| 1. | Marrone MattPlace 1. · Grade 12 · Valley Stream North | 12 | Valley Stream North | 4:38.92a |
| 2. | Oliver Melara-PerezPlace 2. · Grade 11 · Paul D Schreiber | 11 | Paul D Schreiber | 4:41.93a |
| 3. | Colin FunkPlace 3. · Grade 10 · Paul D Schreiber | 10 | Paul D Schreiber | 4:43.20a |
| 4. | Kevin TaylorPlace 4. · Grade 10 · Paul D Schreiber | 10 | Paul D Schreiber | 4:43.88a |
| 5. | Vincent SimonettiPlace 5. · Grade 11 · Massapequa | 11 | Massapequa | 4:44.81a |
| 6. | Christian CiciliaPlace 6. · Grade 12 · Valley Stream North | 12 | Valley Stream North | 4:48.78a |
| 7. | Matthew ScardignoPlace 7. · Grade 11 · Paul D Schreiber | 11 | Paul D Schreiber | 4:49.11a |
| 8. | Jariq McNabPlace 8. · Grade 10 · Freeport | 10 | Freeport | 4:52.67a |
| 9. | Jack LasallaPlace 9. · Grade 12 · Garden City | 12 | Garden City | 4:53.80a |
| 10. | Noah LoewyPlace 10. · Grade 11 · Paul D Schreiber | 11 | Paul D Schreiber | 4:54.56a |
| 11. | John SchwabPlace 11. · Grade 10 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 10 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 4:57.06a |
| 12. | Evan MillerPlace 12. · Grade 12 · Valley Stream South | 12 | Valley Stream South | 4:57.58a PR |
| 13. | Alexander RosarioPlace 13. · Grade 10 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 10 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 4:59.21a |
| 14. | Aidan KopelmanPlace 14. · Grade 10 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 10 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 4:59.25a PR |
| 15. | Sam GodsonPlace 15. · Grade 12 · Long Beach | 12 | Long Beach | 5:01.29a |
| 16. | Alexander MartucciPlace 16. · Grade 10 · WC Mepham | 10 | WC Mepham | 5:01.37a |
| 17. | Dominic SaraciniPlace 17. · Grade 9 · WC Mepham | 9 | WC Mepham | 5:01.46a |
| 18. | Sean WildePlace 18. · Grade 11 · Massapequa | 11 | Massapequa | 5:02.64a |
| 19. | William LanePlace 19. · Grade 10 · Paul D Schreiber | 10 | Paul D Schreiber | 5:04.87a |
| 20. | Zach RagozinoPlace 20. · Grade 11 · Friends Academy | 11 | Friends Academy | 5:04.99a |
| 21. | Amokrane AouchichePlace 21. · Grade 10 · WC Mepham | 10 | WC Mepham | 5:06.12a |
| 22. | Nathan AranoffPlace 22. · Grade 11 · Paul D Schreiber | 11 | Paul D Schreiber | 5:06.41a |
| 23. | Logan BaderPlace 23. · Grade 11 · Sanford H. Calhoun | 11 | Sanford H. Calhoun | 5:07.33a |
| 24. | Matthew LeoPlace 24. · Grade 11 · Valley Stream North | 11 | Valley Stream North | 5:08.56a |
| 25. | Thomas SiatsisPlace 25. · Grade 10 · Valley Stream North | 10 | Valley Stream North | 5:08.72a |
| 26. | Terrence McGintyPlace 26. · Grade 10 · Paul D Schreiber | 10 | Paul D Schreiber | 5:09.68a |
| 27. | Noel BonillaPlace 27. · Grade 10 · Roosevelt (LI) | 10 | Roosevelt (LI) | 5:13.22a PR |
| 28. | Jack SchwabePlace 28. · Grade 10 · Valley Stream North | 10 | Valley Stream North | 5:14.47a |
| 29. | Maxwell MeehanPlace 29. · Grade 10 · Paul D Schreiber | 10 | Paul D Schreiber | 5:15.33a |
| 30. | Danzil MonkPlace 30. · Grade 9 · Freeport | 9 | Freeport | 5:16.58a |
| 31. | Jeremy SilbergPlace 31. · Grade 11 · Paul D Schreiber | 11 | Paul D Schreiber | 5:16.76a PR |
| 32. | Jeuri Lopez-LamarPlace 32. · Grade 10 · Freeport | 10 | Freeport | 5:21.16a PR |
| 33. | Brenden DebrossePlace 33. · Grade 10 · Massapequa | 10 | Massapequa | 5:23.83a |
| 34. | Bryan CarbajalPlace 34. · Grade 10 · Freeport | 10 | Freeport | 5:50.64a |