | Madison BeecherPlace 10. · Grade Fr · Temple | Fr | Temple | 41.89a |
| 11. | Sarah GottschalkPlace 11. · Grade Jr · Bloomsburg | Jr | Bloomsburg | 42.09a PR |
| 12. | Keyanna MillerPlace 12. · Grade Jr · Medgar Evers | Jr | Medgar Evers | 42.18a PR |
| 13. | Jimmia McCluskeyPlace 13. · Grade Sr · Temple | Sr | Temple | 42.22a PR |
| 14. | Imani PetersonPlace 14. · Grade Fr · Temple | Fr | Temple | 42.35a PR |
| 15. | Deja JohnsonPlace 15. · Grade So · LIU | So | LIU | 42.43a PR |
| 16. | Ashley HaynesPlace 16. · Grade Sr · Marist | Sr | Marist | 42.56a PR |
| 17. | Alyssa BarthelmesPlace 17. · Grade Sr · Bloomsburg | Sr | Bloomsburg | 42.75a PR |
| 18. | Ohunene AlbertPlace 18. · Grade Fr · Saint Peter's | Fr | Saint Peter's | 42.79a |
| 19. | Ashe DavisPlace 19. · Grade Jr · Saint Peter's | Jr | Saint Peter's | 42.83a PR |
| 20. | Sophia DowneyPlace 20. · Grade - · Northwood Athletic Club | - | Northwood Athletic Club | 42.92a PR |
| 21. | Dayzondra GonzalezPlace 21. · Grade So · Manhattan University | So | Manhattan University | 43.08a PR |
| 22. | Kaylie WessbergPlace 22. · Grade Fr · Georgian Court | Fr | Georgian Court | 43.09a PR |
| 23. | Carolina HerreraPlace 23. · Grade Jr · Saint Peter's | Jr | Saint Peter's | 43.23a PR |
| 24. | Ana Ordonez-RatamarPlace 24. · Grade Fr · Manhattan University | Fr | Manhattan University | 43.34a PR |
| 25. | Daija KingPlace 25. · Grade Jr · Saint Peter's | Jr | Saint Peter's | 43.40a PR |
| 26. | Crystal JonesPlace 26. · Grade So · Temple | So | Temple | 43.47a PR |
| 27. | Sydnee JacquesPlace 27. · Grade Jr · Temple | Jr | Temple | 43.69a PR |
| 28. | Kianna TidballPlace 28. · Grade Sr · Holy Family (Pa.) | Sr | Holy Family (Pa.) | 43.96a PR |
| 29. | Brianna HoffmanPlace 29. · Grade Jr · Wagner | Jr | Wagner | 43.99a |
| 30. | Gabrielle FrancoisPlace 30. · Grade Sr · Montclair State | Sr | Montclair State | 44.05a PR |
| 31. | Shavel BrownPlace 31. · Grade So · Wagner | So | Wagner | 44.06a PR |
| 32. | Kijara ClinePlace 32. · Grade - · New Horizon Track | - | New Horizon Track | 44.27a PR |
| 33. | Melanie TrinkwaldPlace 33. · Grade Sr · Wagner | Sr | Wagner | 44.27a PR |
| 34. | Lauren RiveraPlace 34. · Grade Jr · Bloomsburg | Jr | Bloomsburg | 44.31a PR |
| 35. | Alexandria OkonPlace 35. · Grade Fr · LIU Post | Fr | LIU Post | 44.33a PR |
| 36. | Nicolette AgostinacchioPlace 36. · Grade Fr · LIU Post | Fr | LIU Post | 44.37a PR |
| 37. | Keisha WhaleyPlace 37. · Grade Fr · Holy Family (Pa.) | Fr | Holy Family (Pa.) | 44.49a PR |
| 38. | Kim JelichPlace 38. · Grade So · Manhattan University | So | Manhattan University | 44.87a |
| 39. | jessica sanchezPlace 39. · Unattached | — | Unattached | 45.06a |
| 40. | Re'ona PettwayPlace 40. · Grade Fr · Temple | Fr | Temple | 45.16a PR |
| 41. | Jade ChungPlace 41. · Grade So · St. Francis Brooklyn (Athletics Ended 2023) | So | St. Francis Brooklyn (Athletics Ended 2023) | 45.21a PR |
| 42. | Achaia PierrePlace 42. · Grade Sr · Holy Family (Pa.) | Sr | Holy Family (Pa.) | 45.21a PR |
