| 1. | Tevin MahlstadtPlace 1. · Grade 10 · Baldwin | 10 | Baldwin | 1:41.34a PR |
| 2. | Cara DuffyPlace 2. · Grade 11 · Island Trees | 11 | Island Trees | 1:46.57a PR |
| 3. | Rachel RosePlace 3. · Grade 12 · East Meadow | 12 | East Meadow | 1:47.05a |
| 4. | Megan ReillyPlace 4. · Grade 10 · Manhasset | 10 | Manhasset | 1:48.02a PR |
| 5. | Madison SohlPlace 5. · Grade 12 · East Meadow | 12 | East Meadow | 1:49.72a |
| 6. | Juliana SimsPlace 6. · Grade 10 · Manhasset | 10 | Manhasset | 1:50.52a PR |
| 7. | MaryGrace CollPlace 7. · Grade 8 · Island Trees | 8 | Island Trees | 1:50.61a |
| 8. | Emmie KeysPlace 8. · Grade 9 · Wheatley | 9 | Wheatley | 1:51.35a |
| 9. | Alexandra MidgettePlace 9. · Grade 11 · Bethpage | 11 | Bethpage | 1:51.51a |
| 10. | Nicole JosephPlace 10. · Grade 12 · New Hyde Park Memorial | 12 | New Hyde Park Memorial | 1:52.19a |
| 11. | Kelly OngPlace 11. · Grade 10 · Plainedge | 10 | Plainedge | 1:52.38a |
| 12. | Madeline HonPlace 12. · Grade 11 · Manhasset | 11 | Manhasset | 1:52.89a |
| 13. | Chidima AdamsPlace 13. · Grade 12 · Baldwin | 12 | Baldwin | 1:53.17a PR |
| 14. | Katherine KirkwoodPlace 14. · Grade 9 · Manhasset | 9 | Manhasset | 1:53.84a |
| 15. | Chloe MantisPlace 15. · Grade 10 · Manhasset | 10 | Manhasset | 1:54.21a PR |
| 16. | Sydney GinsburgPlace 16. · Grade 11 · Manhasset | 11 | Manhasset | 1:54.83a PR |
| 17. | Michela RutiglianoPlace 17. · Grade 11 · Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 11 | Oyster Bay-East Norwich | 1:55.16a |
| 18. | Naisha BatsonPlace 18. · Grade 12 · Uniondale | 12 | Uniondale | 1:57.16a PR |
| 19. | Efe OmokeniPlace 19. · Grade 11 · Freeport | 11 | Freeport | 1:57.30a PR |
| 20. | Janiya CookePlace 20. · Grade 11 · Freeport | 11 | Freeport | 1:57.63a PR |
| 21. | Cantee CowanPlace 21. · Grade 10 · Freeport | 10 | Freeport | 1:58.42a PR |
| 22. | Beradgy FortunePlace 22. · Grade 11 · Baldwin | 11 | Baldwin | 2:00.05a PR |
| 23. | Isabelle LopezPlace 23. · Grade 12 · New Hyde Park Memorial | 12 | New Hyde Park Memorial | 2:06.15a |
| 24. | Aniejah HamiltonPlace 24. · Grade 9 · New Hyde Park Memorial | 9 | New Hyde Park Memorial | 2:06.17a |
| 25. | Eliza TriestePlace 25. · Grade 10 · Manhasset | 10 | Manhasset | 2:06.76a |
| 26. | Erin DamianiPlace 26. · Grade 12 · Plainedge | 12 | Plainedge | 2:06.86a |
| 27. | Cameran ZedalisPlace 27. · Grade 9 · Plainedge | 9 | Plainedge | 2:07.07a |
| 28. | Maricelys FloresPlace 28. · Grade 12 · East Meadow | 12 | East Meadow | 2:08.47a PR |
| 29. | Tara ColonelPlace 29. · Grade 9 · Plainedge | 9 | Plainedge | 2:08.75a |
| 30. | Ashley PredvilPlace 30. · Grade 10 · New Hyde Park Memorial | 10 | New Hyde Park Memorial | 2:08.95a |
| 31. | Allison CorcoranPlace 31. · Grade 9 · New Hyde Park Memorial | 9 | New Hyde Park Memorial | 2:09.98a |
| 32. | Brianna JimenezPlace 32. · Grade 11 · East Meadow | 11 | East Meadow | 2:10.01a PR |
| 33. | Rachel ZweigPlace 33. · Grade 10 · John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 10 | John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 2:10.22a |
| 34. | Aniyah JacksonPlace 34. · Grade 8 · Uniondale | 8 | Uniondale | 2:10.64a PR |
| 35. | Madison OlsonPlace 35. · Grade 9 · Plainedge | 9 | Plainedge | 2:13.01a PR |
| 36. | Corinne HaneyPlace 36. · Grade 10 · Bethpage | 10 | Bethpage | 2:13.85a PR |
| 37. | Justine ChoiPlace 37. · Grade 9 · John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 9 | John F Kennedy (Plainview) | 2:14.27a PR |
| 38. | Alexis PaulPlace 38. · Grade 9 · New Hyde Park Memorial | 9 | New Hyde Park Memorial | 2:14.62a PR |
| 39. | Alexandra GatelyPlace 39. · Grade 11 · General Douglas Macarthur | 11 | General Douglas Macarthur | 2:14.71a |
| 40. | Rachel VerschellPlace 40. · Grade 9 · Bethpage | 9 | Bethpage | 2:17.27a |