| 43. | Suzenie St. GermainPlace 43. · Grade So · Saint Peter's | So | Saint Peter's | 45.22a PR |
| 44. | Ces ColemanPlace 44. · Grade Sr · Holy Family (Pa.) | Sr | Holy Family (Pa.) | 45.27a PR |
| 45. | Alisha SingletonPlace 45. · Grade Sr · Rutgers-Camden | Sr | Rutgers-Camden | 45.90a PR |
| 46. | Carnasia MckelveyPlace 46. · Grade Fr · Medgar Evers | Fr | Medgar Evers | 46.22a PR |
| 47. | Ashara MitchelPlace 47. · Grade Fr · St. Francis Brooklyn (Athletics Ended 2023) | Fr | St. Francis Brooklyn (Athletics Ended 2023) | 46.28a PR |
| 48. | Janelle McPhersonPlace 48. · Grade Fr · Holy Family (Pa.) | Fr | Holy Family (Pa.) | 46.28a |
| 49. | Tanisha WitterPlace 49. · Grade Fr · Kingsborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Kingsborough (N.Y.) CC | 46.61a PR |
| 50. | Mary Pierre LouisPlace 50. · Grade Fr · Montclair State | Fr | Montclair State | 46.72a PR |
| 51. | Arianna TeaguePlace 51. · Grade So · Wagner | So | Wagner | 46.82a PR |
| 52. | Sylvia ZawistowskaPlace 52. · Grade Fr · Montclair State | Fr | Montclair State | 46.89a PR |
| 53. | Shontiana ButcherPlace 53. · Grade So · Rutgers-Camden | So | Rutgers-Camden | 46.99a PR |
| 54. | Ali JohnsonPlace 54. · Grade Jr · Manhattanville | Jr | Manhattanville | 47.01a PR |
| 55. | Victoria TinelliPlace 55. · Grade Fr · Manhattanville | Fr | Manhattanville | 47.03a PR |
| 56. | Sara StebbingsPlace 56. · Grade Sr · LIU Post | Sr | LIU Post | 47.03a PR |
| 57. | Simone ChapmanPlace 57. · Grade Sr · Temple | Sr | Temple | 47.05a PR |
| 58. | Aaliyah WilliamsPlace 58. · Grade So · St. Francis Brooklyn (Athletics Ended 2023) | So | St. Francis Brooklyn (Athletics Ended 2023) | 47.12a PR |
| 59. | Hayley RichBartPlace 59. · Grade Jr · Molloy | Jr | Molloy | 47.16a PR |
| 60. | Erykah KamalPlace 60. · Grade Fr · LIU Post | Fr | LIU Post | 47.39a PR |
| 61. | Malory RathonPlace 61. · Grade Fr · Kingsborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Kingsborough (N.Y.) CC | 47.54a PR |
| 62. | Rashel AndersonPlace 62. · Grade So · Medgar Evers | So | Medgar Evers | 47.82a PR |
| 63. | Joba OdediranPlace 63. · Grade Fr · Montclair State | Fr | Montclair State | 47.88a PR |
| 64. | Chloe MargulisPlace 64. · Grade Sr · LIU Post | Sr | LIU Post | 47.88a PR |
| 65. | Marialaura ReyPlace 65. · Grade Sr · Montclair State | Sr | Montclair State | 48.17a PR |
| 66. | Tiffany WilliamsPlace 66. · Grade Fr · Montclair State | Fr | Montclair State | 48.44a PR |
| 67. | Victoria St. JohnPlace 67. · Grade Fr · Saint Peter's | Fr | Saint Peter's | 49.58a |
| 68. | O'Garro JeffaniePlace 68. · Grade So · Medgar Evers | So | Medgar Evers | 50.83a PR |
| 69. | Dominique SwainPlace 69. · Grade Jr · Montclair State | Jr | Montclair State | 52.47a PR |
| 70. | Brianna BoyerPlace 70. · Grade Jr · Montclair State | Jr | Montclair State | 54.34a |
| 71. | Kylah ThomasPlace 71. · Grade Fr · Kingsborough (N.Y.) CC | Fr | Kingsborough (N.Y.) CC | 56.41a PR |
| 72. | Mina KrastoshevskyPlace 72. · Grade Fr · St. Francis Brooklyn (Athletics Ended 2023) | Fr | St. Francis Brooklyn (Athletics Ended 2023) | 59.82a PR |